page 1886

 1   on the National Board of Directors in 1993?
 2   A   Well, the other three that were representatives on the
 3   Board as members of the APSL were Cornelia Corbett, Martin
 4   Nixdorf and Amancio Suarez.  Mr. Davis was working in the
 5   APSL at the time but was on our Board as Olympic
 6   representative, athlete representative.
 7   Q   So this heading under Olympic Representatives, these
 8   were people that were also on the Board?
 9   A   That's correct.
10   Q   And who was Rick Davis again?
11   A   At that time, he was general manager and possibly coach
12   of the LA Salsa.  He was a former National Team captain,
13   National Team player, professional player.
14   Q   Okay.
15            Let me just go down to the bottom here on
16   representing national affiliate and associate members.
17            What is this national affiliate members?
18   A   Those are a couple of the affiliate members that I
19   mentioned up here.  The first one was the American Youth
20   Soccer Organization.  Soccer Association for Youth is what I
21   labeled SAY.
22            And I mentioned there were a couple of others.
23   Futsal was one, Soccer Industry Council of America was
24   another affiliate member.  And, actually, the last two
25   represented a number of associate members who, amongst

page 1887

 1   themselves, decided who would represent them on the Board.
 2            So you might have had a Soccer for Israel or the
 3   Macabee [ph.] Games Group.  You have representation for
 4   Armed Services.
 5            So six or seven small groups would have designated
 6   those two as their representatives.  And particular
 7   affiliations that are listed are their direct affiliations.
 8   Q   This US Futsal Group, is that the group that, I think it
 9   was Mr. Bowers said, was not regulated by FIFA?
10   A   No, Futsal is -- there's a world championship in Futsal.
11   It's an indoor soccer game that FIFA has.  The FIFA Futsal
12   World Championship is going to be played next month in
13   Guatemala.
14   Q   And, in any event, Mr. Para was the representative from
15   the US Futsal organization?
16   A   Yes, he was.
17   Q   What about --
18                 MR. CARDOZO:  If we can just blow this whole
19   page up, now.
20   Q   Do any representatives from the World Cup --
21   A   World Cup doesn't have representation at the Soccer
22   Federation.
23   Q   Why not?
24   A   They weren't a constituent member of the Soccer
25   Federation.

page 1888

 1   Q   Now, can any one organization control the National Board
 2   of Directors?
 3                 MR. KESSLER:  Objection, your Honor.
 4                 THE COURT:  No, you may answer it.
 5   A   You've got in those different groups people that are
 6   elected by very different bodies.  If you just look at that
 7   big block of people that are regional directors starting
 8   with Mr. Watson, Mr. Watson is elected by somewhere between
 9   13 and 16 states who have three or four representatives that
10   come to a meeting.
11            So there's a region of fifty people voting.  It's a
12   different 50 people that select Mr. Polley and that select
13   Mr. Skirvin and the Mr. Rojas.  You've got different
14   emphases in different parts of the country.
15            The same is true for the youth representatives
16   starting with Mr. Palmeiro, who is from Rhode Island and has
17   been there a number of years.  So these people are elected
18   by completely different groups.
19            Some of the national positions above that --
20   Q   Before you get to the national positions, so who are the
21   50 or so people that elected, for example, Mr. Palmeiro?
22            Where do they come from?
23   A   Mr. Palmeiro -- they come from states as far south as
24   West Virginia, as far north as Maine, as far west as
25   Pennsylvania.

page 1889

 1            So, roughly, I think it's 15 or 16 state
 2   associations.  New York is split into two.  DC is combined
 3   with Virginia, have three or four delegates to the Region I
 4   meeting, whenever that's held, and there may be two or three
 5   of those.
 6            And every couple of years they elect a Region I
 7   director.  Mr. Watson is that director.
 8   Q   And the same thing is true of all these other groups?
 9   A   Different geographic part of the country; by one or two,
10   a different number of state associations, but, yes.
11   Q   Going down to the bottom of this page, again, if we can,
12   with respect to the national affiliate members and the
13   associate members, who votes for them?
14   A   Well, Mr. Haimes was, at the time, I think, president or
15   chairman of AYSO, so it would have been as head of that
16   organization.
17            I'm not sure if Mr. Mason was chairman or not, but
18   he was designated by the Soccer Associate for Youth.
19            Mr. Para for many years been head of Futsal.
20            And last two, as I mentioned, were selected by --
21   I'm not sure how many associate members we had, but, six,
22   seven, eight, nine, ten in that region that would have
23   selected these two as their representatives.
24   Q   How are the Olympic representatives chosen, what's
25   called Olympic representatives?  How are they chosen?

page 1890

 1   A   As we mentioned early, we have, under the Amateur Sports
 2   Act, a requirement that 20 percent of our decision-making
 3   body be comprised of, essentially, of elite athletes, of
 4   players who have played in the Olympics or on the National
 5   Team -- the National Team is the All-Star Team of American
 6   nationals in the last ten years.  So it can't be somebody
 7   that's played in the '50s.
 8            It's to give the players a voice, as they're
 9   required to do, under the Amateur Sports Act and under the
10   USOC constitution.  At that period of time, those players --
11   or at some point in time prior to their being on the
12   Board -- would have been nominated by the president, subject
13   to confirmation by the Board or nominated by the Board,
14   subject to confirmation by the president, something like
15   that, and then elected by other elite athletes.
16   Q   Other elite athletes meaning -- how is that defined?
17   A   The same way.  Players who played in the Olympics in the
18   last ten years or the National Teams.  The players that
19   played in Sydney for us last week or two weeks ago, the men
20   and woman, were part of that group, if we were doing it
21   today.
22            Back then, obviously, it would have been players
23   who played the 1988 games or '84 games or in the World Cup
24   in '90, or whatever it might be.
25   Q   Just going from the bottom, were any of the people

page 1891

 1   representing the national affiliate members or representing
 2   associate members, were any of those people appointed by
 3   Mr. Rothenberg?
 4   A   No.
 5   Q   Were any of the representatives of the Professional
 6   Division appointed by Mr. Rothenberg?
 7   A   No.
 8                 MR. CARDOZO:  You can scroll up.
 9   Q   Were any of the people -- were any of the people in this
10   group appointed by Mr. Rothenberg?
11   A   The coaching committee chair, the last two spots that
12   are mentioned there, those two chairpersons of committees at
13   that time were, again, they were nominated by the president
14   or nominated by the Board are non-voting members of the
15   Board, and they were not elected at that time except by the
16   Board itself or approved by the Board.
17                 MR. CARDOZO:  If we can skip down to the
18   Olympic athletes again.
19   Q   Were any of the Olympic representatives listed here
20   appointed by Mr. Rothenberg?
21   A   No.  I've outlined the method for those.  The president
22   and the Board -- I don't remember the exact formulation of
23   who nominates and who approves -- nominate athletes, and
24   those are voted on by other elite athletes.
25            Some of those -- some of those people had served

page 1892

 1   prior to Mr. Rothenberg being around as president.
 2   Q   We will review that again a little bit later.
 3                 MR. CARDOZO:  If you can back up to the very
 4   top then.
 5   Q   First of all, Mr. Fricker, how did -- did Mr. Rothenberg
 6   appoint Mr. Fricker to the Board?
 7   A   In a matter of speaking, by beating him in an election,
 8   I guess, and he served as past president.  Mr. Fricker was
 9   one of the two defeated candidates in 1990.
10   Q   Did Mr. Rothenberg appoint Doctor de la Pena to the
11   Board?
12   A   No, he did not.
13   Q   How would he have been selected?
14   A   At that time, by the Professional Division which was
15   comprised of the APSL.  So it would have been serving as the
16   representative of the APSL.
17   Q   Now, the name above Doctor de la Pena, I understand,
18   people refer to him as Doctor Bob; is that right?
19   A   Much easier than the trying to get the last name right.
20   Yes, Doctor Bob.
21   Q   How was he selected?
22   A   By those 55 state associations that manage youth soccer,
23   three or four delegates apiece.
24   Q   And the gentleman above him, how was he selected?
25   A   Mr. Borroni, in the same way, by those state

page 1893

 1   associations that oversee amateur soccer, players above the
 2   age of 19.
 3   Q   How was Mr. Groff selected?
 4   A   By the National Council, four or five, 600 people.
 5   Q   And Mr. des Bordes?
 6   A   In the same way, by the National Council.
 7   Q   By the way, had there ever been an election between
 8   Mr. des Bordes and Mr. Rothenberg?
 9   A   There was an election that both were involved in in 1994
10   for the presidency of the Soccer Federation.
11   Q   They ran against each other?
12   A   Yes.  In fact, all three of these people ran for that
13   spot, the top three people.
14   Q   So Mr. Groff, Mr. des Bordes and Mr. Rothenberg ran
15   against each other in 1994?
16   A   Yes.
17   Q   Who won?
18   A   Mr. Rothenberg.
19   Q   By the way, going back to Mr. Fricker, did he run
20   against Mr. Rothenberg in 1990?
21   A   He did, yes.
22   Q   He had been president in 1988?
23   A   Mr. Fricker had been president for six years as of 1990.
24   Q   And so he would have a seat on the Board for how long as
25   immediate past president?

page 1894

 1   A   As long as he was immediate past president, so as long
 2   as the person who defeated him, Mr. Rothenberg was
 3   president, Mr. Fricker would serve as immediate past
 4   president.
 5   Q   By the way, in these campaigns that you described, are
 6   there sort of informal campaign managers, such as we've been
 7   reading about in the newspaper on the national level the
 8   last month or so?
 9   A   In some cases informal; in other cases, a little bit
10   more formal, yes, sure.
11   Q   Do you recall who the campaign manager was for
12   Mr. Fricker in 1990 when he ran against Mr. Rothenberg?
13   A   Well, I didn't use the title, but it was me.
14   Q   You were Mr. Fricker's campaign manager?
15   A   Yes.
16   Q   How did he do?
17   A   Not as well as I would have liked.  We didn't win.
18   Q   Okay.
19            Now, this asterisk next to some of the people we've
20   looked at, if you scroll it down to the bottom as well, what
21   does the asterisk denote?
22   A   These are members of the Executive Committee, which,
23   again, I didn't put on the board.  It would have cluttered
24   it too much.  It's a subset of the Board.
25   Q   And what's the role of the executive committee?

page 1895

 1   A   It acts in place of the Board and is empowered by the
 2   Board in the National Council.  It can -- because it's
 3   smaller, it can meet more often either telephonically or in
 4   person.
 5   Q   If I may, Mr. Gulati, I would like to show you now
 6   Defendants' Exhibit 1049.
 7            Could you tell us what that is?
 8   A   I'm sorry?
 9   Q   Can you tell us what that is?
10   A   It's a similar document, the Administrative Rulebook,
11   the Official Administrative Rulebook for 1988-'89.
12   Q   What year?
13   A   '88.  And it doesn't say '89, but our season starts
14   September 1st.
15                 MR. CARDOZO:  I offer it in evidence.
16                 MR. KESSLER:  No objection.
17                 THE CLERK:  Marked and entered.
18            (Defendants' Exhibit No. 1049 received in
19            evidence.)
20   Q   Can you take a look at the inside page that lists the
21   athletic representatives at that time?
22   A   Yes.
23   Q   Mr. Davis in 1988 was one of the Olympic
24   representatives; is that right?
25   A   He was.

page 1896

 1   Q   And who was president of the USSF at this point in time?
 2   A   Mr. Fricker.
 3   Q   Was Mr. Davis still on the Board in 1993?
 4   A   Yes, he was.
 5   Q   Now, Mr. Lawson, who had nominated him, if you will?
 6   A   The Board or Mr. Fricker.  I don't think it would have
 7   gone before Mr. Fricker.
 8   Q   And he was still on the Board in 1993, right?
 9   A   Yes, he was.
10   Q   And skipping down, Mr. Aly, A-L-Y, he was on the Board
11   in 1988?
12   A   Yes, he was.
13   Q   And he's still on the Board in 1993?
14   A   That's correct.
15   Q   And who nominated him, if you will?
16   A   Again, it would have been Mr. Fricker or the Board of
17   Directors.
18   Q   In any event, these three people were not nominated by
19   Mr. Rothenberg; is that right?
20   A   They couldn't have been.
21   Q   Now, to the best of your knowledge, once you get on the
22   Board as athletic representative, how long do you stay?
23   A   It -- now there is a two-year term.  The athlete group
24   has become much more organized.  Back then in the '80s and
25   '90s, I think you stayed on until either you asked to be

page 1897

 1   removed because of time -- I can recall one such case -- or
 2   because your ten years, you're no longer eligible to serve
 3   because you're now more than ten years away from your last
 4   participation in one of our Olympic or National teams.
 5            I don't think we had periodic elections at that
 6   time unless it was to fill a seat.
 7   Q   If we can go back to the 1993 Board, Exhibit 150,
 8   Plaintiffs' Exhibit 150, again, the members of the Board.
 9            Could Mr. Rothenberg, in your view, have influenced
10   the decisions of these people?
11                 MR. KESSLER:  Objection, your Honor.
12                 THE COURT:  Sustained.
13   Q   Were these people independently elected, Mr. Gulati?
14   A   Yes, they were.
15   Q   And as you look, it might be easier to look at the full
16   document, how many people had some association one way or
17   another with the APSL who were on the Board?
18   A   A direct association, five.
19   Q   Who were they?
20   A   Doctor de La Pena, Ms. Corbett, Mr. Nixdorf, Mr. Suarez,
21   and Mr. Davis.
22   Q   How many had a relationship of any kind with MLS?
23            (Pause in proceedings.)
24   A   Mr. Rothenberg.
25   Q   Anybody else?

page 1898

 1   A   No.
 2   Q   Now, why is it, Mr. Gulati, that the rules of the USSF
 3   are set up so that you have to have a lot of involvement in
 4   soccer in order to get on the National Board of Directors?
 5   A   It's not a rule that you have to have a lot of
 6   involvement, but you're not going to get elected unless
 7   you're involved with some part of the game.
 8            People are going to want somebody that knows about
 9   the game, they know personally, in most cases.  And a number
10   of these positions, there's some sort of informal
11   campaigning.
12            But you're being asked to serve on a Board of an
13   organization that oversees soccer in the United States.  It
14   would be silly to have a lot of people who don't know about
15   the sport in the US.
16   Q   You explained to Mr. Kessler the other day that you
17   were, at one point in time, on the constitution or rules
18   committee of the USSF?
19   A   The constitutional commission, at one point, yes.
20   Q   Did the commission ever consider that as a requirement
21   of being on the National Board of Directors you should have
22   no relationship with any other aspects of soccer?
23   A   I don't remember any such ...
24   Q   Would you have favored any such proposal?
25                 MR. KESSLER:  Objection.

page 1899

 1                 THE COURT:  Sustained.
 2                 MR. CARDOZO:  Okay.
 3   Q   By the way, how much are you paid?
 4            How much is someone paid to be on the National
 5   Board of Directors?
 6   A   No one is paid to be on the Board of Directors.
 7   Q   How much is one paid to be on the National Council?
 8   A   No one is paid to be on the National Council.
 9   Q   Where do the people receive there compensation to go to
10   all these meetings?
11   A   All of the people that are involved in these
12   organizations at the National Council and National Board are
13   volunteers in their roles here.  So they have other jobs or
14   they're retired or they're -- it's not too many that are
15   independently wealthy or -- so they're either retired or
16   they have other jobs.
17   Q   Okay.
18            Now, I'm not sure I asked you this.  What is the
19   role of the executive committee?  You identified members but
20   what's the role of it?
21   A   It acts in place of the Board.  It's a subset of the
22   Board.
23   Q   How often do they meet, do you know?
24   A   Right now, it's almost monthly by telephone.  I don't
25   recall how often it was back then.

page 1900

 1   Q   Okay.
 2            Now, putting aside how people are elected and who
 3   they represent, what is it that USSF does?
 4            Can you give us a feel for that?
 5   A   It does a number of different things.  The USSF, or it's
 6   constituent members, are involved in every phase of the
 7   game.
 8            So at one level you're going to have a state
 9   association that might have a coaching manual for under
10   eight players.  So it might be a document of how parents who
11   are just becoming involved in the game that have no
12   experience should start to train their young players and
13   whether it's not to yell too much during games or whether
14   they should play on smaller fields.  At another level, you
15   might have the same thing for referees.
16            At a very different level, you could have, How we
17   would get our best Connecticut All-Star team or
18   Massachusetts All-Star team put together to compete against
19   the California team.
20            And, obviously, at another level you have, How do
21   we get the best 18 or 20 players and give them a training
22   program to compete in the Olympics.  All of those areas and,
23   obviously, trying to raise money to try to do some of these
24   things and so on.
25            So it's involved from the grassroots to the World

page 1901

 1   Cup, men's side, women's side.
 2   Q   Now, in recent years, there has been some -- has there
 3   been any progress in developing US soccer internationally,
 4   in your view?
 5   A   The answer is yes.  Clearly, in the last 10, 15, 20
 6   years, we've made a lot of progress.
 7            Our teams have achieved more recognition, and I
 8   mean recognition both through their on-field performances
 9   and through the media than ever before.
10            Obviously, our Women's National Team is the world
11   champion.  We got the Silver Medal a couple of weeks ago in
12   Sydney, but are defending world champions.  Our men's
13   Olympic team did better than they've ever done.
14            We had a youth team, our Under 17 Team, did better
15   than any youth team that that age group has ever done.
16            Our indoor teams have won the world championship --
17   I'm sorry, have finished second and third.  They didn't win
18   it.
19            So in the last decade, the performance of National
20   Teams is better than any time in the history of the Soccer
21   Federation.
22   Q   And all of these activities are run under the auspices
23   of the USSF?
24   A   That's correct.
25   Q   What is the annual budget of the Federation?

page 1902

 1   A   Currently, it's about $30 million.
 2   Q   Where does that money come from?
 3   A   A number of different sources.  Today, the two biggest
 4   ones are sponsorship revenues, companies that pay,
 5   essentially, to get identification with the USSF or
 6   commercials on games that are on television.
 7            And, secondly, National Team games.  We charge for
 8   everyone the National Team plays against, Brazil and so on.
 9   Those aren't necessarily money-making, but they're a revenue
10   source.
11            And the third biggest is membership dues.  So
12   coming back to this diagram, that Under-Eight player pays X
13   dollars to participate for referees, for the league fees,
14   for field use and all that.  Fifty cents of what he pays or
15   she pays goes to the Soccer Federation as part of that
16   30 million.  And the amateurs, it's a different amount than
17   the pros.  It's a different amounts.
18   Q   What does the USSF do with all this money?
19   A   Institutes a number of those programs that I mentioned
20   early.  The biggest is around players, player development,
21   especially at the elite level, because it leaves the
22   grassroots work to be done by its constituent members.
23            Just the way that local governance works, the
24   school system is run locally, but education policy, if you
25   will, the National Team are organized and directly funded by

page 1903

 1   USSF.  Referee programs, coaching programs, medical
 2   programs, we have had a big initiative recently about safety
 3   in soccer.  So all of these things.
 4   Q   Now, before we leave the subject of how the USSF is
 5   organized, I want to ask you a question about Nike.
 6            Mr. Kessler asked you some questions about when you
 7   were involved with the USSF, at one level you did something
 8   in connection with Nike.
 9            Could you explain what it is that you had done?
10   A   Well, I have done a lot of things with Nike.  They're a
11   big player in the sport now.
12            What Mr. Kessler was asking about was when Mark
13   Abbott and I had written a few pages, six, seven, eight
14   pages, kind of an overview of the possibility of women's
15   soccer in the United States.  It was some years ago, four or
16   five years ago that we wrote at the request of Nike.
17   Q   Did this have something to do with the NSA review
18   committee?
19   A   We had a group in 1996-'97 after the Olympics in Atlanta
20   that was talking about trying to start a women's soccer
21   league.  In the process of that, they were talking to a
22   number of potential investors or potential sponsors.  One of
23   them was Nike.
24            Nike asked, I think Mr. Abbott specifically, since
25   he had been involved in the MLS startup, how -- what he

page 1904

 1   thought about this.  And that led to us writing a short
 2   document at the request of the president of Nike at the
 3   time.
 4   Q   Did you consider you had some kind of conflict of
 5   interest in preparing that document?
 6   A   The largest contractor in economic terms from American
 7   companies asked us to outline what we thought about starting
 8   a women's professional soccer league, the best way to do it.
 9            So I don't think there was any conflict whatsoever.
10   Q   Okay.  Let me move to a different subject, Mr. Gulati.
11   I want to ask you about the World Cup.
12            Before I start, let me ask, what is FIFA?
13   A   FIFA is the acronym that -- the initials of the
14   international governing body for soccer in the world.
15   Q   How many members is FIFA comprised of?
16   A   Just over 200 at this stage.
17   Q   Is one of those members the United States?
18   A   The United States Soccer Federation is a member of FIFA,
19   yes.
20   Q   What does FIFA do?
21   A   In the same way that the Soccer Federation has
22   responsibilities for the number of issues that I outlined in
23   the US, FIFA has that internationally.
24            So, at one level, it also puts out development
25   programs, especially for developing countries, less so for

page 1905

 1   Germany than there might be for a country that's less
 2   developed in soccer terms.  At the other end of the
 3   spectrum, it owns the World Cup.  It's responsible for World
 4   Cup.
 5   Q   What is the World Cup?  We heard a lot of talk about it.
 6   A   It's the world championship of soccer.  It's a process
 7   that a very large percentage of those 200 plus members
 8   participate in at one level or another in qualifying games.
 9            The US is in a qualifying game tomorrow.
10            So you have 180 or 190, 170 or whatever teams that
11   participate in it at one level, playing through various
12   stages of the competition to a final event.  When people
13   generally talk about the World Cup, they're talking about
14   that final tournament.
15            And that is -- today it's a 32-team event.  It's
16   been -- I don't know what it was in the '40s or '50s or '60s
17   or '70s, but as late it's a 16-team event of the National
18   Teams, which is the All-Star teams, the Dream Teams, if you
19   will, of each of the participating countries, and you play
20   for the world championship.
21   Q   How often is the World Cup held?
22   A   Once every four years.
23   Q   And how is it decided who those 32 --
24            I guess it's 32 teams now?
25   A   That's correct.

page 1906

 1   Q   How is it decided which 32 teams get to participate?
 2   A   Well, out of the 32 -- and the next World Cup will be in
 3   Japan and Korea -- it's been tradition for quite some time
 4   to have the host be an automatic participant.
 5            So in this case, we have two hosts, so both Korea
 6   and Japan automatically qualify.
 7            It's been tradition for quite some time that
 8   defending champion automatically qualifies.  So France,
 9   which won the last World Cup, is in.
10            The other 29 participants have to qualify based on
11   geography, which a number of teams will qualify from Europe,
12   some from North American, Central American and the
13   Carribean, which is where we participate, some from south
14   America, Africa and so on.
15   Q   How is it determined where the 32 -- let's say Japan and
16   Korea, that you just mentioned.  How is it decided where
17   that tournament will be held every four years?
18   A   FIFA makes that decision.
19   Q   When was the World Cup held in the United States?
20   A   In 1994.
21   Q   And so it was FIFA that decided to award the World Cup
22   to the United States in 1994?
23   A   That's correct.
24   Q   And how many people watched the final rounds?
25   A   Sold just over 3 million tickets for the World Cup that

page 1907

 1   was in the US.
 2   Q   What about television audience?  Do you have any idea?
 3   A   A number that's always used for the finals, more than a
 4   billion viewers watched it.  There's also a cumulative that
 5   in excess of ten billion.  But if one person watches 40
 6   games, it gets kind of thwarted.
 7   Q   I want to ask you some questions about how the United
 8   States got to host the tournament in 1994.
 9            When is it, do you know, that FIFA decided to award
10   the World Cup to the United States?
11   A   July 4, 1988.
12   Q   July 4, 1998 --
13   A   1988.
14   Q   '88.  FIFA decided that six years later the World Cup
15   would be held in the United States?
16   A   Yes.
17            In FIFA, it's generally six years in advance unless
18   there's an emergency situation, because you need -- FIFA
19   views that as the minimum time you need to get ready.
20   Q   Had the US ever hosted the World Cup before?
21   A   No.
22   Q   What's the process by which a country gets awarded the
23   World Cup?
24            Does FIFA just decide the United States, this is
25   for you?

page 1908

 1   A   No.  It's a competitive process.  Sometimes -- probably
 2   about eight years prior to a particular World Cup, FIFA will
 3   ask for bids, and they'll put out some specifications of
 4   what you need if you want to bid.
 5            And countries that want to bid for the World Cup
 6   submit applications and do the requisite lobbying of people
 7   that are eventually going to decide, and that's probably a
 8   year-and-a-half-to-two-year process, in some cases longer,
 9   and then FIFA makes a decision.
10   Q   And did you have anything to do with the application the
11   United States submitted to FIFA in connection with the '94
12   World Cup?
13   A   I did.
14   Q   What did you do?
15   A   I was involved in the working group that put together
16   our bid.
17   Q   Who did you work with?
18   A   Mr. Fricker, a gentleman named Scott LeTellier and a
19   number of people from a consulting company in Washington.
20   Q   Now, Mr. Fricker at this time was president of the USSF?
21   A   He was.
22   Q   Who was Mr. LeTellier?
23   A   Mr. LeTellier involved in the Soccer Federation for many
24   years, had been involved in the sport, had been involved in
25   the '84 Olympics.

page 1909

 1            And Mr. Fricker asked Mr. LeTellier to be what was
 2   effectively the principal author of our World Cup bid.
 3   Q   How -- is this a two- or three-page letter that you sent
 4   to FIFA?
 5   A   No, it's a two -- in our case, it was two letter-bound
 6   volumes, hundreds of pages, stadium contracts, a letter from
 7   the President, and probably letters from various departments
 8   of the US Government, stating specifications, ticketing
 9   plan, everything.
10   Q   And when would this document have been submitted to
11   FIFA, approximately?
12   A   I'm not sure when the -- late '87, early '88.  They
13   would have -- it would have been forwarded ten months in
14   advance after the documents are submitted.
15            Then they look at the venues.  They travel to each
16   of the venues and make sure you're doing everything you said
17   you could do.
18   Q   And did Mr. Rothenberg have anything to do with this
19   application?
20   A   Not that I'm aware of, no.
21   Q   At the time this application was submitted to FIFA in
22   1988, had you ever met Mr. Rothenberg?
23   A   No.
24   Q   Did you know who he was?
25   A   I did not.

page 1910

 1   Q   Now, how much time did you spend putting this document
 2   together that you said was two or three bound volumes?
 3   A   I don't know.  I mean, this is a dozen years ago.  So in
 4   some weeks, it would have been virtually nothing.  Other
 5   weeks, it could have been a lot more, but I don't
 6   specifically recall how many hours.
 7   Q   Had you been involved in a World Cup application before
 8   this?
 9   A   Yes.
10   Q   When was that?
11   A   In 1983.
12   Q   Did the United States make an application for the World
13   Cup in 1983 as well?
14   A   Yes.
15            It was on an emergency basis.  We made an
16   application in 1983 for the 1986 -- I think it was '83 for
17   the 1986 World Cup.
18   Q   I assume that was not successful?
19   A   We didn't host it.
20   Q   Was Mr. Rothenberg involved in that?
21   A   No, he was not.
22   Q   Now, with respect to the 1988 application, was Henry
23   Kissinger involved?
24   A   Doctor Kissinger had been on a board or an advisor to
25   the bid effort.  He was a well-known gentleman.  He wasn't

page 1911

 1   working diligently on our bid documents, but he had some
 2   involvement, yes.
 3   Q   Who was he?  What was his background, for those of us
 4   who may not remember, Mr. Gulati?
 5   A   He was the former Secretary of State.
 6   Q   Before that, do you know what he did?
 7            Before he was in government, do you know what he
 8   did?
 9   A   I think he was a professor, but I'm not sure.
10   Q   He was a professor at Harvard?  Does that ring a bell?
11   A   No.
12   Q   Okay.
13            Was he a soccer fan, do you know?
14   A   Yes.
15            Those of us who have been around him have been
16   regaled with stories of when he was soccer player and soccer
17   fan, how he used to skip school to go and play soccer.
18   Q   Now, let's move up to what happened after the United
19   States was awarded the World Cup.
20            That was July 4, 1988?
21   A   That's correct.
22   Q   Now, what did this mean to US soccer that in 1988 the US
23   had been granted the World Cup?
24   A   Well, it meant at some point in the future we were going
25   to host what was the premier soccer event in the world.  We

page 1912

 1   hoped it would help us elevate interest in the game in the
 2   United States.
 3   Q   Why did you hope -- what was the connection between the
 4   World Cup and getting heightened interest in US soccer?
 5   A   It's, I think -- we're trying to raise awareness of
 6   soccer at the sport at a high level, or any level, having
 7   the world premier event.
 8            I think having the Superbowl in Boston would raise
 9   the awareness of professional football in the United States.
10   That was the general idea.
11   Q   So what is it -- after the USSF got awarded the World
12   Cup, what is it that they had to do?
13   A   Immediately after or in order --
14   Q   Well, just -- just describe generally what steps had to
15   be taken between 1988 and 1994.
16   A   You've got a multiple-city event.  And that -- in 1988,
17   I don't know how many we were proposing, but it ended up
18   being nine cities.
19            So you are going to put on major events.  It's
20   nine-plus Superbowls, if you think of it that way.  You've
21   got everything from hiring hundreds of staff people,
22   thousands of volunteers, a communication system that is
23   going to link all of those people and be able to link
24   worldwide.
25            You've got tens of thousands, if not hundreds of

page 1913

 1   thousands, of visitors that are going to be coming to those
 2   venues.  We had an accommodation bureau.  We had a travel
 3   service set up.  We had huge security issues.  We had
 4   interaction with a number of different departments in the
 5   federal government and state government.  Some of the big
 6   ones, obviously, regarding security.
 7            Soccer has had a problem in some parts of the world
 8   with fan violence.  All of that.
 9            You had to generate a TV signal that was going to
10   be seen in the rest of the world.  We had to get these games
11   on TV if you were going to popularize the sport here.
12            You had stadium contracts.  You had stadium
13   redesigns.  A number of football stadiums where we played
14   were not big enough field-wise for soccer.  So we had
15   construction issues.  We had some modifications that FIFA
16   made to help deal with those.
17            It's on par with putting on a, you know, a number
18   of Superbowls.  Different languages, people coming from
19   different countries, over a 30-day period rather than a
20   one-day event.
21   Q   So did the USSF take care of all these details?
22   A   No -- well, the USSF was the one who was given the World
23   Cup.  It set up an organizing committee to do that.
24   Q   Now, after the World Cup was awarded in 1988, who formed
25   the separate organizing committee?

page 1914

 1   A   After we were given the World Cup, it was Mr. Fricker.
 2   Q   And why -- do you have an understanding why he set up a
 3   separate committee?
 4   A   Well, it's been tradition to do that to the previous
 5   World Cup, but the major issue at that time was to shield
 6   the Soccer Federation from liability.
 7            There had been some event previously that had done
 8   very badly.  Others had done well.  But Mr. Fricker wanted
 9   to shield the Federation, and the Board wanted to shield
10   itself, I guess, from liability.
11   Q   Why was there a concern about liability?
12   A   We had just been awarded the World Cup, and we were just
13   given the rights to host this huge party, and we weren't
14   sure exactly who was going to turn up for the games, what TV
15   audiences were going to be like.
16            In short, whether we were going to make money or
17   lose money on it, and that was a big risk when FIFA awarded
18   us the World Cup, and continued to be a big risk for many
19   years.
20   Q   What was the ultimate outcome?  Was there liability to
21   whoever it was who hosted it?
22   A   Eventually, there was a surplus.
23   Q   Was that -- what amount, do you recall?
24   A   In the neighborhood of $65 million.
25   Q   Was that more or less than had been originally

page 1915

 1   anticipated?
 2   A   The original anticipation back then was that we not lose
 3   money.  So the target in '88 internally was that we would
 4   break even.
 5   Q   Who besides Mr. Fricker initially was involved in the
 6   organizing committee?
 7   A   I'm not sure that we had a group called the "Organizing
 8   Committee," but in the Board it was Mr. Fricker, I believe,
 9   Mr. des Bordes, and Mr. Paul Stiehl, who was treasurer of
10   the Soccer Federation at the time.
11            So the three nationally elected officers of the
12   Soccer Federation.
13   Q   And Mr. des Bordes, that's the same gentlemen that we
14   talked about who was involved in the 1993 vote for --
15   A   Same one.
16   Q   Were you involved in these early stages in doing
17   anything with the World Cup?
18   A   Yes.  I wasn't on the Board, but that's why I said we
19   didn't have an organizing committee as such.  I had been
20   involved in the bid efforts, and there were half a dozen,
21   maybe ten, people that were informally involved even at that
22   early stage of advising Mr. Fricker, talking to
23   Mr. LeTellier, whatever it might be.
24   Q   Okay.
25            Now, after Mr. Rothenberg -- when was

page 1916

 1   Mr. Rothenberg elected president of the USSF?
 2   A   1990.
 3   Q   What step -- what happened in connection with the World
 4   Cup after Mr. Rothenberg was elected?  Do you remember?
 5   A   I'm not sure what you mean by that.
 6   Q   Well, did Mr. Rothenberg continue the structure that
 7   Mr. Fricker had set up?
 8   A   I'm not sure about formally.  Clearly, Mr. Rothenberg
 9   came to be chairman of the organizing committee.  I think we
10   looked at documents last week that showed the change in
11   either corporate name or whatever, but Mr. Rothenberg came
12   to head the organizing committee.
13   Q   And what about Mr. LeTellier?  Was he still involved?
14   A   He stayed on initially as president, later as managing
15   director and chief operating officer.
16                 MR. CARDOZO:  Your Honor, this might be a good
17   place to stop.
18                 THE COURT:  All right.  Good suggestion.
19   We'll recess for the day and resume tomorrow at nine.
20            (Proceedings adjourned.)
21   
22   
23   
24   
25   

page 1917

 1                            I N D E X
 2   WITNESS:         DIRECT    CROSS    REDIRECT    RECROSS
 3   
 4   
 5   SUNIL GULATI, resumed
 6    By Mr. Kessler  1768
 7    By Mr. Cardozo          1861
 8   
 9                         E X H I B I T S
10   
11   PLAINTIFFS':
12   
13   No. 786     Demonstrative                          1769
14   No. 11      Application for Certification          1774
15   No. 14      Minutes of 12/17 meeting               1804
16   No. 253     Memorandum from Rothenberg to APSL     1822
17               owners
18   No. 258     Memo from Gazidis                      1827
19   No. 482     Memo from Gulati to Sage, Logan,       1834
20               Gazidis
21   No. 294     Document                               1848
22   No. 27      Recommendations of the Professional    1852
23               Development Committee
24   No. 150     USSF Administrative Rulebook           1877
25   
page 1918

 1   DEFENDANTS':
 2   
 3   No. 1280    Chart                                 1877
 4   No. 1049    Administrative Rulebook '88-'89       1897