page 129 1 Yesterday when I started, I think I was just 2 introducing Mr. Garber, the Commissioner of Major League 3 Soccer, who is here with us again this morning, and I just 4 want to continue on first with my introductions. 5 Next to Mr. Garber is Mark Abbott. Mark, if you 6 could stand. Mr. Abbott is the league's chief operating 7 officer. His job was to create MLS along with 8 Mr. Rothenberg and others, and he's been working at MLS ever 9 since trying to make it a success. 10 Next to Mr. Abbott is Ivan Gazidis, the league's 11 executive vice president, and Mr. Gazidis' job is to 12 negotiate and hopefully hire MLS players and persuade them 13 that MLS is the place to be and to sign them to contracts 14 within the budget guidelines set by the league. 15 Now, as Judge O'Toole told you yesterday, an 16 opening statement, such as the one I'm giving, is sort of an 17 outline of a jigsaw puzzle. And I say this because a trial, 18 I think, is like a puzzle. You get lots of pieces from the 19 witness stand and from documents, and then when you 20 deliberate, you put all those pieces together. And before 21 you deliberate, Mr. Kessler and I will stand up and give you 22 our closing statements and tell you why we think the pieces 23 should be put together in a particular way. 24 But this morning what I want to do is give you the 25 outline of that puzzle, or at least the outline as we think page 130 1 it should be seen, and I think after you hear that outline 2 and then see the pieces and when you put those pieces 3 together, you'll see that MLS did absolutely nothing wrong. 4 Now, as the Judge also told you yesterday, the 5 opening statements of counsel are not evidence. They're 6 just arguments. The evidence is the documents and the 7 witnesses that you're going to hear and see, and this is a 8 very, very important point to remember because as I outline 9 the way MLS sees the evidence, sees what the evidence will 10 be, I think you'll hear that a great deal of what 11 Mr. Kessler told you yesterday simply is not correct. 12 Now, Mr. Kessler told you that documents don't lie. 13 Well, that may be, but when you take snippets out of 14 context, you can gain a very different impression of what 15 the truth is. And what you have to do is listen to the 16 witnesses and look at the full text of the documents, and 17 I'm confident that when you do that, you'll see that the 18 documents don't suggest at all this conspiracy, this 19 diabolical plan, Mr. Kessler talked about. And the argument 20 charts, those charts that Mr. Kessler put up, are just 21 arguments and sometimes made-up arguments, not based on 22 fact. 23 Now, one of the things that Mr. Kessler didn't tell 24 you is exactly what the real issue in this case is. Let me 25 answer that. page 131 1 This case is about one question and one question 2 only: Was it improper for the United States Soccer 3 Federation to designate Major League Soccer as the only 4 Division~I major league soccer league in this country for 5 two years? 6 The decision to designate one league, and that 7 league to be MLS, was made in December of 1993 on a 8 provisional basis, and then in 1995, MLS was given that 9 designation on an exclusive basis for only two years. 10 Now, you will hear in the course of a trial a lot 11 of other things, a lot of other statements, a lot of other 12 actions. But, ultimately, the question, the question you 13 have to ask yourself, is whether the decision to designate 14 only MLS for two years as the Division~I soccer league in 15 this country, whether there was anything improper about it. 16 Now, in talking about whether there should have 17 been two Division~I leagues, Mr. Kessler didn't tell you 18 that in every single country of the world where soccer is 19 played on a professional major basis, there is only one 20 division soccer league. 21 Now, plaintiffs are claiming here that for some 22 reason in the United States where we have one major league 23 baseball -- one league for major league baseball and one 24 league for major league basketball and one league for major 25 league football and one league for major league hockey, and page 132 1 where in this country we have failed -- the history in 2 soccer has failed over and over again, Mr. Kessler didn't 3 explain you to why there should be two leagues for soccer in 4 the United States. 5 Now, let me summarize very briefly, and I'm going 6 to go into it in my opening, what the evidence is going to 7 show on the decisions that are in question. 8 The first question: Should there be one league? 9 The evidence will show you that after an exhaustive 10 and very, very fair process, over 20 neutral members of the 11 board of directors of the USSF, the Soccer Federation, 12 concludes that there was simply not enough fans, sponsors, 13 television partners, to support two Division~I leagues in 14 this country. 15 Those board members, after hearing all the facts, 16 concluded that if there were two Division I leagues rather 17 than one, the competition that the two leagues would have 18 against one another would simply put each other out of 19 business. And the result would be another failed effort to 20 establish a major soccer league in this country. 21 And so they decided that there should be only one 22 league for a two-year period. 23 Now, Mr. Kessler would have you believe that if 24 there were two leagues, the players would have been paid 25 more. Wrong. In the five years that MLS has existed, it's page 133 1 lost $250 million, real money. 2 Now, the investors believe in the long run they're 3 going to succeed, but today, seven years after the decision 4 that's being sued upon here, there are not enough fans, not 5 enough television support, not enough sponsors to support 6 one successful Division~I league, let alone two. 7 Now, most of the morning yesterday you heard about 8 this so-called conspiracy, and Mr. Kessler suggested to you 9 that this rival league, this APSL, should have been given a 10 Division~I certification. 11 What Mr. Kessler didn't tell you is that the APSL 12 plan was, frankly, a joke. It was based on nothing more 13 than unsubstantiated hope by a league that in the last three 14 years had seen 15 of its 22 franchises fold, go out of 15 business. 16 Now, Mr. Kessler didn't tell you also that the APSL 17 plan proposed that it would pay the players half, half of 18 what the MLS plan proposed. 19 Now, Mr. Kessler stood up and said $24,000 minimum 20 salary at MLS and how can someone live on $24,000? You know 21 what the APSL plan called for? It said that a third of the 22 players on the -- if the APSL had been the Division~I 23 league, a third of the players would have been paid on the 24 average $15,000. 25 I'm going to come back to that in a few minutes, page 134 1 but I first want to put this case in context, and since 2 we're in a political season and it's common for candidates 3 to say how did I do the last four years, I'd like to suggest 4 that you ask yourself a question throughout this trial: 5 Would the players have been better off with or without MLS? 6 Your Honor, with your permission, I'd like to put 7 that question up on the screen, if I may? 8 Now, once you have answered that question, I think 9 you will see there will be no basis to decide for the 10 plaintiffs. 11 Let me tell you some of the facts in connection 12 with this that Mr. Kessler didn't tell you about. 13 First, soccer is the most popular sport in the 14 entire world, much more popular than the NBA, football, 15 basketball, Major League Baseball. But in the United 16 States, professional soccer has simply failed. People don't 17 watch it. 18 You will hear from that witness stand that in 1995, 19 the year before MLS first started play, there was no 20 professional soccer league in this country. The most 21 popular sport in the world couldn't make it. The last 22 important major soccer league in this country had gone out 23 of business ten years earlier. And since then, no major 24 soccer league existed in this country. No league in which 25 the players could play, no league that soccer fans could page 135 1 watch. 2 3 Second fact: MLS is still a very, very fragile, 4 start-up company. It is fighting to gain fans and gain 5 advertisers, and so far it hasn't succeeded. It hopes it 6 will. 7 It succeeded in doing one thing. It has succeeded 8 in improving the prospects of the very people who have 9 brought this lawsuit, the soccer players. 10 Now, Mr. Kessler told you that because of this 11 conspiracy, because of this monopoly, that MLS has been 12 underpaying its players. Well, let's look at what the facts 13 are going to show. 14 In 1995, before MLS existed, if you were the very, 15 very best soccer player in this country and wanted to play 16 soccer in this country, you had to play in the minor 17 leagues, Division~II or Division~III, as they're referred 18 to. And the average salary for a player in the minor 19 leagues at that time was in the teens, less than $19,000. 20 Many teams it was even less for the average salary. 21 Today, today, the average salary for a player in 22 MLS is over $80,000, an amount that soccer players in this 23 country couldn't have dreamed of five years ago. And the 24 number of soccer players in this country playing for MLS who 25 are earning more than a hundred thousand has more than page 136 1 doubled in five years. 2 And despite the fact that MLS is having these 3 losses, the salaries it pays to its players has been going 4 up, although not as rapidly as the players would like. And 5 MLS has created 240 jobs for Major League Soccer players 6 that didn't exist before. 7 Now, let me say just a word about the figures, 8 $80,000 and so forth. 9 Mr. Kessler said to you yesterday that the average 10 MLS compensation was much less than $80,000. I don't know 11 where he got the numbers. Maybe he forgot to include the 12 signing bonus that most players -- that many players get. 13 But I'm confident that when you hear from our expert, a 14 noted economist at UCLA, that you'll conclude our numbers 15 are correct. We hope the $80,000 figure is going to go up, 16 but at the moment, MLS can't afford it. 17 Now, Mr. Kessler also didn't tell you that because 18 of MLS it has become possible for soccer players in this 19 country to showcase their talents to foreign teams which 20 have sat up and started to take notice. And those foreign 21 teams are now actively pursuing MLS players. 22 Teams from overseas regularly scout MLS games. MLS 23 players, you will hear from that witness stand, regularly 24 receive job offers from foreign soccer teams, sometimes for 25 compensation much, much more than MLS can afford to pay. page 137 1 But, of course, to meet the foreign competition, 2 and as people like Mr. Gazidis will tell from you that 3 witness stand, MLS has no choice but to do the best it can 4 to increase it's salaries so it can hold on to these players 5 and make sure the fans will see the highest quality soccer 6 possible. 7 Now, Mr. Kessler yesterday minimized these 8 international opportunities, he called them. I think he 9 said at one point only eight MLS players really had 10 international opportunities. Well, let me just give you one 11 little anecdote: In the last 12 months, the evidence will 12 show, MLS found it necessary to, in effect, tear up the 13 contracts it had with over 70 players, nearly one-third of 14 all of MLS's contracts, MLS had to say we have to 15 renegotiate. 16 And MLS voluntarily agreed to pay those players 17 more money than it had to under the contracts. Why didn't 18 Mr. Kessler tell you this? 19 The MLS witnesses are going to tell you that the 20 reason they did that, the reason they had to renegotiate the 21 contracts, was because it had to do something to keep those 22 players in this country, to meet the foreign competition. 23 And thanks to MLS, the players' salaries and compensation 24 have increased. They've gotten better health benefits. 25 They have better stadiums in which to play, and they have page 138 1 better coaching. 2 And it's not just the players who have benefitted 3 from MLS. The fans are beneficiaries, too, unfortunately 4 not yet as many fans as we would like. 5 Because of MLS, the evidence will show, soccer fans 6 now have affordable, professional major league games to go 7 to with their children. Advertisers have other sports to 8 watch on television, to endorse on television. Internet 9 broadcast television stations have another product that they 10 can latch onto. The people who buy -- who make t-shirts and 11 hats have another product that they can put a logo on. None 12 of this was true five years ago. 13 There's a new competitor, a very small one, but a 14 new competitor in the sports marketplace along with major 15 league baseball, football, basketball, hockey and so forth. 16 Now, the plaintiffs seem to forget that MLS has 17 done this. And they seem to forget the benefits that MLS 18 has conferred on both them and the fans. 19 Now, they also ignore another fact: MLS has done a 20 lot of good things for the players and the fans but hasn't 21 done so well for itself. 22 Now, Mr. Kessler told you that this big, bad 23 monopolist, MLS, did something wrong. Well, between the 24 time MLS was created and 1999, MLS's losses, total losses, 25 MLS and its investors, were about $200 million, as you can page 139 1 see from this chart, 200 million. 2 Unfortunately, the projection taking it through 3 this year when we obviously don't have final figures 4 available, is it's going to reach $250 million, a quarter of 5 a billion dollars of actual losses. Not fancy writeoffs or 6 tax gimmicks; real losses. Money spent on players' 7 salaries, advertising, stadium leases, office employees and 8 so forth. It dwarfs -- these expenses in total dwarf the 9 revenue MLS gets. 10 Now, Mr. Kessler, for some reason, suggested that 11 this chart would mislead you. I'm confident when you hear 12 the evidence that it is accurate. I stand by it. 13 Now, Mr. Kessler said also, speaking of misleading, 14 that the value of an MLS investment unit had increased from 15 $5 million to $20 million in five years. 16 Well, I'm sure Mr. Garber and the other people at 17 MLS wish that that were true, but the value of something is 18 what a willing buyer is willing to pay a willing seller. 19 And the evidence is there are simply not willing buyers 20 interested in paying anything close to what the MLS investor 21 has put into the enterprise. 22 The evidence will show -- not the argument but the 23 evidence will show -- that the original MLS investors have 24 invested in their investment and in the league as a whole in 25 the neighborhood of over $25 million. And the evidence will page 140 1 also show that the last offer for an ownership interest in 2 MLS was less than $10 million. And even at that price, MLS 3 was unable to close the deal. 4 MLS can't find a buyer willing to pay anything 5 close to what has been invested. 6 Now, MLS has existed, as I said, for five years. 7 Its success is by no means assured. Put out of your minds 8 the comparison to the NBA or the NFL or some other sports 9 leagues. MLS has nothing -- can't possibly be compared to 10 those leagues. 11 Those leagues we've all grown up with. There's a 12 fan base. People learn about it from the time they're five 13 or six years old. MLS has a tiny fan base. 14 The monies it receives from television are 15 miniscule. There is no comparison between the other sports 16 leagues. But the salaries have gone up. And the investors 17 have taken other steps to try to improve things. 18 For example, one of the MLS investors took 19 $25 million out of his own pocket and built a soccer 20 stadium, a soccer-specific stadium so his team that he was 21 an operator of would have a soccer-only stadium in which to 22 play. 23 Think about it. If a business is losing money and 24 its revenues are, at best, flat, what should it ordinarily 25 do? It should take steps to control costs. But the costs page 141 1 have gone up. Salaries have gone up because MLS had to 2 compete in the worldwide market for the best people it could 3 get. 4 Now, the plaintiffs say the increases aren't 5 enough. MLS should have paid them more money. And now, 6 they say, not only should they be paid more money, they 7 should get millions of dollars in damages. 8 Wealthy investors, and there may be some, don't 9 just throw money away. They have to see light at the end of 10 the tunnel. And have plaintiffs considered that at some 11 point these investors are going to say, Enough is enough. 12 I'm not willing to write any more checks, and will close the 13 league down. 14 It doesn't seem that the players have kept that in 15 mind. 16 One last thing Mr. Kessler forgot to emphasize: No 17 one forced the players to sign contracts with MLS. You saw 18 yesterday from the plaintiffs whose pictures Mr. Kessler put 19 before you that many of the MLS players are graduates from 20 some of the top colleges in the United States, Princeton, 21 Stanford, Duke, Virginia, UCLA. Now, the players chose to 22 play soccer for a living rather than pursuing a more 23 traditional career like you and me. And people who make 24 that choice know that in soccer, unlike baseball or 25 football, the best talent, the highest salaries, are often page 142 1 found outside of the United States. Plaintiffs' choice was 2 to play soccer, and MLS is delighted and very pleased that 3 they did so and that they decided to play soccer with MLS, 4 but the plaintiffs made that decision on their own, with 5 their eyes wide open. 6 Now, a lot of American players, the evidence will 7 show, made the opposite choice. They decided to play 8 abroad. 9 Now, surely the players, whom you will hear are 10 represented by sophisticated agents, knew that when they 11 signed a contract with MLS, it was a new, fragile start-up 12 league; that it would have to work hard to succeed. Some of 13 these plaintiffs, in fact, had worked for other soccer 14 leagues or teams that have gone out of business. 15 The players certainly knew that the success of MLS 16 was no means assured. 17 And surely they knew that if they were going to 18 pursue a career as a Division~I soccer player in this 19 country, that it would take time for MLS to build a fan base 20 and increase players' salaries. 21 Now, Mr. Kessler said, well, MLS suggests if we 22 can't play soccer, you should wash cars. Come on. We know 23 that these players, well-educated college graduates, have a 24 big choice between playing soccer and washing cars. 25 Finally, on sort of the context of this case before page 143 1 I talk about this so-called conspiracy, the players don't 2 tell you that if MLS is this big, bad monopolist, it 3 certainly hasn't shown on its effect on consumers, on people 4 like you whom the anti-trust laws are supposed to protect. 5 How has the consumer been hurt? Ticket prices, 6 television fees, sponsorship costs, they haven't increased. 7 If MLS is this big, bad monopolist, it's not doing a very 8 good job using that power very effectively. 9 Now let me get into some of the specifics of this 10 case and first to talk to you about this monopoly, this 11 alleged conspiracy. 12 Now, in order to understand that there was no 13 conspiracy and that the decision to certify one league and 14 to certify it -- to certify MLS as that league, that that 15 decision was absolutely proper. You have to use your common 16 sense, and, as we all learned in school, history is 17 sometimes a very good tool in helping one decide how to deal 18 with the future. 19 And so I want to talk about the history of soccer 20 in this country for a minute, a history that you're going to 21 hear from that witness stand. Because it is the lessons 22 that are taught by this history that explain the reasons 23 behind the decisions about which the players complain. 24 Some of you may have heard or read that between 25 1968 and 1984 there was another soccer league in this page 144 1 country. It was called the Northern American Soccer League, 2 NASL. 3 Now, Mr. Kessler said in his opening that he was 4 going to tell you about that league, but he didn't. That's 5 a very critical omission because that history of that league 6 lay at the forefront of why the USSF board decided the way 7 it did. 8 One of the teams in the NASL was a team called the 9 Cosmos. They were based in New York, and they signed 10 players with what were then astronomical salaries, and they 11 were able to hire some of the greater soccer players in the 12 world, such as Pele from Brazil, perhaps the greatest soccer 13 player of all time. 14 And the Cosmos were owned by a very large company, 15 a predecessor of Time-Warner, and they were very, very 16 successful, at least on the field. 17 They drew large crowds to Giants Stadium. They won 18 the league championship for a number of years, and you know 19 what happened? In 1984, the Cosmos and the rest of the NASL 20 went out of business. Why? You will hear the explanations 21 from the witness stand, and you will learn firsthand from 22 the people who were involved in the NASL, including some 23 people who end up being involved with MLS, such as 24 Mr. Rothenberg. And you will hear their views as to what 25 happened with the NASL and why that experience was so page 145 1 important to them. They will tell you that, in their view, 2 the NASL failed because given this tiny soccer audience in 3 this country, the other teams in the league couldn't keep up 4 with the Cosmos. Many of them tried to at the beginning and 5 tried to outspend each other to get Pele here and another 6 player there and so on. They joined the arms' race but they 7 couldn't compete with one another. 8 The quality of soccer started to go up as they 9 attracted these international superstars. But fan interest 10 didn't increase. The Cosmo gate receipts became higher and 11 higher relative to anybody else. And other teams which 12 didn't have the Time-Warners behind them began to lose 13 money. And then they tried to get better players so they 14 could compete with the Cosmos, and they lost more money and 15 more money and more money. 16 And so pretty soon the Cosmos were dominant, 17 absolutely dominant on the field. The other teams weren't 18 competitive. The teams literally spent themselves out of 19 existence. Fans lost interest. The Boston team, which very 20 appropriately was called the "Minutemen," existed for only 21 two years and folded. So did other teams. 22 In 1980, the NASL had 24 teams. Four years later, 23 it had nine. The next year, it had none. And then for ten 24 years, for ten years, there was no major soccer league in 25 this country. page 146 1 Now, the NASL teams fought vigorously with each 2 other for players. They paid top dollars for foreign stars, 3 and the result was failure. 4 The founders of MLS and the members of the USSF 5 board took all these facts into account when they were 6 deciding in 1993 whether there should be one team or two, 7 one league or two, and whether MLS should be that league. 8 Because this history showed that as of 1995, the year before 9 MLS began play, this country, although it has a -- 10 particularly this city, have a wonderful history of interest 11 in sports, be it the Red Sox, the Patriots or the Bruins or 12 the Celtics, it didn't seem that this country or this city 13 could support professional soccer. Fan interest wasn't 14 there. 15 16 Now, I want to say a word about FIFA that 17 Mr. Kessler talked to you about. That's the international 18 federation that governs soccer on a worldwide basis. 19 They didn't want to give up, and neither did other 20 people like Mr. Rothenberg, who love the game of soccer in 21 this country and believe that some day, some day, if you did 22 it right, soccer on the professional basis could succeed. 23 And so very appropriately, July 4, 1988, four years 24 after the Northern American Soccer League went out of 25 business, FIFA said, We're going to grant the World Cup, the page 147 1 most prestigious soccer tournament in the world, we're going 2 to grant the World Cup to the United States in 1994. 3 Now, that is the international tournament. It's 4 held every four years, and the championship game in that 5 tournament is watched by over a billion people on 6 television, ten times more than watch the Superbowl. The 7 World Cup tournament decides which country has the best 8 soccer team in the world. 9 Now, when FIFA gave the United States this right to 10 host the World Cup, it attached a very, very important 11 condition. It said, We will grant you the rights to put on 12 the World Cup if you establish a Division~I, a major 13 league -- major soccer league in this country. And so it 14 was the job of the USSF, that's the federation that governs 15 soccer in this country, to set the standards for Division~I 16 certification, and to decide who should get that 17 certification; and it was also the job of the USSF to 18 determine the organization and the running of the World Cup. 19 And so a year later, Mr. Rothenberg was elected 20 president of the USSF, and the USSF began to take on the 21 responsibilities of putting this World Cup -- seeing that 22 the World Cup was organized and seeing that ultimately there 23 would be a Division~I major league team. 24 Incidentally, when I finish speaking this morning, 25 Mr. Robbins, who is the attorney for the USSF, will be page 148 1 talking to you. 2 Now, Mr. Kessler yesterday talked about the USSF 3 board as some kind of self-appointed little club. He said 4 it took it upon itself to determine who should be certified 5 as a league that had Division~I status. And he told you 6 that that board was handpicked by Alan Rothenberg. 7 Now, every major sport in the entire world has an 8 international federation at the top that sets the major 9 policies for the sport. There are over 60 international 10 federations in the world. And then most countries, 11 including ours, has a domestic federation for basketball, 12 for hockey, for gymnastics and for soccer. 13 Now, let me show you, first of all, a page from 14 Defendant's Exhibit 1049 which is the USSF constitution. 15 Now, on Page 1 you'll see it talks about the 16 purpose of the Federation: To promote soccer in the United 17 States of America, including national and international 18 games and tournaments. That's the purpose of the USSF. 19 Now, what has the USSF done to fulfill that 20 purpose? Well, in the last five years, highlighted by 21 events of yesterday, it's been dramatic. 22 We have a young, obviously fledgling, soccer league 23 which the USSF has always felt is of critical importance to 24 building Major League Soccer and soccer generally. We now 25 have the women's team that many of you may remember that page 149 1 last year captured everyone's imagination during the 2 extraordinarily successful 1999 Women's World Cup. And 3 yesterday, yesterday in Sydney, Australia, the US Mens 4 Olympic Soccer Team, not a dream team made up of the 5 superstars but limited to players under age 23, that soccer 6 team advanced to the second round of the Olympics for 7 the first time in 76 years. 8 That these things are happening all at once is no 9 accident. The USSF is fulfilling its mandate, to promote 10 soccer. 11 Now, let me go back to Page 8 of the rule book. 12 This is the USSF rule book. And what it talks about is who 13 is going to be on the USSF board. 14 Mr. Kessler told you that the Board was composed of 15 Mr. Rothenberg's handpicked cronies. Who is the Board? The 16 National Board of Directors, president, vice president, 17 treasurer. Then it says vice president from the amateur 18 division. Then it says vice president from the youth 19 division. Then it says vice president from each 20 professional council and three other representatives of the 21 professional division. That would include the APSL. 22 Then it says athlete representatives, athlete 23 representatives as required by an act of Congress. That's a 24 citation to a congressional statute. 25 Then it says four more directors from amateur, four page 150 1 directors from youth, past president, chairman of the 2 referees, chairman of the coaching committee. Then from a 3 page from the rule book which I won't bother with you now, 4 there's detailed rules about how each of those groups select 5 their representatives. 6 Did Mr. Kessler really mean to suggest to you that 7 Mr. Rothenberg went around the country and engineered the 8 election of all these people? 9 Look who was on the Board. This is from the next 10 few pages of the rule book. This is who was on the Board in 11 1993. So it says the vice president from the amateur 12 division, the vice president from the youth division, 13 Mr. De LaPena, he was from the APSL, the vice president from 14 the professional division. And then after the past 15 president, someone from the -- two people from -- four 16 people from the amateur group, people from the youth group, 17 people from the coaching committee, referees and so forth. 18 Is it really to be believed that that's the group, 19 that's the group, unquestionably, that made the decision as 20 to whether there should be one Division~I league and whether 21 that league should be MLS? 22 Is it really true that Mr. Rothenberg went around 23 to each of these groups, that he went to the athletes, 24 former or present players on the National Team, the highest 25 soccer team in the United States, and he engineered this? page 151 1 It's just not to be believed. And you will hear it from the 2 witness stand. 3 Now, Mr. Rothenberg, who is sitting over there, and 4 others will tell you what really happened and the fact that 5 there was no conspiracy. There's no secret about what 6 happened. You'll look at the documents. You'll see what 7 happened. 8 Alan Rothenberg, who had been in sports for over 25 9 years, had run an extraordinarily successful Olympic 10 tournament for soccer in 1984 when the Olympics were held 11 here in Los Angeles, and he was elected president of the 12 USSF. And he said, I have my mandate. I'm going to be the 13 president, and I'm going to do everything possible to put on 14 the successful World Cup that FIFA has granted to us, and 15 I'm going to do everything possible to carry out the 16 condition that FIFA attached to that World Cup, establishing 17 a Division~I league. 18 And then after the planning for the World Cup 19 began, it wasn't at all clear that anyone was doing anything 20 about creating a Division~I league, and Mr. Rothenberg 21 stepped up to the plate on that issue as well. 22 Now, the USSF Board, the people whose names you 23 just saw, they promulgated and distributed objective 24 standards as to who would receive the Division~I 25 certification. And you'll look at those standards and page 152 1 you'll see if they were "rigged," I think, was Mr. Kessler's 2 words. I'm confident you will conclude that they were 3 perfectly appropriate and objective. 4 And then in December of 1993, that Board, excusing 5 anyone who had a conflict, anyone such as Mr. de~la~Pena and 6 the other APSL people, excusing Mr. Rothenberg and anyone 7 else who might be associated with MLS, that Board 8 provisionally selected MLS as the Division~I league. 9 Now, this is very important. A little more than a 10 year later, the Board unanimously approved a resolution 11 confirming that MLS would be the Division~I league and the 12 only Division~I league for two years. That resolution was 13 passed unanimously. And among the people who voted for that 14 resolution which said there will be one Division~I league 15 for two years and that league will be MLS, among the people 16 who voted for that resolution was the commissioner of the 17 APSL. 18 Those two decisions, the 1993 decision that made 19 the provisional certification and the 1995 certification is 20 what the players say were wrongful. 21 But without those decisions reached by this 22 independent board and the extraordinary efforts of 23 Mr. Rothenberg, Mr. Garber and his predecessors and the MLS 24 staff, there wouldn't be Division~I soccer in this country 25 today. page 153 1 Now, Mr. Kessler spent most of yesterday telling 2 you about this conspiracy. But he spent -- he didn't spend 3 very much time, and I'd like to spend some time, telling you 4 what the evidence will show as to why there was going to be 5 only a -- only one league for a two-year period. 6 Now, the evidence will show that at least as long 7 as 1988, long before Mr. Rothenberg was on the scene, the 8 USSF said we want only one Division~I league, the one league 9 requirement that's in that very handbook I put up before. 10 This preference for one league, not two but one league, is 11 not surprising but, as I said before, every country in the 12 world -- and there's a lot more soccer support in every 13 country in the world -- every country in the world where 14 major soccer is played has one league, not two. That's 15 certainly true in the United States, as I indicated. 16 Now, what did the APSL say about this one league? 17 Let's look at Plaintiff's Exhibit 165, Page 9. And 18 if we could blow up the paragraph near the bottom, I think 19 it's here. 20 The previous paragraph, I believe. 21 That's it. Here we go. 22 This is from the APSL document in July of 1993, 23 before the decision was made. APSL said, It was 24 contemplated there would be one Division I Premier League. 25 Ladies and gentlemen, that's what the APSL said six page 154 1 months before the USSF Board said there is going to be one 2 league, but, of course, then they said the one league is 3 going to be MLS and things changed. 4 Mr. Kessler told you yesterday that the APSL always 5 wanted there to be more than one league. I guess he forgot 6 about that document. 7 Now, the USSF didn't decide on one league just 8 because that's the way it had always been because the people 9 who participated in the decision, the people on the USSF 10 Board who will testify from that witness stand, they'll tell 11 you what was in their minds. They'll tell you why they 12 voted for one league. And they'll go back to the North 13 American Soccer League experience and that the past efforts 14 to have soccer in this country had failed and failed 15 miserably because there was such a small base. 16 There was intense competition in 1993, as there is 17 even today, for the attention of sports fans. It would take 18 a lot of money to get Division~I soccer off the ground. It 19 would take -- you had to anticipate major losses. And even 20 some of the players -- you will hear testimony from even 21 some of the players that the players didn't think that there 22 were enough top-quality players in this country to support 23 two leagues. 24 Now, those were the facts that the witnesses who -- 25 the people who voted in 1993 decided why there should be one page 155 1 league. They felt if there were two leagues, the very small 2 group of fans would be divided. There wouldn't be enough 3 support for either league. They'd knock each other off, and 4 the result would have been a disaster. 5 Now, maybe you disagree with that decision, 6 although I doubt it, but was it designed to monopolize the 7 market? No. It was taken in an effort to make professional 8 soccer work. 9 Now, the evidence will tell you, in retrospect, 10 that the decision was ripe to have only one league because, 11 as I have said, MLS is losing money. Its values have not 12 increased. It's generating very modest revenues. Fans have 13 not increased. Sponsors have not increased, and it's, as I 14 said, it's losing money. 15 And the investors have lost all their money. And 16 if there had been two leagues competing, as Mr. Kessler 17 insists should have occurred, the attention of the fans 18 would have been diverted even more and both leagues would 19 surely be out of business. 20 Now, Mr. Kessler also said that if there was going 21 to be a certification of one league, it should have been the 22 APSL. He said the APSL had players. The APSL had stadiums. 23 They had uniforms and MLS had nothing. Well, let me talk 24 about the MLS plan first and then the APSL plan because I 25 think it's very important. page 156 1 Let me tell you about the MLS plan. 2 The first thing the MLS plan said -- and each 3 league put a big, fat document together that you'll see, 4 business plan, proposal, and they submitted it to the USSF. 5 And the MLS said we're going to organize ourselves 6 differently than the conventional sports leagues like 7 baseball and football. 8 MLS said that we're going to create a single 9 entity, one company, that will run all the teams. And the 10 MLS investors will simply be stockholders in this one team. 11 They won't be owners of the individual teams. And most of 12 the investors will own -- will have an operating interest to 13 run the team, but they won't own it. They'll receive a 14 management fee. 15 Other investors, like Mr. Rothenberg, will just be 16 investors. They won't run a team. And so unlike most of 17 the other sports leagues, established sports leagues, but 18 like most other businesses in this country, all of the MLS 19 investors, people who don't operate a team and the people 20 who do, share in the profits or losses of the league, just 21 like stockholders in any other business. 22 And since MLS owns all the team, it owns all the 23 other assets, logos, et cetera. And it makes all the 24 decisions; what television contracts to enter into, what 25 sponsorship agreements to enter into. It even signs the page 157 1 lease agreements with, for example, Foxboro Stadium. 2 And it also decides, along with all these other 3 decisions, which players to employ and how to use its money 4 and whether to pay the players $50,000, 100,000 or more. 5 Now, I want to emphasize, there's nothing wrong -- 6 it is perfectly legal for MLS to have decided to organize 7 itself in this fashion. It is perfectly lawful for MLS to 8 have decided this is the way we're going to be organized, 9 that the league will own all the teams and the league will 10 sign all the players. 11 And it was perfectly lawful for MLS after it was 12 formed to carry out this policy so that the league and not 13 the individual teams would decide what players to employ and 14 at what price. 15 I want to make sure that everyone appreciates that. 16 There is no issue in this litigation about the lawfulness of 17 MLS's actions in this regard. The fact that more 18 established sports leagues founded 50 or a hundred years ago 19 do it differently doesn't change the fact. 20 In fact, if you look at most of the new sports 21 leagues that have come on the scene, the WNBA, even the 22 newly announced XFL, have also organized themselves in this 23 single-entity fashion. 24 Well, why? Why did MLS organize its -- tell the 25 USSF it was going to do things this way? page 158 1 Well, you will hear from Mr. Rothenberg that he 2 said to himself and to the other prospective investors, 3 we've got to find a way that soccer is going to succeed. 4 We've got to do it differently. We've got to do it 5 differently than the North American Soccer League. 6 And so MLS said we're going to form this 7 single-entity approach, and it was perfectly lawful for them 8 to do that. 9 And MLS told the USSF one other thing. It said, 10 we'd like to become the Division~I league. Make no mistake 11 about it, but in our judgment, the United States of America 12 cannot support two Division~I leagues. We must have an 13 exclusive period to be that Division~I league. If you don't 14 want to do it, if you don't want to certify us as the 15 exclusive Division~I league, that's your right, but don't 16 expect us to make the extraordinary investment -- an 17 investment that now is $250 million in the red -- don't 18 expect us to make that investment if we're not going to be 19 the single league. 20 And then MLS -- the plan that MLS put together, 21 that you'll see in the jury room and you'll hear a lot of 22 testimony about, went into the economics of what it 23 proposed. And it said, We'll have $50 million. We'll raise 24 $50 million, and we'll take $30 million and spend it on 25 players in the first year. page 159 1 And for purposes of this lawsuit, the next 2 statement is very important. MLS said we propose in year 3 one that the average player compensation will be $70,000. 4 MLS said our teams will be located in the major cities of 5 this country. MLS said that the investors and executives 6 would include people like Alan Rothenberg, Bob Kraft here in 7 Boston, nationally recognized businessmen whose experience 8 was extensive in professional sports, including the NFL and 9 the NBA. 10 That was the MLS's proposal. 11 What about the APSL proposal, the APSL proposal, 12 the one that Mr. Kessler said should have been approved? 13 Well, Mr. Kessler I don't recall talking about the history 14 of APSL. I don't recall whether he said anything about 15 whether the APSL plan had any reality to it. 16 Let me put that in context in 1993 when the APSL 17 put this application in. Mr. Kessler is right, they were 18 operating, the APSL was operating, although they were on 19 life support. 20 Now, let's look at that chart, the APSL chart that 21 Mr. Kessler put up yesterday. One, two, three, four, five, 22 six, seven teams. Three years before there had been 22 23 teams. Fifteen -- actually 16, had gone out of business. 24 Because, you see, Seattle Sounders started play in 1994. So 25 in the previous year, there were only the six teams. And page 160 1 the seventh team was a team in Canada, a team in Toronto. 2 So this United States proposed major league, United 3 States Division~I proposed league, would have one team in 4 Montreal, one team in Vancouver and had just had a team in 5 Toronto, a United States major league. 6 The other cities, Denver, Los Angeles, Seattle, 7 Tampa, Fort Lauderdale, a nationwide United States major 8 soccer league. That's what was supposed to be proposed. 9 Not a Canadian, not a North American soccer league, a United 10 States soccer league. 11 Now, what about the attendance figures for these 12 seven teams? I didn't hear any mention about that 13 yesterday. 14 The highest grossing team in terms of attendance in 15 the year last season was the Montreal team. Their average 16 attendance for this proposed major league was 4,800 fans, 17 average. You know what the lowest attendance was? 687 18 people a game. 19 Can you imagine 687 people sitting in Foxboro 20 stadium watching a game? 21 This was the major league plan. 22 Now, the APSL said no problem, we're going to have 23 9,000 fans a game. Why? Why would one believe that that 24 was true? 25 The MLS proposal, by the way, projected fans at page 161 1 12,500 for the first year, and that prediction came true. 2 Now, of most relevance to this lawsuit is what the 3 APSL told the USSF it would do about players. After all, 4 we're in a lawsuit by the players, about the players, who 5 are complaining that they didn't earn enough money. 6 Now, the APSL told the USSF that if it got the 7 certification, it would play the players, on average, 8 $34,000. $34,000. MLS had said $70,000, and that 9 prediction by MLS would come true. $34,000, said the APSL. 10 The APSL said we're going to spend $850,000 on 11 salaries per team. MLS had said we're going to spend a 12 couple of hundred thousand more than that. 13 Let's look at this in a little more detail, and I'm 14 looking at Plaintiff's Exhibit 3. This was the proposal of 15 the APSL, and let's look at the paragraph about player 16 salaries. 17 Can you blow that up, please. 18 This is what the APSL said about salaries. It said 19 there would be six players at $30,000; six players at 20 $20,000; and five players at expenses only, $15,000 total. 21 $3,000 a player. 22 So for the whole year, five players would get 23 $3,000 each. Remember, MLS had proposed $24,000 minimum. 24 And that $24,000 minimum that MLS had said is what 25 Mr. Kessler said, Who can live on it with a wife and two page 162 1 children? 2 Now, putting aside the fact that the young players, 3 the entry-level players at MLS, really don't have a wife and 4 two children, they're just out of college, why was the APSL 5 proposal better? Six players would be at $20,000 and five 6 others at $3,000. Why is he complaining about MLS? 7 The APSL plan wasn't a Division~I plan. It was a 8 minor league plan. So why did the USSF approve the MLS 9 plan? What would you have done? 10 MLS had the best financing, the best business plan, 11 far more money and it didn't have the history of failure. 12 Now, yesterday Mr. Kessler put up Plaintiff's 13 Exhibit 253 before you. This is a memorandum that he sent 14 to the APSL owners. Remember that? Put that before you. 15 He was trying to make peace with the APSL, and he invited 16 them to join MLS, but he said -- move that up a little bit. 17 Okay. 18 We would like to have you participate in the form 19 of a credit fair market value. Please do this, join MLS, 20 commit the additional capital to assure that the best 21 available players join the league, that we have a truly 22 major marketing effort. 23 Was that a conspiracy? Of course not. We wanted 24 more money so we could spend more money on players, not the 25 $3,000 a player that the APSL was proposing. page 163 1 But the APSL, as its history demonstrated, was 2 really a minor league, a small-time operation. 3 As Mr. Rothenberg said, calling you Division~I is 4 not enough. The public will see right through it. 5 ABC is not going to sign a contract to put games on 6 television where you're paying the players $3,000. ABC is 7 not going to telecast a game where 687 people are in the 8 stands. 9 What Mr. Rothenberg said to the APSL owners wasn't 10 a threat. Mr. Rothenberg had been in the sports business 11 for over 25 years. He knew that the APSL proposal was bound 12 to fail. 13 Now, you're going to hear, I think in the next 14 couple of days, a videotape of pretrial testimony of one of 15 the APSL owners, and he's going to tell you that the 16 certification process wasn't fair, that his league should 17 have been certified. And he's going to say we had a 18 promise, and Mr. Kessler discussed that with you. We had 19 the, quote, first opportunity to post a letter of intent to 20 be a Division~I league. 21 I don't know what that means, but certainly this 22 APSL owner doesn't know what "first opportunity to post a 23 letter of intent" was because he wasn't even around when 24 that letter was given. 25 You'll hear about that letter from people who were page 164 1 around. They'll tell you what it meant. But whatever it 2 meant, it certainly didn't guarantee the APSL that it would 3 get Division~I status if it gave the plan of the kind it 4 gave to the USSF. 5 And I'm sure when you listen to this and see this 6 testimony, you'll remember that this person was a 7 disappointed applicant, and his recollection may be a little 8 bit faulty because of that. 9 In fact, this person's public comments were so 10 inaccurate that it led Mr. Rothenberg to lose his temper and 11 call him some names. And Mr. Kessler showed you that 12 document the other day. And when you appreciate what the 13 APSL plan was, made up out of whole cloth and no reality, I 14 think you can understand why Mr. Rothenberg lost his temper. 15 And whatever this APSL former owner tells you in 16 this testimony you will see, remember that in 1995 when the 17 USSF Board voted to make the MLS certification permanent, 18 remember that one of the people who voted "yes" in that 19 unanimous resolution was the APSL commissioner himself. 20 Now, there's one other point about the APSL. The 21 failure to get Division~I status didn't mean that the APSL 22 was out of business. Not at all. In fact, the APSL isn't 23 in this courtroom. They're not suing. The APSL continued 24 in business as a minor league. It merged with another 25 league, and, in fact, it is a major competitor of MLS today page 165 1 for some of the lower-end players. 2 APSL could continue to sign players, lease stadiums 3 and so forth. So what you're going to hear, ladies and 4 gentlemen, is that the USSF Board, that Board whose members 5 I showed you before, looked at all this evidence and said to 6 themselves, The MLS plan is a much, much better plan, a much 7 better chance for survival. And for two years we've got to 8 give MLS a chance to be the only Division~I league. 9 The APSL plan, on the other hand, was made up out 10 of whole cloth, and I am confident that when you look at all 11 the evidence, you'll see why the decision to certify MLS was 12 correct. 13 And, in fact, let me ask you to think through this 14 case, was there a better choice than MLS? Think about that 15 question, which I'll leave up for a minute. 16 MLS is proposing to pay the players much more than 17 the APSL with a much greater financial commitment, organized 18 by the leaders of American business and sports, compared to 19 the APSL. It seems to me the decision was obvious. 20 It wasn't a desire to create a monopoly. It was a 21 desire to create a successful soccer league. 22 Now, I would suggest -- you remember what I said 23 about the division league, and remember what I've said about 24 the APSL verses the MLS plan? The case should be over 25 because, remember, they're complaining that there should page 166 1 have been either the APSL or both leagues, but Mr. Kessler 2 says there was this conspiracy. Mr. Rothenberg had a 3 diabolical conspiracy, he told you yesterday. The evidence 4 will show this is false. This is a very, very serious 5 charge that's been brought and there's no basis to it. 6 Remember, the players keep saying if it wasn't for 7 this conspiracy, the APSL would have been certified as 8 Division~I. Can that really be believed? And players say 9 if APSL had been certified, we would have gotten a lot more 10 money. How can they say that when the plan said we'll give 11 the players half of what MLS says, and we'll be paying 11 12 players less than $15,000 on average? 13 Now, this conspiracy charge surrounds the fact that 14 at some point in this process Mr. Rothenberg was president 15 of the USSF, the head of the World Cup Organizing Committee 16 and the principal organizer of MLS. 17 Mr. Kessler was right on that point. At some point 18 in time, Mr. Rothenberg was in charge of each of those 19 groups, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with that 20 fact. 21 Now, I already mentioned the USSF Board and who 22 composes it, because soccer is supposed to be run by people 23 who are running it, who are involved in it. That's why the 24 Board of the USSF is composed of these different 25 representatives. There's nothing wrong about that. That's page 167 1 the way it's always been done. That's the way every sports 2 governing body is set up. You don't want some stranger 3 coming in. You don't want all strangers on the board. 4 Now, Mr. Rothenberg was elected president of the 5 USSF in 1990. There had already been in place by the time 6 he was elected president a World Cup Organizing Committee 7 whose job it was to put on this very prestigious World Cup. 8 Many members of the World Cup Board had already been 9 selected before Mr. Rothenberg was on the scene. In fact, 10 the vast majority of the members of the World Cup Board -- 11 and this is very important -- the vast majority of those 12 members had nothing at all to do with the USSF. 13 Now, the USSF is composed of these various 14 representatives of soccer. The World Cup Board was composed 15 primarily of a very different kind of people. Let me tell 16 you who some of those people were. 17 Henry Kissinger. I suspect many of you remember 18 Henry Kissinger, the former Secretary of State of the United 19 States. Peter Ueberroth, former Commissioner of Baseball. 20 William Simon, the former Secretary -- the former Treasury 21 Secretary. John Nordstrom the head of the department store 22 chain. 23 Do you really think these people like Henry 24 Kissinger, Peter Ueberroth, William Simon and John Nordstrom 25 were puppets of Alan Rothenberg's? page 168 1 These were men who had built a career of public 2 service and successful entrepreneurship in this country. 3 Not only were these men of obvious independent 4 judgment, but they had nothing whatsoever to do with the MLS 5 certification process. It was completely separate. 6 Now, what happened? What happened that Mr. Kessler 7 tries to put these little pieces together in a way which 8 doesn't withstand a hard look. 9 Remember the World Cup had been granted to the US 10 on the condition that a Division~I league be established. 11 World Cup's scheduled for 1994. And preparations for the 12 World Cup were underway, and in the spring of 1993, 13 Mr. Rothenberg got a very important letter from FIFA. 14 That's the international group that had given the United 15 States the right to run the World Cup, and you're going to 16 look at that letter. And that letter reminded 17 Mr. Rothenberg that the World Cup had been given to the 18 United States on a very important condition: That a 19 Division~I league be established. 20 And the letter said it didn't appear that much 21 progress had been made and demanded a detailed progress 22 report by the end of 1993. And, unfortunately, FIFA was 23 right. There hadn't been much progress. 24 Now, Mr. Kessler says that Mr. Rothenberg hatched a 25 conspiracy and that ever since he had been plotting to get page 169 1 the Division~I certification, ever since 1990. 2 But the fact is that until he got that letter in 3 1993, not a single step had been taken to form a major 4 soccer league in this country, and Mr. Rothenberg sprung 5 into action. 6 The World Cup committee, which had nothing to do 7 with the USSF group, as I said, created a subsidiary, Major 8 League Professional Soccer. 9 That job, the job of that subsidiary, was to 10 creation a new league. And Mr. Rothenberg said, okay, I'll 11 take charge of that as well. And so the World Cup said, 12 We're going to give this subsidiary a $5 million loan to 13 carry out its work. It's going to come out of World Cup 14 surplus. This was perfectly logical since the World Cup 15 proceeds, the surplus, had to, in part, be used to found a 16 division -- to help support soccer in this country. 17 The loan wasn't a secret. It was completely 18 documented. And MLS has taken that loan, secured it and 19 promised to pay it. 20 The APSL didn't get the loan because they didn't 21 ask for it. They did ask for it when they filed their 22 application in December of 1993, and the issue became moot, 23 because, as we've seen, they weren't certified. 24 Now, Mr. Rothenberg, this supposed villain, who you 25 will see from that witness stand and who you will evaluate, page 170 1 was asked to take on a series of very challenging 2 assignments. 3 You know what happens when you always volunteer, 4 busiest person, the most successful person, takes on one 5 more job and one more job. He was successful in running the 6 soccer tournament for the Olympics. He had a long and 7 successful sports background. He had been elected president 8 of the USSF. He had been placed in charge of the World Cup 9 precisely because of his background and his successful 10 running of soccer tournaments, and that benefitted the 11 entire sports community. No one had stepped forward to get 12 the Division~I league off the ground. So Mr. Rothenberg 13 said, I'll do that as well. And in order that there be no 14 conflicts, Mr. Rothenberg said, I'm going to disqualify 15 myself from any decision affecting the organizations that 16 I'm heading. 17 Should he be faulted for that? He devoted enormous 18 amounts of time to this effort, and the effort was an 19 extraordinary success. 20 Now, there's one last conspiracy charge that is 21 made. They said there was something wrong, Mr. Kessler, 22 because the World Cup Board, not the USSF Board, the World 23 Cup Board, awarded Mr. Rothenberg $7 million when everything 24 was over. 25 Now, the presidency of the World Cup, unlike the page 171 1 presidency of the USSF, that was supposed to be a paying 2 position. But Mr. Rothenberg had said, I'm not going to get 3 paid. You decide whether I do a good job, and then you 4 decide whether I should be paid. For more than four years 5 he wasn't paid a nickel running the World Cup. 6 The tournament turned out to be the most successful 7 World Cup in history. It generated over $60 million of 8 surplus to use to the benefit of soccer in this country. 9 And so the World Cup board met, and they hired an outside 10 agency, executive compensation firm, and said, What should 11 we pay Mr. Rothenberg? And that outside agency recommended 12 $7 million. 13 And then the World Cup board -- Henry Kissinger, 14 Peter Uberoff, Bill Simon, all those other people that I 15 mentioned, voted to approve that. Does that mean that there 16 was a conspiracy? Does that mean that MLS shouldn't have 17 been certified? No. 18 The evidence will show that the Division I vote was 19 absolutely correct and not at all affected by any of these 20 conspiracy charges. 21 Your Honor, I have about 20 minutes more. I can 22 keep going or -- 23 THE COURT: Why don't you keep going. 24 MR. CARDOZO: Okay. If I could just take a -- 25 (Pause in proceedings.) page 172 1 MR. CARDOZO: I want to move to a different 2 subject but it's related. 3 Another reason, wholly apart from the merits of the 4 fact that the Division~I league certification process was 5 correct, another reason why the decision did not create an 6 unlawful monopoly, as the players call it, is that MLS is a 7 part, a very, very tiny part, of a worldwide international 8 soccer market competing for soccer players. 9 And because of that fact, that it's a tiny part of 10 a worldwide market, the fact that MLS was designated as the 11 only Division~I league in this country can't be considered 12 monopolistic, improperly monopolistic. 13 The plaintiffs say Division~I certification process 14 allowed MLS to become a monopoly because MLS controls the 15 player market in the United States and, therefore, we can 16 underpay our players. But the reason that's wrong is that 17 the market definition wrong. 18 If the plaintiffs were right, if MLS was 19 underpaying its players, why is it that ever since its 20 formation MLS consistently increases players' salaries and 21 tears up contracts before they're over? It wouldn't. 22 To pay the players more when you're losing money 23 and to pay the players more before their contracts expire is 24 crazy, unless there's a reason for it. 25 And what's the reason? To keep the players in this page 173 1 country playing for MLS because MLS faces extraordinary 2 competitive pressure from abroad. 3 Now, what does "monopoly" mean? What does 4 "monopolize" mean? It certainly is true that the day before 5 MLS was created there was no major soccer league in this 6 country, and the day after it was created there was one. 7 That doesn't mean MLS did anything wrong. It simply meant 8 that MLS joined this vast international market. 9 So as you think -- as you listen to the evidence, 10 ask yourself this question: Does MLS compete with foreign 11 teams and other domestic US teams for players? 12 The answer is a loud Yes. The relevant market in 13 this case is not this country and just major soccer players. 14 Put the question differently. Think about it this 15 way. If MLS didn't pay the player what the player thought 16 he should get, is there another soccer team somewhere else 17 that would hire the player for more money, and would the 18 player go there? Are there reasonable alternatives that 19 will allow the player to play soccer other than for MLS? Do 20 other soccer teams want the players to play for them? 21 I want to review this evidence in a little more 22 detail, but I want to give you a little suggestion. This is 23 a class action, and you're going to hear, Mr. Kessler told 24 you yesterday, from the eight what we call "named" 25 plaintiffs, the people that actually brought the lawsuit. page 174 1 Now, they represent -- for legal purposes, they 2 represent the class of MLS players. But that doesn't 3 mean -- that doesn't mean that their experience is typical 4 of that of the average player. I'm sure you will listen 5 carefully to what the evidence is going to show and what 6 those players say on both direct examination and 7 cross-examination. 8 Now, there are something like 550 or 600 players, 9 technically members of this class. It's probably about 100 10 to 150 less than that because it includes players who never 11 played a game for MLS or played less than the equivalent of 12 one game. Don't worry. You're not going to hear from 13 anywhere close to 550 players, but you are going to hear 14 from a few others, either in person or by hearing their 15 depositions, and you'll also hear about the MLS' dealings 16 with the players from people such as Mr. Gazidis. 17 And from all that evidence, you're going to learn 18 that the players can choose to play abroad, do choose, 19 sometimes to play in the minor leagues and sometimes refuse 20 to sign renewed contracts with MLS. 21 You have to look at this in two ports: First, the 22 international opportunities and then the domestic 23 opportunities. 24 Now, one of the things to keep in mind is that 25 soccer is an international game, as I said before. As I page 175 1 said, the World Cup is watched by over a billion people. 2 The attendance and television ratings for soccer, in 3 England, Argentina, France, Germany, Brazil, those 4 television ratings are as high as an NBA or baseball or 5 football game get in this country. 6 People abroad -- for those of you who been abroad, 7 you probably know this -- they're passionate about their 8 teams. You probably read about riots sometimes that 9 accompany soccer games abroad. And, of course, because of 10 this intense interest overseas, the money that soccer teams 11 generate outside this country is much, much higher than what 12 is generated in the United States. So MLS has to worry 13 every single day about losing players to the foreign market. 14 As I mentioned at the beginning, MLS has 15 renegotiated over 70 contracts this year before they 16 expired, and it did it even though it was losing money, 17 because it wanted to be sure that it could keep those 18 players playing in the United States as long as possible. 19 Let me give you one example. This is a typical 20 example. 21 A few weeks ago, MLS faced the following situation: 22 It had a rookie named Adam Brown, and they had to 23 offer him a huge salary increase. He had only been playing 24 for MLS for a few months. 25 Mr. Brown was drafted out of college in January. page 176 1 He signed a contract with MLS for $30,000, and then he 2 started playing, and he was terrific. Well, that's good and 3 that's bad because the foreign teams sat up and took notice. 4 And just a few months ago, after Mr. Brown had 5 signed his contract, a team in the Norway Division~I league 6 offered Mr. Brown, a rookie who had been playing for a few 7 months, they offered him $166,000 a year and a 8 $139,000 bonus. 9 What did MLS do? They had just signed this player 10 for $30,000. MLS said, We got to keep this guy. And so 11 they offered him lots more money. They increased his -- 12 they offered to increase his salary from 30,000 to 160,000. 13 You know what Mr. Brown did? He said no. 14 Now they're in the middle of negotiations, and I 15 hope it works out; but the point is that the players have 16 these other opportunities, as this story illustrates. 17 Now, Mr. Kessler says there's international market. 18 He told you only a few players play overseas. He tried to 19 give the impression that only eight of this class had true 20 international opportunities. 21 Well, let's look at Plaintiff's Exhibit 716. It's 22 entitled -- this is Plaintiff's Exhibit 716, "International 23 Experience of MLS Players." I'm sure you can't read it, but 24 I'd just like to scroll down. 25 Keep scrolling down, this is -- page 177 1 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, I'm sorry, we have 2 to interrupt for a second. I'd like to approach. 3 THE COURT: Why don't you take it off the 4 screen for a minute. 5 (SIDE BAR CONFERENCE AS FOLLOWS: 6 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, as you know, we had 7 an agreement to exchange demonstratives and, in fact, they 8 gave us other demonstratives for Mr. Klein's testimony which 9 is what this is. This is their expert's chart. We had no 10 notice of this. We designated it as an exhibit which we did 11 for purposes of cross-examination. We had no intention -- 12 and just because it's on our exhibit list does not mean 13 that -- we would object to this exhibit, and we want an 14 opportunity -- we had a 72-hour notice and they absolutely 15 just violated that rule. 16 MR. CARDOZO: I asked specifically yesterday 17 whether exhibits -- there had been no objection. We didn't 18 have to notify. This is listed as an exhibit. This is the 19 plaintiff's exhibit. This is not a demonstrative. This is 20 a page out of their exhibit -- 21 MR. KESSLER: No, your Honor, this is a page 22 out of their expert's report which we objected to. 23 THE COURT: Is it in the pretrial? 24 MR. CARDOZO: Yes. 25 MR. KESSLER: Yes. page 178 1 MR. CARDOZO: Exhibit 716. 2 (Pause.) 3 MR. CARDOZO: Here it is. 4 MR. KESSLER: This is Mr. Klein's -- expert -- 5 the pretrial order. 6 MR. CARDOZO: Exhibit 716 is what I'm showing 7 this witness. 8 MR. MYER: Your Honor, if I could. 9 THE COURT: Let me find it. 10 MR. CARDOZO: It's Tab -- 11 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, if I may, they 12 designated this as an exhibit for them and we objected to 13 it. This same document was Defendant's Exhibit 1225. The 14 fact that we listed it on our list for possible 15 cross-examination does not mean it's unobjected to. We 16 objected to their using it. 17 MR. CARDOZO: Well, I don't understand. 18 THE COURT: This doesn't limit it to 19 cross-examination. 20 MR. CARDOZO: Not at all. 21 THE COURT: I think you can use it. 22 MR. CARDOZO: Thank you. 23 END OF SIDEBAR CONFERENCE.) 24 MR. CARDOZO: I know you can't read the names, 25 but if you can just scroll down, look at all these names, page 179 1 just keep scrolling and scrolling and scrolling. 2 Remember Mr. Kessler said no one had international 3 opportunities. These are people who played for MLS and who 4 played before or after in Europe or South America or 5 someplace else. Look at this. Nigeria, Peru, Poland, 6 Scotland, South Africa. We're at 82. Got another hundred 7 to go. All right. Look at the countries. 8 Mr. Kessler told you only a few players -- you can 9 now turn that off -- I'm going to go back to Page 4 in a 10 minute. He said only a few players have international 11 opportunities. 12 The fact is, ladies and gentlemen, that as of 1998, 13 which is when this exhibit was prepared, over 160 MLS 14 players had played abroad. 15 Let's look at Page 4. Let's just go back to 16 Page 4, if we could, of that exhibit. And look at 17 Mr. Allnut. Played Mexico Division~II and also played for 18 MLS. 19 Look at Page 5, Mr. Paul Caligiuri. Mr. Paul 20 Caligiuri, he's a US citizen, played for the German bund 21 detective lag league in Germany. 22 You know what Mr. Caligiuri was? He was an 23 original plaintiff in this case. Not a plaintiff in the 24 case anymore, but he was an original plaintiff. He played 25 in two different leagues in Germany, and I could go on and page 180 1 on to other people on this list which we don't have time to 2 cover. 3 Even Stephen Trittschuh, a named plaintiff who 4 apparently is going to testify, he's played in MLS, Czech 5 Republic and Holland. 6 So, ladies and gentlemen, there are huge numbers of 7 international opportunities. 8 Let me give you just one more example. 9 Yesterday -- I talked about yesterday how the US 10 Olympic team for the first time advanced to the second round 11 of the preliminary picks. You know who the star, the US 12 star of yesterday's game was? It was of someone who the MLS 13 tried to sign, a US player, playing for his country. Is he 14 playing for MLS? No. He's playing for one of the top teams 15 in Germany. But Mr. Kessler says that US players don't have 16 an opportunity to play abroad. 17 The evidence will show not what we're arguing but 18 the evidence, such as those kinds of exhibits, will show 19 that some players play for MLS and then go abroad for more 20 money, and other players take the opposite approach, and 21 still other players say if you don't pay me more money, I'm 22 going to go abroad. 23 Now, let me just give you one other example. 24 Mr. Kessler said, Well, it's only Division~I. Players only 25 want to be in Division~I. But one of the players page 181 1 Mr. Kessler referred to yesterday was anthony Razzo, and he 2 started at MLS for the minimum salary, about $24,000. 3 Mr. Razzo is not a superstar. He's a good player. Not a 4 marquis player. 5 MLS offered Mr. Razzo $250,000 to stay with MLS. 6 You know what? Mr. Razzo said, sorry, guys, I'm going to a 7 Division~II team in Europe. 8 No international opportunities, free movement, 9 alternatives. There are lots and lots of these people. The 10 statistics show it. You will hear it from the witness stand 11 over and over again. And that is because the international 12 soccer market is so huge. 13 Think Pedro Martinez, who I suspect many of you 14 have heard of, great pitcher for the Boston Red Sox. If the 15 Red Sox don't pay Pedro Martinez at the end of his contract 16 what he wants, he can go to 29 other Major League Baseball 17 teams. He's not going to go to France or Germany because 18 baseball, if you're a great baseball player, the best 19 opportunities are in the US. 20 That's not true in soccer. The best soccer teams 21 are outside of this country. 22 There are more than 400 teams, you will hear, that 23 can compete for players, 400 teams, and they have competed 24 for the players. 25 Reasonable alternatives? You bet. page 182 1 And our expert, Doctor Klein, will tell you, I've 2 given this a study. I've put this all together, and in my 3 opinion, based upon my study, there are over 200 MLS 4 players -- about half of the players in MLS have played at 5 least a game -- who could play abroad if they wanted to. 6 Half of the class. 7 This isn't theoretical. This is actual. That's 8 what the evidence shows. 9 Mr. Kessler says, Well, they have limits on the 10 number of people. Foreign teams can only employ a certain 11 number of foreigners. It hasn't prevented those people from 12 playing. All those people whose names you saw on the chart. 13 There are 2,000 -- 2,000 available jobs for US Soccer 14 players abroad. 15 Alternative employment opportunities? You bet. 16 This isn't what Larry Bird could face or Mo Vaughn 17 could face or Bobby Orr could face. They only had 18 alternatives as a practical matter in this country. Not 19 true in MLS. 20 Now, I don't want to overstate this. I've been 21 talking about international. There's also domestic because 22 not every player, I'm not suggesting that every single 23 player in MLS could play abroad because, like in most sports 24 leagues, there are great players, good players and 25 not-so-good players. page 183 1 Now, one of the not-so-good players, unfortunately, 2 is Mr. Fraser, who was the leading plaintiff in this case. 3 And after a year playing for MLS, he was cut, and 4 I'm sure you're all familiar with players being cut. 5 Now, Mr. Kessler said to you, at least he strongly 6 suggested to you, that Mr. Kessler was cut because he 7 brought this lawsuit. 8 I don't know why any of the other players weren't 9 cut, if that's his theory. Mr. Kessler seems to see a 10 conspiracy every time he doesn't like a decision. The fact 11 is Mr. Fraser was cut because he wasn't so good. 12 He could play in the minor leagues, in Division~II, 13 as many, many players do, and you will hear evidence over 14 and over again that there are many, many US players who pass 15 up playing for MLS, who would rather play for Division~II 16 teams, who would rather play for the A League, the successor 17 to the APSL. 18 Why? Because these players at the low end can earn 19 more money playing in the minor leagues than they can for 20 MLS. Why? Sometimes the players are more valuable to the 21 minor league team than being a bench warmer for MLS. 22 Sometimes the player, because he can combine with 23 the indoor league and an outdoor league, he can earn more 24 money. And you will hear testimony from that witness stand 25 that these players play for the minor leagues. page 184 1 Now, I'm running out of time, but I just want to 2 give you an idea of what I'm talking about, so I'll ask 3 Mr. Geritano to put Plaintiff's Exhibit 716 up on the Board. 4 Now, these are A League, just the A League players 5 with MLS experience. Again, I don't expect you to be able 6 to absorb all of this. This is a player who played with 7 MLS, now playing in the A League, and this is the A League 8 income, monthly income. These are these players who 9 Mr. Kessler says they're not in the same market. Look at 10 them all. If goes on and on and on. 11 Ladies and gentlemen, just as there were lots and 12 lots of opportunities at the high end, there's lots and lots 13 of opportunities at the low end. It's very important as you 14 hear the evidence to keep this question in mind. 15 Alternative employment opportunities. 16 Now, in the five minutes that I will allot myself, 17 if I may, let me just bring this all to a close. 18 There's some issues that I haven't talked about. 19 Remember, how have the consumers been hurt? They 20 haven't been. Ticket prices haven't gone up. Television 21 rights fees haven't gone up. Nobody has been hurt. 22 Remember the smallness of the MLS market? And let 23 me just suggest to you, I suspect that some of you on this 24 jury are sports fans. 25 Now, I do remember from our discussions when we had page 185 1 the jury selection that most of you -- I don't think any of 2 you had ever seen an MLS game and only a few of you had 3 watched it on television. I suspect that some of you 4 probably watched the Red Sox game against the Indians last 5 night, and I suspect that even more of you know who won. 6 There was another game in Boston last night, a 7 playoff game. It drew a third of the fans of the Red Sox 8 nonplayoff game. 9 I wonder how many of you know -- don't answer, but 10 I wonder how many of you know whether the New England 11 Revolution -- whether the New England Revolution or the 12 Chicago Fire won. 13 MLS has a thin support group. It has got to do 14 better. It hasn't been able to do that. 15 Now, the plaintiffs are asking for millions and 16 millions and millions of dollars of damages. How can they 17 suggest if the APSL had gotten this certification that they 18 would have been better off? 19 Why do they think, that they would have received 20 more money? How can they suggest that if there had been two 21 leagues rather than one, more of the -- there would be more 22 money available to the plaintiffs, and why do we think with 23 MLS underpaying its players the way it is, why do the 24 plaintiffs think that the players have been underpaid? 25 Let me just ask for the questions that I've been page 186 1 asking over time to be put back up on the board so you can 2 take a look at all of them together. 3 Remember these questions throughout the case: 4 Would the players have been better off with or 5 without MLS? 6 Were there any better choices than MLS? 7 Does MLS compete with foreign teams and other 8 domestic teams for players? 9 Has MLS done anything to hurt the consumers? 10 Ladies and gentlemen, you have been more than 11 patient, and I am confident when you think about these 12 questions and listen to the evidence you're going to be able 13 to answer these questions in a way that will show that MLS 14 has done nothing wrong. 15 I want to take just one last moment to introduce 16 two of my colleagues who are going to be working with me 17 during this case: My partner, Nancy Kilson, who will be 18 examining some of the witnesses, and my associate, Tandy 19 Meghan O'Donoghue, who will be assisting us as well. 20 Ladies and gentlemen, the players had choices. 21 Before MLS existed, if they wanted to play soccer, 22 they could play for the minor leagues or they could play 23 abroad. Now, they have a third choice. They can play for 24 MLS. 25 MLS doesn't have those choices. MLS is a very page 187 1 small, fragile company. If it makes the wrong choices, if 2 it can't choose to turn the red ink around, MLS will die. 3 I ask you to listen carefully to the evidence, and 4 when it is over, I'm confident that you will return a 5 verdict in favor of Major League Soccer. 6 Thank you very much for your attention. 7 THE COURT: Thank you, Mr. Cardozo. We'll 8 take the morning recess at this stage. 9 THE CLERK: All rise. 10 (Whereupon, the jury left the courtroom.) 11 (Recess.) 12 (Whereupon, the jury entered the courtroom.) 13 THE COURT: Mr. Robbins. 14 MR. ROBBINS: Thank you, your Honor. 15 May it please the Court, ladies gentlemen, my name 16 is Paul Robbins. I'm representing the United States Soccer 17 Federation. Mr. Nick DiGiovanni, who is not here today, is 18 a Boston colleague of mine who may be here on a few 19 occasions if I have an emergency, but I plan to be here most 20 of the time. 21 You've all been very patient listening to 22 Mr. Kessler and Mr. Cardozo's presentations. They covered 23 an awful lot of material, and I know it's difficult to 24 absorb it all in one sitting. 25 I had an awful lot of notes here which I'm not page 188 1 going to use to save you from listening to me for an hour 2 and a half, but there is some material that I think it's 3 important that I cover on behalf of my client. And remember 4 that I'm representing the United States Soccer Federation. 5 "USSF" or "The Federation," it may be called, throughout the 6 trial. 7 I want to touch on something and amplify a point 8 that Mr. Cardozo made. Mr. Kessler said yesterday that the 9 Federation -- and I believe these were his words -- were a 10 private, self-proclaimed body that claims to govern soccer. 11 And I want to hit that head on right at the beginning. 12 The United States Soccer Federation is the national 13 governing body for soccer in the United States. What does 14 that mean? There is an act of Congress that created the 15 United States Olympic Committee, and that act of Congress 16 provides that the United States Olympic Committee with 17 respect to all sports, not just soccer but with all sports 18 that are involved in the Olympics, there shall be recognized 19 a national governing body, and the recognition is by the 20 United States Olympic Committee. 21 The Federation that we're talking about in this 22 case is the recognized national governing body by the United 23 States Olympic Committee pursuant to an act of Congress of 24 the United States. 25 We are not a private self-proclaimed governing page 189 1 body. We act pursuant to an act of Congress. 2 What does the National governing body do? It has a 3 mandate. Mr. Cardozo put up on the screen the constitution 4 of the United States Soccer Federation. Also in the act of 5 Congress, it mandates what the goals and responsibilities of 6 the national governing bodies are. 7 Principally -- and I'm not going to read them all 8 to you -- but principally, our principal mission is to 9 establish national goals for the support and to encourage 10 interest and participation throughout the United States in 11 that support. 12 That is the mandate of the United States Soccer 13 Federation, and I'm confident that as this trial develops, 14 you will see that everything the Federation did was pursuant 15 to that mandate. 16 Mr. Kessler said yesterday that, well, Mr. Robbins 17 is going to say the Federation is a not-for-profit 18 corporation and that's not important. Ladies and gentlemen, 19 that's exceedingly important. The Federation is not in 20 business to make money. The Federation exists for one 21 reason only: To develop and encourage the sport of soccer 22 in the United States. 23 It is not for profit. It has no economic interest 24 in the success or failure of MLS, APSL or anything else. 25 As a matter of fact, parenthetically, Mr. Kessler page 190 1 talked a lot about how there should be two leagues. Some of 2 the funds that the Soccer Federation gets is from fees paid 3 by leagues. Division~I leagues pay more money than 4 Division~II leagues. If you carry Mr. Kessler's argument to 5 its logical conclusion, the Federation should sanction a 6 dozen Division~I leagues because then the Federation would 7 get more fees from those leagues and higher fees. 8 So if we were simply acting out of economic 9 interest, we would have sanctioned MLS; we would have 10 sanctioned APSL; we would have sanctioned everybody. We 11 didn't do it. Why didn't we do it? Because it would not 12 have been in the interest of soccer in the United States. 13 Mr. Kessler also talked about the diabolical 14 conspiracy. I guess I represent the coconspirator along 15 with MLS. The Federation allegedly conspired with MLS to 16 destroy APSL and to hurt the players. Ladies and gentlemen, 17 that is absolute nonsense. 18 The people who voted to sanction MLS as the sole 19 Division~I soccer league in the United States were the 20 members of the National Board of Directors of the 21 Federation. 22 Do you know how many of these people get paid for 23 being on the Board? Not one. They're all volunteers. They 24 are elected by their grassroots organizations, the amateurs, 25 the pros, the youth soccer, referees. In fact, the players, page 191 1 the players have a representative -- have representatives on 2 the NBOD, and one of those players, Peter Vermes, is a 3 member of the class here. He's not one of the eight named 4 players who are named as plaintiffs, but he is a member of 5 the class because he is a player in MLS. 6 Mr. Vermes voted both at the December 1993 meeting 7 and also at the January 1995 meeting where MLS was granted 8 first provisional status as the sole Division~I league, and 9 in January of '95, exclusive status for two years and only 10 two years, which I'll discuss in a little bit, but that was 11 the unanimous vote, and a member of this class, Mr. Vermes, 12 voted in favor of that. 13 Mr. Kessler spoke a lot about APSL and how that 14 league existed and how the Federation didn't treat it 15 fairly, didn't act appropriately and pushed it aside when it 16 voted to designate MLS as the sole Division~I league. 17 Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Cardozo spent a lot of 18 time on it. I'm not going to devote too much time, but I 19 have to tell you it's preposterous. 20 The APSL was a minor league. It had minor league 21 players, a lot of them. Some of them now -- a lot of them 22 are now in MLS, but the owners were not financially capable 23 of doing what was necessary to establish a first-class 24 Division~I league, which is what the Federation was 25 absolutely determined to accomplish. page 192 1 Mr. Cardozo mentioned the Olympics. Yesterday for 2 the first time the United States advanced to the second 3 round in the Olympics in soccer. It did so, we believe, 4 because it basically presented a pro team. In 1996, the 5 players were college players and they didn't do very well. 6 Now, all but one of the players on the Olympic team 7 is a professional, and they've advanced to the second round. 8 And, incidentally, 14 of those 18 players are MLS players. 9 The Federation's mandate, as I said, is to develop 10 interest and participation in soccer throughout the United 11 States internationally and nationally. Obviously, the 12 primary international competition is the Olympic 13 competition. 14 The Federation was absolutely convinced that in 15 order to develop soccer so that the United States could 16 compete on the international level, it was incredibly 17 important to have a good, solid Division~I pro league 18 because that's how you develop the players. 19 I'm not sure if this was made clear to you, but the 20 Olympic team is a conglomeration of players from all over 21 the world. They just happen to be United States citizens. 22 A lot of them play on the MLS teams. Several play in 23 Europe. I think there's one college player. 24 The only way to develop a good, strong team is 25 develop good, strong pros. The only way to develop good, page 193 1 strong pros is to have a solid Division~I league. And that 2 was the Federation's mandate. That was its goal, and that's 3 what it accomplished. 4 If APSL had been designated, the testimony will 5 show you that we would have had more of the same. It was a 6 minor league. The plan they presented was a minor league 7 plan. 8 Now, you're going to hear, I think Friday, Doctor 9 de~la~Pena by videotape deposition. He was the owner of the 10 Los Angeles APSL team. He's going to testify that he was 11 happy to have two leagues sanctioned as Division~I leagues. 12 He was happy for the competition. 13 I'm going to ask for the screen to be set up. This 14 is Plaintiffs' Exhibit 165. Would you turn to Page 5 of 15 that, please. 16 This is the APSL plan, ladies and gentlemen. You 17 see the yellow highlight, the Premier League. And the 18 Premier League was to be APSL as a Division~I league. Shall 19 be sanctioned by USSF, that's my client, and Canadian Soccer 20 Association as the only Division~I highest ranking league in 21 North America. 22 See what it says? Shall be sanctioned by the USSF 23 as the only Division~I league. That was his league, 24 Doctor~de~la~Pena's league. 25 When you hear his testimony, I ask that you page 194 1 remember that when he testifies, that he was happy to have 2 more than one Division~I league in the United States. 3 I'm going to talk a little bit now about why there 4 should be only one Division~I league. At least 5 preliminarily, Mr. Cardozo discussed with you the history of 6 soccer in the United States, of professional soccer. My 7 kids play it. I think some of your kids play it. 8 Unfortunately, despite the fact that it is by far the most 9 popular spectator sport in the world, that is true 10 everywhere but in the United States. The history has just 11 been one of failure. 12 Ladies and gentlemen, I submit to you that it would 13 have been preposterous in 1993 for the Federation to 14 sanction more than one Division~I league initially. There 15 weren't enough players. There weren't enough sponsors. 16 Certainly, God knows, there weren't enough fans, and there 17 still may not be enough fans. MLS is still struggling, as 18 Mr. Cardozo said. 19 If you had more than one league initially, the fans 20 wouldn't know where to go. Sponsors wouldn't know where to 21 go. You were doomed, both, to failure. 22 The Federation decided -- and we believe it made a 23 good faith and correct decision -- that initially there 24 would be only one Division~I league. And in 1993, as you 25 heard, the National Board of Directors voted 18 to 5 to page 195 1 sanction MLS. 2 There were two other applicants. There was an 3 application promoted by a man named Jim Paglia. That got no 4 votes. There was the application promoted by APSL. That 5 got five votes. 6 MLS got 18 votes, and those votes were by members 7 of the National Board of Directors, the people elected by 8 the grassroots soccer community of the United States, the 9 people who have no economic interest in MLS's success or 10 failure. Their only, their only goal was to do what was 11 best for soccer, and now they're accused of being part of a 12 diabolical conspiracy, not just a conspiracy but a 13 diabolical conspiracy. Mr. Kessler is simply not going to 14 be able to prove that. 15 Mr. Kessler put up a chart yesterday showing how 16 certain people from the Federation went to work for MLS. As 17 he makes his presentation throughout the trial, I want you 18 to watch that because I want you to ask yourselves how many 19 of those people voted at the board meetings in 1993 and 20 1995? And I will tell you, not one. Not one. 21 The National Board of Directors, those members, are 22 totally independent. They are not hand-selected by Alan 23 Rothenberg. To suggest that he could do that is simply 24 silly. They're elected by their own constituencies. 25 Now, you're going to hear testimony from a man page 196 1 named Lee des~Bordes. He goes by Hank des~Bordes. 2 Mr. Kessler mentioned him yesterday and said that he was 3 part of this conspiracy. 4 In 1993, Mr. des~Bordes was the executive vice 5 president of the Soccer Federation, nonpaid. Mr. des~Bordes 6 chaired the meeting in December of 1993 when the vote was 7 taken. He did that because Mr. Rothenberg, the president of 8 the Federation, was recused. He excused himself because he 9 had a conflict of interest. He was obviously promoting MLS, 10 and he stepped down. 11 Doctor de~la~Pena, who was a member of the National 12 Board of Directors, APSL's representative, also was excused. 13 Mr. des~Bordes ran that meeting, ran it fairly, 14 and, as it turned out, MLS was designated. 15 Mr. Kessler suggested, I think, that Mr. des~Bordes 16 was among the lackeys of Alan Rothenberg. The testimony 17 will show that that simply is not so. In fact, 18 Mr. des~Bordes ran against Mr. Rothenberg for president of 19 the United States Soccer Federation and was soundly 20 defeated. 21 Mr. Kessler talked about the bonus that 22 Mr. Rothenberg received from World Cup, $7 million bonus. 23 Remember that? Mr. des~Bordes voted against Mr. Rothenberg 24 getting that bonus. 25 Mr. Kessler yesterday talked about the $5 million page 197 1 loan that World Cup made to MLS. And I think he said there 2 are some good people -- in fact, one executive, I think that 3 was his word, voted against the loan to MLS. Do you know 4 who that one executive was? That was Mr. des~Bordes. 5 So Mr. des~Bordes voted against Mr. Rothenberg's 6 money. Mr. des~Bordes voted against Mr. Rothenberg's 7 salary. Mr. des~Bordes ran against Mr. Rothenberg and lost 8 for president of the Federation. And yet Mr. Rothenberg 9 believed that MLS presented the best chance for soccer's 10 future in the United States, and therefore he voted for MLS. 11 This was a fair vote. It was done in a nonpartisan 12 manner. Nobody was trying to screw APSL. 13 Mr. Kessler spoke yesterday about the resolution. 14 Remember the 1991 resolution that he flashed up on the board 15 that said that APSL will have the first opportunity to post 16 a letter of intent to become a Division~I league? I guess 17 he's arguing that that meant two years later, regardless of 18 any change in circumstances, APSL had to be given an 19 automatic sanction as Division~I soccer in the United 20 States. If that's what he's arguing, think about that. 21 That would be totally against the mandate of the Federation. 22 The Federation is required to do what's in the best interest 23 of soccer. 24 If APSL didn't have the best presentation and 25 didn't have the best plan and nevertheless was chosen by the page 198 1 Soccer Federation to be the Division~I league, that would 2 have been totally contrary to the Soccer Federation's 3 mandate. 4 APSL was not shut out of the process. The 5 Federation's benchmarks for Division~I were circulated to 6 the soccer community. Everybody who showed an interest in 7 submitting a proposal to be sanctioned as Division~I was 8 given all the information that was necessary. 9 Everybody who wanted to make a presentation was 10 permitted to make a presentation. Mr. de~la~Pena's group 11 made their pitch and they were rejected. They were rejected 12 on the merits. And the testimony -- I'm not going to repeat 13 what Mr. Cardozo said, but the testimony on the merits will 14 show clearly that the Major League Soccer presentation was 15 by far the best, and that's why it was chosen. 16 I want to talk a little bit about Mr. Rothenberg 17 because Mr. Kessler has cast him, I guess, as the principal 18 villain of this piece. And I feel comfortable doing this 19 now because Mr. Rothenberg is not the president of the 20 organization which I'm representing. The Federation doesn't 21 have an economic interest in the success or failure of MLS. 22 Ladies and gentlemen, I think you will hear from 23 the testimony that Mr. Rothenberg, far from being a 24 diabolical conspirator, truly is a visionary with respect to 25 soccer in the United States. page 199 1 I don't think that anybody is going to be able to 2 say that anyone has done more for soccer over the last 50 3 years than what Mr. Rothenberg has done. And for him to be 4 cast as a -- as diabolical I really believe is beyond the 5 pale. 6 And I think as you listen carefully to the 7 testimony and watch the witnesses, their demeanor, what they 8 say, read the documents carefully and not the snippets that 9 we're presenting to you now but read them all, take them in 10 context, I think you will see that MLS, which I don't 11 represent did anything wrong, the Federation certainly did 12 nothing wrong. 13 Just to close -- I'm trying to take as little of 14 your time as possible, which I'm sure you'll appreciate -- 15 MLS is a nonprofit corporation. It doesn't make a dime from 16 MLS, outside of being paid the fees that MLS pays as the 17 Division~I league. It had no economic interest to become 18 part of the conspiracy to monopolize. It only wanted to do 19 what was best for soccer in the United States. 20 The members of the National Board of Directors are 21 volunteers. For them to be cast as conspirators is, 22 frankly, insulting. They tried to do what was right. In 23 fact, they tried to be so reasonable that they only gave MLS 24 exclusivity for two years. 25 The documents will show on January -- I think it page 200 1 was January 29th of 1995, the Board voted unanimously -- 2 and, again, the Board consisted of members of the grassroots 3 organization, including players and a member of this 4 class -- voted in favor of that unanimous resolution that 5 MLS would be given exclusivity for only two years. 6 As of July of 1997, anybody who wanted to apply for 7 Division~I status could have done so. They haven't. But 8 MLS is not a monopoly. The Federation is not part of any 9 conspiracy to monopolize. As you listen to the testimony, 10 I'm sure you'll find that to be the case. 11 At the end of the trial, I'm confident that you 12 will find that the complaint against USSF should be 13 dismissed. 14 There's just one more thing I'd like to say. The 15 plaintiffs obviously go first in this case. It's their 16 burden. Now, they're going to put on their witnesses and 17 their case. And it may sound pretty good to you, but, 18 remember, the defendants have a chance to put on a case as 19 well, and I'm just going to ask you to keep an open mind 20 until the very end after I've had a chance to put on my 21 presentation, after Mr. Cardozo has his chance to put on his 22 presentation. 23 Now, there may be quite a few witnesses that I 24 don't cross-examine because I think that the material will 25 have been covered, and I assume you don't want me to get up page 201 1 and talk just to hear myself speak. This case is going to 2 be long enough as it is. 3 If I don't cross-examine, please don't think that 4 I'm not paying attention. I am. It's just that I think 5 that the material has been covered sufficiently to protect 6 my client. 7 So with that, I'm going to close. I thank you very 8 much for your attention. I know how difficult it is to sit 9 and listen to us for the next however long it's going to be. 10 The parties really appreciate it. 11 There's a quotation in the building downstairs as 12 you walk through -- you see all those carved-out 13 quotations -- one of them, I think, is very, very apropos 14 here. To paraphrase it, the reason we have trials is to 15 keep us all from killing ourselves -- killing each other. 16 We don't want to see these players go against the 17 owners because that would be unfair. We have to have a 18 chance. The testimony and the documents will show clearly 19 that there is no case here and it should be dismissed. 20 Thank you very much.