2118
- GULATI -
1 Argentinean II.
2 Ben Iroha has played in England, in Nigeria, leave
3 Belgium out, but I think he played there.
4 Stern John has played in Trinidad and in England.
5 Mo Johnston has played in Scotland, primarily,
6 Scottish Premier.
7 Cobi Jones played again last night for the US has
8 played in Brazil first division, played in the English
9 Premier League.
10 Paul Keegan has played -- I'm not sure if it's
11 Irish second -- we're not sure.
12 Q If you're not sure, don't say.
13 A We won't use him.
14 I think those are most of the players from these
15 two pages.
16 Q The good news is we're halfway through the alphabet but
17 I think we have to go on. The next two pages, please.
18 A John Kerr -- he was on -- John Kerr has played in the
19 English Premier, the English I. He played in the Irish I
20 but that's not here.
21 Doctor Khumalo has played in the South African
22 Premier, the Argentinean first division.
23 Dominic Kinnear has played in Mexico.
24 Running out of room here in Mexico.
25 Frank Klopas played in Greece, played first in the
2119
- GULATI -
1 '94 World Cup.
2 Roman Kosecki, Roman has played in Spain, in
3 Poland, couple other places that I don't recall. So we
4 won't use those.
5 Lubos Kubik has played in the Czech first division
6 and the Czech second division, has played in France and in
7 Germany.
8 Alexi Lalas, star of our '94 World Cup team who
9 played here in Boston has played in Italian Serie A.
10 Mike Lapper has played in England and in Germany.
11 Also on our '94 World Cup team.
12 Roy Lassiter, Serie B, in Italy and Costa Rica.
13 Eddie Lewis, member of our National Team, currently
14 plays in England.
15 Those are the ones I remember from this page.
16 Q The next two pages.
17 A Carlo Liamosa, who played last night for the US, played
18 in Colombia.
19 Lawrence Lozzano played in the Mexican second.
20 Martin Machon, Martin played in Mexico. Martin has
21 played in Spain. Martin has played in Guatemala.
22 Joao Luiz, Brazilian first division player.
23 Marquinho, Brazilian first division player.
24 Brian McBride has played in German second and in
25 England.
2120
- GULATI -
1 Ivan McKinley played in South Africa.
2 Paulinho McLaren has played in the Brazilian I.
3 Victor Mella has played in Chili.
4 Tony Meola played in England.
5 Sergio Miguez played in Argentina.
6 Those are the ones I recall.
7 Q Next two pages, please.
8 A Joe-Max Moore, English Premier, German second. Played
9 for us last night.
10 Jaime Moreno has played in Bolivia and in the
11 English Premier as well as the English I. I'm not sure if
12 he played in Peru or not, but we'll leave that.
13 David Nakhid, who has played in a number of places.
14 The one I remember for sure is Trinidad.
15 Alberto Naveda has played in Argentina and is
16 currently in Israel.
17 Peter Nowak has played -- has played in -- Peter,
18 where are you. Peter has played in Polish I, in the German,
19 and will play in the MLS championship game this Sunday.
20 I don't remember about Uche Okafor, but he played
21 overseas, so we'll leave him out.
22 Curt Onalfo, member of our '92 Olympic Team has
23 played in the Mexican second.
24 Q You can put the checks out to the side if you can't fit
25 them all in the box.
2121
- GULATI -
1 A Okay.
2 Arley Palacios played in Colombia.
3 Carlos Parra had played in Colombia.
4 David Patino in Mexico.
5 Adrian Paz played in Uruguay, played in England and
6 played in Argentina.
7 Daniel Peinado played in Argentina.
8 Steve Pittman played in Scotland. I don't remember
9 whether it was Premier or I.
10 Q If you don't remember it, let's skip it.
11 A Skip Steve. He played for our US National Team as well.
12 Jerzy Podbrozny played in a few different places.
13 The ones we're sure about here are Spanish II. I'm not sure
14 if he played in Poland or not. He played in two or three
15 other places, but we won't use those.
16 Looks like we have those two pages.
17 Q Let's move on.
18 A Preki, who will also play in that championship game this
19 week, played in the Yugoslavian first division. He played
20 in England. I don't know if he played in -- I'm not sure if
21 he played in the top division before they called it the
22 Premier League or not. It was some years ago.
23 Q If you're not sure, Mr. Gulati, don't check it off.
24 A David Quesada played in Costa Rica.
25 Mauricio Ramos played in Bolivia.
2122
- GULATI -
1 Tab Ramos played in the Spanish second division as
2 well as the American first division.
3 Thomas Ravelli, one of the best goalkeepers of all
4 time, played in the Swedish first division.
5 Paul Rideout -- Paul Rideout -- Paul Rideout played
6 in the England Premier. Paul Rideout played in the
7 English I. Paul Rideout played in Italian I. Paul Rideout
8 played in China, Kansas City to Beijing.
9 Jorge Rodas played against us a couple times,
10 Guatemalan first division.
11 Edmundo Rodriguez played in the Mexican second.
12 Silvio Rudman played in the Argentinean I.
13 Refik Sabanadzovic played in the Yugoslavian
14 league.
15 Hugo Sanchez played in the Austrian first division,
16 Spanish first division as well as the Mexican first
17 division.
18 Wellington Sanchez, Ecuadorian first division.
19 Tony Sanneh played for us last night in that World
20 Cup game, plays in the Bundesliga.
21 Those are the ones I recall here.
22 Q Next two pages, please?
23 A Giovanni Savarese, Serie C in Italy. He's played a few
24 games in Venezuela, but we don't have that here.
25 Brian Sebapole played in South Africa.
2123
- GULATI -
1 Diego Serna, Miami player, played in Colombia.
2 Richard Sharpe played in England.
3 Andrew Shue, Beverly Hills 90210, played in
4 Zimbabwe.
5 Juergen Sommer, the goalkeeper here in Boston,
6 played in the English Premier, the English I. I think he
7 played in the German league so we won't use that.
8 Diego Sonora played in the Argentinean I, maybe
9 later in the II, I don't know for sure.
10 Mike Sorber, member of the '94 US World Cup team,
11 played in Mexico.
12 Leonardo Squadrone played here in Boston as well as
13 for Argentina's Division I and two.
14 Juan Berthy Suarez played in DC, down in Bolivia.
15 Chris Sullivan, Chris played in lots of places,
16 member of our '90 World Cup team. Chris played in Hungary
17 y. Chris played in France in the second division. Chris
18 played in the Danish league, and a few more that I don't
19 remember for sure.
20 Alain Sutter, Alain played in Germany.
21 Jerry Tamashiro played in Peru.
22 Those are the ones I remember here.
23 Q Next two pages.
24 A Ryan Tinsley played in the German second.
25 Steve Trittschuh, we talked about earlier, played
2124
- GULATI -
1 in Czechoslovakian first division.
2 Trotman, I'm not sure about.
3 Francisco Uribe played in Mexican first division,
4 as well as the Mexican second pretty recently.
5 Istvan Urbanyi played in the Hungarian first
6 division. Was a teammate of Cris Sullivan's for a little
7 while.
8 Carlos Valderrama, one of our star players, Carlos
9 played in the Colombian first division. Played in the
10 Spanish first division. Played in the French first
11 division. One of the world's marquis players.
12 Martin Vasquez played in Mexico.
13 I'm not sure about José Vasquez. We'll skip him.
14 Marcelo Vega played in Chile.
15 Etcheverry is up there. We've got a couple of
16 those in the first division. Those Chileans, missed
17 that first box.
18 Peter Vermes played in the Dutch first division,
19 played in Hungary, played in the Spanish II, and I don't
20 know if it's announced yet, but we'll do it here, he was
21 Defender of the Year, maybe we mentioned that earlier, this
22 year in MLS, captain of the National Team.
23 Diego Vierra played in Uruguay.
24 I can't remember if Bojan Vuckovic played --
25 Waldir played in Peru.
2125
- GULATI -
1 Robert Warzycha, one of the top players in the
2 league, played in Poland and played in England, but I don't
3 remember if it was --
4 Q If you don't remember, skip it.
5 A We'll skip that.
6 Mark Watson played in England.
7 Roy Wegerle played in the English Premier.
8 Welton played in the Brazilian I.
9 That's the end of that page.
10 Q The good news is we're getting to the Ws although we
11 have goalies that follow but keep going, please, Mr. Gulati.
12 A Evans Wise plays in Germany now.
13 He played in Trinidad but I'm not a hundred percent
14 sure. So we'll leave that alone.
15 Peter Woodring played in the German II and in the
16 German III.
17 Chris Woods played in the English Premier.
18 Eric Wynalda, again, from the Boston team here,
19 played in the German Bundesliga and in Mexico.
20 Frank Yallop played in English I.
21 AJ wood played, I think, in the German II, but we
22 won't use that.
23 Walter Zenga who was player coach here in Boston a
24 couple of years ago played in the Italian I, one of the top
25 goalkeepers in the world.
2126
- GULATI -
1 Zico played in Mexico in II.
2 And Jacek Ziober played in Poland land in the I and
3 Spain in the I.
4 That's the end.
5 Q I think I misspoke, Mr. Gulati, I think the goalkeepers
6 were already covered.
7 A I'm not sure if they were all covered, one comes to
8 mind, certainly, Calio Azmi [ph.].
9 Q Can you just -- let's do this. When you look down the
10 list of goalkeepers that follow starting at Page 375, see if
11 there are any names other than what you've already reviewed.
12 You indicate that you've skipped some people.
13 (Pause in proceedings.)
14 A No, it looks like the goalkeepers are listed twice,
15 once --
16 Q Okay.
17 Thank you, Mr. Gulati, and I apologize to the jury
18 for what I know was a boring exercise.
19 (Witness resumes stand.)
20 MR. CARDOZO: Can we just look at the first
21 page of the register again.
22 Q Mr. Gulati, the information that you were looking at in
23 the book, did that indicate in any way the teams where the
24 players had played?
25 A No, it does not.
2127
- GULATI -
1 Q And so what you've just told us was based upon your
2 recollection based upon your experience in soccer; is that
3 right?
4 A Yes, that's correct.
5 Q Now, of all the players you've just mentioned, did each
6 of those players play at MLS at some point in time?
7 A Yes, they did.
8 Q And some of them came to MLS from one of these leagues;
9 is that right?
10 A Some of them came to MLS from one of those leagues, yes.
11 Q And some of them left MLS and went to one of these
12 leagues; is that right?
13 A Others were in that category, yes.
14 Q And did some do both, come and -- come and go?
15 A Some came, some left and then came back and all those
16 combinations, yes.
17 Q Did these players have a choice between playing for MLS
18 and playing for another league?
19 A Not only did they have a choice, they availed themselves
20 of that choice and played in another league.
21 Q If they didn't like -- the players that you mentioned
22 didn't like the salary MLS offered, what could they do?
23 MR. KESSLER: Now I'm going to object.
24 THE COURT: Sustained.
25 Q One last point on this, Mr. Gulati.
2128
- GULATI -
1 Looking at the first column, Argentina to Croatia,
2 could you tell us very quickly -- could you go back up to
3 the board and indicate Argentina to Croatia, whether those
4 leagues are Division I, Division II or Division~III and put
5 the number in the parentheses.
6 (Whereupon, the witness stepped down.)
7 (Witness complies.)
8 Q And can you keep going and stop before you get to
9 England.
10 (Witness complies.)
11 Q Let's just skip England and can you complete the rest of
12 the chart and then I'll ask you some questions about it.
13 (Witness complies.)
14 Q Okay. Why don't you sit down and we'll fill in -- I'll
15 just ask you a couple of questions about England and then
16 we'll take a break, if that's okay.
17 (Whereupon, the witness resumed the stand.)
18 Q Mr. Gulati, there's been some confusion about the
19 English Premier League and the English First Division
20 League.
21 What is your understanding as to what the top
22 league in England is called?
23 A Everyone knows that the top league in England is the
24 Premier League.
25 Q And what is the league below the top league, below the
2129
- GULATI -
1 English Premier League?
2 A What is call the First Division.
3 Q Now, had there been a time when the leagues were called
4 something else in England?
5 A For a very long time, there's been 4-leagues or four
6 divisions, if you will. They were called the First
7 Division, the Second Division, the Third Division and
8 the Fourth Division, and, as I mentioned a couple of days
9 ago, below that is what's called non-league soccer.
10 Q And did there come a point in time when England changed
11 the names of its leagues?
12 A Essentially what happened is that early '90s, the First
13 Division became what's now known as the Premier League.
14 The First Division as we know it now was the second league
15 so they renamed the leagues.
16 And it's not all the teams moving at the same time
17 because in England we've got promotion and relegation teams
18 that move up and down.
19 Q When they changed the names, did the teams that had
20 previously been called -- before they changed their names,
21 the top league was called the First Division?
22 A That's correct.
23 Q And when they changed their name to the Premier League,
24 what leagues were in the First Division -- in the Premier
25 League -- what -- withdrawn.
2130
- GULATI -
1 When they changed their name to Premier League,
2 what teams were in the Premier League?
3 A Virtually all of the teams that were in the First
4 Division came into the Premier League; not all of them, but
5 virtually all of them.
6 Q And when they changed the name of the Second Division to
7 the First Division, what teams ended up in the First
8 Division?
9 A The same -- the same principle. Virtually all the teams
10 that were in the II became part of the I.
11 Q And, therefore, Mr. Gulati, in the soccer community,
12 what is understood to be the First Division in England and
13 what is understood to be the Second Division?
14 MR. KESSLER: Objection, your Honor, as to
15 "the soccer community."
16 THE COURT: Overruled.
17 You may answer.
18 A Anyone that's involved in international soccer,
19 certainly in English or European soccer, understands that
20 the top division in England is the Premier League.
21 Q Okay.
22 So if you were up at the board -- we won't take it
23 now -- what would you indicate next to English Premier
24 League and what would you indicate next to English First
25 Division?
2131
- GULATI -
1 A Premier League is one, English First Division would be
2 two and the English Division II would be three.
3 MR. CARDOZO: Your Honor, may I --
4 Q And, Mr. Gulati, as you look at this chart, were most of
5 the leagues that played soccer -- most of the countries that
6 have soccer in this world, how many Division I leagues do
7 they have?
8 A All those -- all of those countries that we've just
9 outlined have one top league, Division I league.
10 MR. CARDOZO: This might be a good place for a
11 break your Honor.
12 THE COURT: Okay. We'll take the morning
13 recess.
14 THE CLERK: All rise. Court is now in recess.
15 (Whereupon, the jury left the courtroom.)
16 (Recess.)
17 (Whereupon, the jury entered the courtroom.)
18 MR. CARDOZO: May I proceed, your Honor?
19 Q Mr. Gulati, looking at the -- this chart, Exhibit 1294,
20 I want to call your attention to the designation of the
21 Scottish Premier League and the Scottish Division I league
22 that you put in parentheses.
23 I note you had to move it down -- the board is down
24 because we have to put some other things up on the screen.
25 Let me just read to you that you put a parentheses,
2132
- GULATI -
1 number one, next to both the Scottish Premier League and the
2 Scottish Division I league.
3 Is that your recollection?
4 A That's a mistake. I was going a little too quickly.
5 Q What is your recollection?
6 A The Scottish Premier League is the top division, and I
7 should have a two next to the Scottish Division I.
8 That's -- going to quickly on that list.
9 Q Calling your attention right underneath that to your
10 designation of the South African Premier League and the
11 South African Division I league, you also put parentheses
12 next to those league.
13 Is that your same recollection?
14 A Same thing. I was going too quickly.
15 MR. CARDOZO: Your Honor, with your
16 permission, I would like to make the change.
17 MR. KESSLER: No, I object to it. They can
18 make another designation -- that's the exhibit -- I want the
19 record as how the witness wrote it down because I'm going to
20 cross-examine him about it.
21 THE COURT: I think you can cross-examine him,
22 but it's clear he's changing it, and you can ask him about
23 it.
24 MR. KESSLER: Well, he's changing it after
25 break with his counsel. I think I'm entitled, your Honor,
2133
- GULATI -
1 to have a record of the exhibit coming in as it's there.
2 THE COURT: No, you can change the chart. And
3 you may cross-examine about the change.
4 MR. CARDOZO: All right.
5 MR. KESSLER: Very good, your Honor.
6 MR. CARDOZO: Mr. Kessler, since I only can
7 put an X since it doesn't erase, I will clearly indicate
8 what --
9 MR. KESSLER: Thank you.
10 BY MR. CARDOZO
11 Q Mr. Gulati, just to conclude this point, what does this
12 chart tell you as to the alternatives available in other
13 countries to MLS players?
14 MR. KESSLER: Objection, your Honor. Calls
15 for a conclusion.
16 THE COURT: Sustained.
17 MR. CARDOZO: Okay.
18 Q Mr. Gulati, there's been a lot of talk about dual
19 citizenship and dual passports and work permits and the like
20 from some of the players who testified before you. I want
21 to ask you some questions about that.
22 How many people, roughly, played in MLS in, say,
23 this past season?
24 A Average roster is about 22, 23 players. Twenty players
25 and then some developmental players. We've got a couple of
2134
- GULATI -
1 other categories, but 22, 23.
2 Q So 22, 23 times 12, roughly 260, something like that?
3 A About that, yes.
4 Q Now, of those 260 or so players, do you have an
5 understanding as to how many are foreign nationals and are
6 working here on a work visa?
7 A The limit is essentially five per team. We've got a
8 couple of categories within that, but about five per team.
9 Not all teams have five, so as an estimate, I think it's
10 about 55 this year.
11 Q What is a foreign national, Mr. Gulati?
12 A For us, that's what it is, generally, it's a player
13 who's playing in the league that does not have a US passport
14 or other permanent residency in the US.
15 Q Now, in addition to those with approximately 55 players,
16 are there other foreign nationals playing for MLS with
17 something called a green card?
18 A Yes, there are players who play in the league that have
19 a foreign passport but have permanent residency, a green
20 card, as you called it.
21 Q Approximately how many of them, would you say?
22 A I think there's two to three on each team, and that
23 changes because some players who have been here become
24 permanent residents.
25 Q So that's roughly 24 or so?
2135
- GULATI -
1 A That's an estimate yes.
2 Q Is that within the 55 or in addition to the 55?
3 A No. For the purposes of the league and US law, those
4 players are treated as if they're citizens, so they're in
5 addition to the 55.
6 Q So that's about the 260 or so MLS players -- about 79 or
7 so would come within one of these first two categories?
8 A That's correct.
9 Q Now, are some MLS players what has been called --
10 withdrawn.
11 Do some MLS players have passports for both United
12 States and another country, so-called dual citizenship?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Do you have any idea how many of those players are?
15 A I'm not sure about all of them. If we look at just the
16 Boston team, the New England team, at least three on the New
17 England team. And if every team was like New England, then
18 you'd have 36, but that's based on New England having at
19 least three.
20 So I would estimate about 35.
21 Q So that's 79 plus 35, that is, those 35 would have both
22 a US passport and a passport for another country?
23 A As an estimate based on New England, yeah.
24 Q So that's about 114 or so players would have either a
25 work permit -- they're foreigners, they have a work permit.
2136
- GULATI -
1 They're foreigners, and they have a green card or
2 they have dual citizenship?
3 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, I now object. It's
4 speculative. He doesn't know about any team but New
5 England, and Mr. Cardozo is leading him to a league
6 estimate.
7 THE COURT: No, overruled.
8 A It's roughly 80. And the first two categories, 55 plus
9 two per team that are, on estimate, green card holders. And
10 based on New England, three that have dual citizenship, so
11 that's a good estimate, yes.
12 Q And how many players are in MLS altogether, roughly?
13 A About 250, 260.
14 Q So -- I want to talk about foreign restrictions in a
15 minute.
16 But forgetting foreign restrictions, could the
17 players you just identified, the roughly 110, 115 players,
18 was there another country in the world that they could play
19 in without any restrictions whatsoever?
20 A Absolutely, yes.
21 Q Why do you say that?
22 A If there's a foreign national, in that first group of
23 55, they have another country that they hold a passport for
24 exclusively. So they clearly have another league, as long
25 as there's a league in their country, and I think there are
2137
- GULATI -
1 for those players.
2 On the green card holders, they also have a foreign
3 passport, so they have another country that they would not
4 be restricted from playing in. And the dual citizens or the
5 dual passport holders, by definition, have another country.
6 And if it's a European passport, they have many
7 options.
8 Q Okay.
9 Now, let's talk about the restrictions that would
10 operate with respect to other countries and whether
11 Americans or people who hold perhaps a passport to France
12 but want to play in Switzerland.
13 Are there restrictions abroad that limit the number
14 of foreigners who can play soccer for a team in a particular
15 country?
16 A In many countries, that's true, yes.
17 Q Does the existence of these restrictions affect in any
18 way your conclusion that there are foreign alternatives
19 available to MLS players?
20 A No. It doesn't. We just went through an exercise that
21 showed that a lot of MLS players have, in fact, played
22 abroad.
23 Q What exactly are these foreign player limits we've heard
24 so much about?
25 Can you just describe this generally?
2138
- GULATI -
1 A Like MLS, a number of federations or leagues have rules
2 about the number of non-domestic players that can play. And
3 that's for any number of reasons, to develop the National
4 Team, to make sure you have some local players that fans can
5 identify with. So those are numerical limits.
6 There might be three, four, five, six.
7 Q Well, Mr. Bowers told us --
8 MR. CARDOZO: Take a look at him again.
9 Q -- that 75 -- it was necessary that he play in
10 75 percent of National Team games for European teams to even
11 look at you.
12 Is that your understanding?
13 A That's -- that's absolutely not correct.
14 Q What is your understanding on that?
15 A The 75 percent rule that Mr. Bowers is referring to
16 applies in one or two countries, primarily in the United
17 Kingdom, but it doesn't apply for other places.
18 Q Well, what is your understanding of the difficulty of a
19 player trying to play in Europe, in a foreign country,
20 today?
21 A If you're good enough, you'll be able to play, and if
22 you want to do it.
23 Obviously, in certain countries, it is more
24 difficult than in others and there are restrictions.
25 Would it be easier if those didn't exist? Of
2139
- GULATI -
1 course. But a number of players, American and international
2 players, have played -- crossed over from MLS.
3 Q You referred a moment ago to limits, three or four or
4 five.
5 Is that a limit per league or a limit per team?
6 A No, it's a limit per team, so three for a particular
7 team in England or in France or in Spain, or five, or
8 whatever the number might be.
9 Q Now, focusing on the year 2000, the last few years,
10 Mr. Gulati, has it become easier or harder for a foreign
11 person to play soccer in Europe?
12 A For Europeans to move between European countries has
13 become considerably easier in the last few years because
14 what's happened is --
15 Q Well, let's not have a dialogue.
16 MR. KESSLER: Well, the witness was finishing
17 the answer to his questions. Unless he wants him to say
18 something else --
19 Q I apologize for interrupting, Mr. Gulati. Go ahead.
20 A Because of some changes in legislation.
21 Q What has occurred in Europe to make it easier for
22 European players to play for a different country in Europe?
23 A For most of Europe, now, it doesn't matter if you're
24 from England or France or Germany, to play in one of those
25 leagues. So it's analogous in the US to having a change
2140
- GULATI -
1 that says it doesn't matter if you're from Massachusetts.
2 You can work in New York, and vice versa.
3 So now if you're a French player, you can play in
4 England, and you're no different than if you were born and
5 raised in London.
6 Q And what other countries does that rule apply to?
7 A Much of Europe. The European community, and in some
8 countries, it involves an even wider group.
9 Q So if a French player wants to play in Germany today, do
10 the restrictions that you've described apply to him?
11 A No, they do not.
12 Q Now, has that change in the rules made it easier or
13 harder for an American to play in Europe?
14 A Well, if you have limits of -- it's made it easier.
15 If you have limits on foreign players, and that
16 limit is five, and most of the players you recruit are no
17 longer subject to that limit because they're treated as
18 domestic players, clearly there are more opportunities, more
19 slots available for American or South American or any other
20 players.
21 Q Well, Mr. Semioli told us that Europeans can move from
22 country to country and not be counted as a foreign player.
23 Is that what you're saying?
24 A About most of Europe, that's correct.
25 Q And he then said that that freed up spots for Americans
2141
- GULATI -
1 to play; is that right?
2 A Absolutely correct.
3 Q I see. Okay.
4 Now, Mr. Dodd said --
5 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, I object to him
6 reading testimony and asking the witness --
7 THE COURT: No, go ahead.
8 Q Mr. Dodd told us, "There's an unspoken rule" in England
9 that English clubs rarely use foreign players.
10 Is that true?
11 A Absolutely not. There's been a concern in England
12 recently that some of the teams don't have any English
13 players.
14 So Chelsea has been a big example. Quite often
15 starts 11 players who are not English in its first team.
16 Q Are there players, American players, who are today
17 playing in the English Premier league?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Who?
20 A Joe-Max Moore is playing in the English Premier League
21 for Everton.
22 Q Has anyone else played there?
23 A Playing there now or played there?
24 Q Played there. Past tense.
25 A Yes, Juergen Sommer has played there. John Harkes has
2142
- GULATI -
1 played there. Brad Friedel has played there.
2 Q Okay.
3 Now, Mr. Trittschuh told us that people have to
4 meet certain National Team playing requirements to get the
5 necessary work permit from Europe.
6 Is that correct?
7 A No, that rule is an English-based rule. It may apply in
8 Scotland, but it's generally -- it's confined to the United
9 Kingdom, about 75 percent participation on the National
10 Team.
11 Q Mr. Dodd told us that most of the players who have
12 played overseas have had some type of document or passport
13 that allowed them to do that; is that right?
14 A Not a passport. They didn't have a right by being a
15 domestic. Eventually, they got some document which was a
16 work visa, but you don't have to be a dual citizen to go and
17 play in these countries.
18 Q Well, is this -- has this, in fact, occurred or is this
19 just the theory that they have a right to play?
20 A We have a number who have played -- and the list that we
21 have on the board, a number of players from MLS who either
22 came from Europe or went to Europe, including American
23 players, including some who did not have a second passport.
24 Q How do players become aware -- are they aware of these
25 opportunities?
2143
- GULATI -
1 A Yes, very much so. Increasingly so with communication
2 technology.
3 Q Have you had any recent examples in your own experience
4 of players who have become aware of opportunities or who
5 have exercised opportunities to play abroad?
6 A Sure. We have players that move all the time, even in
7 the last few weeks.
8 Q Did you have any experience in your role at New England
9 in that connection recently?
10 A We had three of our young players -- I'm sorry, from New
11 England --
12 Q New England or San Jose.
13 A Mr. Chronopolous, who was in court a couple of days ago,
14 called with his representative and wanted to go over to
15 England with a first division team.
16 And we recently sent three players from San Jose to
17 go and play in Poland for a couple of months.
18 Q So have foreign player restrictions prevented MLS
19 players from playing abroad?
20 A No. It would be easier without them, but absolutely
21 not.
22 Q Mr. Bowers told us that he only wanted to play in a
23 Division I league, so Division II wasn't an option.
24 Have you found that to be correct?
25 A That Mr. Bowers said that or --
2144
- GULATI -
1 Q Is that your understanding, that players only want to
2 play in a Division I league?
3 A I think --
4 MR. KESSLER: Objection, your Honor.
5 THE COURT: Overruled. You may answer it.
6 A Players are generally interested in where they can make
7 the most money and other things that are important to them
8 personally, but they're guided by economics, and there's
9 lots of players that might choose to play in a good second
10 level rather than the first level in other country, for
11 example.
12 Q Do you have any examples of that?
13 A A recent one is Stern John who went from our league,
14 from MLS, and is playing in Nottingham, which is in -- up on
15 my board what I've got is a second level.
16 He had a chance to play in the Premier League, but
17 I think he may have gotten more money or decided that he
18 wanted to play for a good second-level team rather than be
19 playing for Watford, which was his other offer.
20 So, in general, are you going to want to play in
21 the top league, yes, but there are going to be exceptions to
22 that.
23 Q Just to jump ahead for a minute, what about players
24 playing domestically?
25 Have some players turned MLS down to play
2145
- GULATI -
1 domestically?
2 A Yes, they have.
3 Q Now, one of the areas you didn't cover in your testimony
4 before the break was players who MLS never signed.
5 Are there players who have played abroad that MLS
6 was not able to attract to come to play for MLS?
7 A Yes. Any number of them.
8 Q Can you give us some examples?
9 A We mentioned a few yesterday. Juergen Kliensmann,
10 Roberto Baggio, Romario.
11 But it's like asking are there items in Tiffany's
12 you didn't try to buy. We can't afford most of them so we
13 don't spend time trying to get most of them.
14 Q Are there American players who have played abroad that
15 MLS -- that you've tried to attract back to the States and
16 have failed?
17 A Same thing. We've talked to some of them, but when it
18 became obvious that we weren't going to be able to coax them
19 back, we didn't try much harder after that.
20 Q Any names come to mind?
21 A Claudio Rano, Casey Keller, Ernie Stewart we tried with.
22 We've had conversations with Craig Berhalter.
23 Q Mr. Dougherty told us that he didn't have a chance to
24 find out his competitive value with another Division I
25 league.
2146
- GULATI -
1 Did players have a chance to find out their
2 competitive value?
3 A We've got -- I don't know how many checkmarks we've got.
4 We've got a lot of players that played overseas.
5 Q Let's focus for just a couple of minutes on US leagues.
6 Has MLS faced competition for some players from
7 domestic leagues?
8 A Yes, it does.
9 Q Now, in 1996, what were the leagues that MLS looked at
10 in the United States to attract some of its players?
11 A In 1996, we had -- the biggest would be the USISL which
12 was, in fact, formed by a number of leagues. The A-League
13 was part of the USISL. It was also a Division~III league.
14 The NPSL, which was the indoor league at the time.
15 I don't recall if the CISL was already playing or not or had
16 already stopped playing, but they were players who had
17 played in the CISL that we had talked to.
18 Q Just give us a couple of names of people who you
19 attracted from either the APSL or the USISL.
20 A A number of our players that played in the league.
21 We've got some of them in this. Paul Bravo came to
22 us from San Jose, from one of those leagues. Chris Armas
23 came from one of those leagues. Mark Dougherty came from
24 one of those leagues, and so on.
25 Q Did some players come from the indoor league?
2147
- GULATI -
1 A Yes, they did.
2 Q Can you give us a couple of examples?
3 A Sean Bowers came to us, obviously, from the indoor
4 league. Matt Knowles came to us from the indoor league.
5 Later on, Henry Gutierrez came to us, I think, a year later.
6 So any number from the NPSL or CISL.
7 Q Well, let me ask you a few more questions about the
8 indoor league.
9 You heard some testimony from a number of the
10 players that indoor soccer is not comparable to outdoor
11 soccer, and I'd like to divide my questions first with
12 respect to the consumer and then from the perspective of the
13 player.
14 Does indoor soccer appeal to the same kind of
15 audience as outdoor soccer?
16 A Some, yes.
17 Is it exactly the same audience? No.
18 Q Looking at the players as distinct from the audience,
19 are the same kinds of skills needed to play indoor soccer as
20 compared to outdoor soccer?
21 A Many of the skills are very, very similar, yes.
22 Q And if a player is a good player in indoor soccer, is it
23 a good indication that he be a good player in outdoor
24 soccer?
25 A Certainly be a strong indication that he's a good soccer
2148
- GULATI -
1 player.
2 Q Are there some players who have excelled in indoor
3 soccer and gone on to be a success in outdoor soccer?
4 A Yes.
5 Q Who?
6 A Preki, who I mentioned earlier and who is playing in our
7 championship game this week, is a very good indoor player
8 and has gone from indoor to outdoor.
9 Matt Knowles was a very good indoor player and
10 wasn't quite as good outdoor but he came to us.
11 Ted Eck, a solid player in both leagues, indoor and
12 outdoor.
13 And we've had players that have played outdoor that
14 have never played the indoor game until they played with our
15 National Team indoors and were outstanding.
16 Q In attempting to -- in negotiating contracts while you
17 were at MLS, did you find yourself in competition with the
18 indoor leagues?
19 A For a number of players, yes.
20 Q Can you give us one example?
21 A Tried to get a number of players from the league, from
22 the NPSL.
23 Paul Dougherty would be one example.
24 MR. CARDOZO: Can you show us Paul Dougherty.
25 Q That's Paul Dougherty?
2149
- GULATI -
1 A It is.
2 Q Anybody else?
3 A Scott Swietzer would be another example.
4 Q You can keep going. If we have the picture, we'll show
5 them just to --
6 A Hector Marinaro would be another example.
7 Victor Nagarro would be another example. There's
8 any number of these players.
9 Q Did this competition for players, be it in the indoor
10 league or the APSL or the USISL, was this limited to 1996 or
11 did this competition continue thereafter?
12 A It continues throughout.
13 A couple of the players that I mentioned in the
14 last four or five we were not able to get in 1996, and they
15 decided to play indoors. They came to us later on, and
16 others did not.
17 And some we dropped our interest in.
18 Q Well, let's focus -- the APSL by 1996 was called the
19 A-League; is that right?
20 A Yes, it was part of the USISL family.
21 Q And do you recall did the -- did MLS bid against the
22 A-League for players?
23 A Certain players, yes.
24 Q And what division was the A-League?
25 A It had -- I don't know when -- we covered a year
2150
- GULATI -
1 yesterday. I don't know what date they switched from a
2 no-name classification to be called the A-League, but they
3 were Division II.
4 Q But MLS competed with this Division II league for
5 players?
6 A For some players, yes.
7 Q Do you recall any examples?
8 A Matt Knowles was a player who was actually at an indoor
9 team. Rochester of the A-League was bidding for him. We
10 also, as it turned out, were bidding for him, and he
11 literally started in the midwest, went to Rochester for a
12 press conference while he was still talking to us.
13 We increased our offer, and he came to play in New
14 York.
15 Q So there are a number of players?
16 A There were -- he's the best example. I remember
17 three-way bidding, but there are a number of players that,
18 umm ...
19 Q Well, do you view the A-League as a farm system, as
20 Mr. Dodd called it?
21 A No. We have an agreement now that allows us to call up
22 players. But if you ask the players in Rochester, for
23 example, which is the champions of the A-League, they don't
24 view themselves as a farm system for MLS.
25 We've had players from fairly recently turn us
2151
- GULATI -
1 down. Other teams look at it more as a developmental
2 situation, but the better players don't view it that way.
3 Q Why would a player turn down -- do you have an
4 understanding as to why a player would turn down an offer
5 from MLS to remain in a Division II league?
6 MR. KESSLER: I object, your Honor.
7 THE COURT: Overruled. You may answer.
8 A The ones that have turned us down, it's been primarily
9 financial. They've been able to make more money. It could
10 also be because they want to be a key player on a second
11 division team rather than play in the MLS in the first
12 division.
13 Q What do you mean being a key player on a second division
14 team versus playing in MLS?
15 A You might want to be the -- you might prefer to be the
16 star player for Rochester in the A-League rather than to be
17 on the bench for the New York-based team.
18 And the same way that you might prefer to go to a
19 small college and be the starting quarterback rather than be
20 the sixth quarterback at Oklahoma.
21 Q Well, in his opening statement, Mr. Kessler said that
22 MLS players have no choice. They have but one league to
23 deal with; is that correct?
24 A No, that's not correct.
25 Q Let me ask you another question.
2152
- GULATI -
1 Did MLS, from time to time while you were working
2 in the league office, receive inquiries from other teams
3 abroad about whether or not MLS would make certain players
4 available to them?
5 A Sure. Happens all the time.
6 Q How did that come about?
7 A A team would see one of our players in a game or scout
8 the player or see a game on television. Could be any number
9 of ways. Or play against one of our teams in an
10 international exhibition game, and they would like to
11 proceed in potentially contracting the player.
12 Q And are arrangements sometimes worked out in that
13 regard?
14 A Sometimes they are, yes.
15 Q And whenever a player who is still under contract with
16 MLS moves to another league, a team in another league, does
17 he do that with his consent or without his consent?
18 A Any time a player moves while he's with MLS or outside
19 of MLS, he has to come to a new agreement with his new team.
20 Q When you hear -- got expressions of interest from these
21 other leagues, what did MLS do?
22 A In some cases, we asked the -- we asked the
23 international team, Make us an offer.
24 In other cases, we say, Why don't you talk with a
25 player first.
2153
- GULATI -
1 In other cases, they might be asking to invite the
2 player to a tryout.
3 So it could be any number of things in how you
4 would take the next step.
5 Q Did you make any efforts to persuade the player to
6 remain with MLS?
7 A If it was a player we were interested in keeping and the
8 offer was something that we could try to match or come close
9 to, then, yes, absolutely.
10 Q Well, did there come times when you decided to try to
11 renegotiate a player's contract in order to persuade them to
12 remain with MLS?
13 A Sure.
14 Q What did that entail?
15 A Well, if a player was going to -- was -- had a
16 possibility of leaving or a potential of leaving or another
17 club was interested, it obviously triggers your interest
18 more. All players had the possibility of leaving.
19 So you try to negotiate a longer contract, and that
20 involved paying a player more money.
21 Q Why don't you just wait until the player's contract was
22 over to renegotiate?
23 A You like to know that you're going to have the player in
24 the future, and you don't want to wait until the last day to
25 be sitting down to do that. So you want to try to get a
2154
- GULATI -
1 longer contract much earlier.
2 Q What incentive did you offer the player in return?
3 A In general, it's more money, salary, signing bonus, and
4 it could be any one of a number of other things, but a
5 longer guaranteed contract would be one of them.
6 Q And have there been players whose contracts you, in
7 fact, did renegotiate in order to persuade them to remain
8 with MLS?
9 A I or members of the MLS player department, yes, there
10 have been any number of them.
11 Q Do you remember who they are, any of them?
12 A Jason Price; Ben Olsen, who played last night; Josh
13 Wolff, who played last night for the US Team. Carlos
14 LLamosa.
15 It's a long, long list of players.
16 Q Were you always successful?
17 A No.
18 Q Was Tony Sanneh one of the people that you successfully
19 renegotiated a contract with?
20 A No, he was not.
21 Q Did you try to renegotiate a contract with Mr. Sanneh?
22 A Over the course of his term playing in MLS, we tried on
23 a number of different occasions to get Mr. Sanneh to sign a
24 longer contract.
25 Q Who is Mr. Sanneh?
2155
- GULATI -
1 A He is a player who came to MLS from Minnesota. Played
2 in DC United for three years and now plays in the German
3 Bundesliga.
4 Q And why did MLS not keep him at MLS?
5 A We got outbid. We couldn't afford to pay him what the
6 German team did.
7 Q Any other player that you remember who you got outbid
8 for?
9 A There's a number of players that left the league that we
10 could not afford or lost the bidding, if you will. There's
11 been a couple of those in the last few years that involve
12 the two teams I most directly work with.
13 Eddie Lewis, the league tried to renegotiate a
14 longer contract with and get him to stay. It wasn't
15 successful in either of those, either getting a longer
16 contract or in having him stay, and he went and is now
17 playing England.
18 We mentioned Stern John earlier, another player in
19 that category.
20 So you've got those things happening all of the
21 time when players have a possibility that they want to
22 explore it and you try to get them to stay.
23 Q And can you give us an example where you were successful
24 in renegotiating a player's contract, persuading them to
25 stay with MLS?
2156
- GULATI -
1 A A couple I mentioned earlier were Ben Olsen and Josh
2 Wolff, and that -- we've been successful up to now. In the
3 Olympics they did well, and we don't know how they'll do the
4 next time around.
5 Q When did this renegotiation process -- did this happen
6 in MLS's first season or is it a more recent phenomena?
7 A No, it's happened from day one. We had players who left
8 us early on or had possibilities to leave us, and we
9 negotiated contracts.
10 Q Mr. Gulati, you spent the morning talking about these
11 alternatives reflected on the chart and the stories you just
12 told.
13 Did the existence of these alternatives affect you
14 when you conducted your negotiations with individual
15 players?
16 A Sure.
17 Q How?
18 A If there's a lot of interest in a player or potential
19 interest in a player, you know that you can lose the player
20 either now or when their contract is over or you're going to
21 have a problem when they're done because they can leave, so,
22 of course, it does.
23 Q And, finally, Mr. Gulati, do MLS players, in fact, have
24 alternatives to play professional soccer for someone other
25 than MLS?
2157
- GULATI -
1 A Absolutely, yes.
2 Q Mr. Gulati, you've been very patient with me. I thank
3 you for your time.
4 MR. CARDOZO: No further questions.
5 THE COURT: Mr. Robbins.
6 MR. ROBBINS: If I do this in 15 minutes or
7 less, your Honor, do I get a standing ovation?
8 (Laughter.)
9 CROSS-EXAMINATION
10 BY MR. ROBBINS
11 Q Just very briefly, Mr. Gulati, a couple of players just
12 that I happen to know a little bit about.
13 Who is Landon Donovan?
14 A Landon Donovan was a member of our Olympic Team. He was
15 an 18-year-old player who plays at Bayer Leverkusen in
16 Germany.
17 Q Is he basically considered to be a young phenom in
18 American soccer?
19 A He's a very talented young player, yes.
20 Q Did you make an effort to try to get him to come to MLS?
21 A Absolutely.
22 Q Were you successful?
23 A No, we were not.
24 Q You said he went to Germany to Bayer Leversen [sic], did
25 you say?
2158
- GULATI -
1 A Bayer Leverkusen.
2 Q And he's on their developmental team or their reserve
3 team or what?
4 A He's on their reserve team this year, and he's hoping to
5 get some opportunities with their first team.
6 Q So that's a player that you made an effort to get and
7 you couldn't even get him to come to MLS in the first
8 instance?
9 A That's correct.
10 Q And another well-known player is Casey Keller?
11 A Correct?
12 Q You mentioned all these players who played last night
13 for the US.
14 What were you talking about, something near and
15 dear to your heart?
16 A The US National Team played in a very important game in
17 the World Cup qualification. It was played in Columbus,
18 Ohio, last night.
19 Q And they tied?
20 A Unfortunately, we did.
21 Q Still in it, right?
22 A We're not out of it. That's correct.
23 Q So if we beat Barbados, we're in, right?
24 A That's correct.
25 Q And we're in what, just so the jury understands?
2159
- GULATI -
1 A We're in the final round of qualifying for the 2002
2 World Cup.
3 Q And the goalie on the team last night was who?
4 A Casey Keller.
5 Q And Casey plays where now?
6 A In the Spanish first division.
7 Q And before then he played?
8 A In England.
9 Q In the Premier League?
10 A Yes.
11 Q Did he ever come to MLS?
12 A No.
13 Q Did you ever try and get him?
14 A We've had some general conversations with Casey. He's
15 made it very clear that we're not going to be able to afford
16 him at this stage.
17 Q He's too expensive?
18 A He's too expensive.
19 Q Going back to a couple of points just to try and clean
20 up some of the sagebrush here.
21 Mr. Kessler in his opening said that as part of the
22 diabolical conspiracy between MLS and the Federation, the
23 Federation is a self-proclaimed regulator of professional
24 soccer.
25 Is that correct?
2160
- GULATI -
1 A No, it's not a self-proclaimed regulator at all.
2 Q It's the national governing body of soccer?
3 A It gets its authority from the United States Olympic
4 Committee and an act of Congress and --
5 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, we would like to
6 approach, actually.
7 THE COURT: No.
8 MR. KESSLER: No? Okay.
9 A -- and FIFA.
10 Q Let's just -- and I'm going to be very brief on this
11 because I've been through it, but I think you have some
12 expertise on this.
13 The Federation is the national governing body,
14 correct?
15 A That's correct.
16 Q And the term "national governing body" means what?
17 A Means it oversees soccer at all levels in the United
18 States.
19 Q All right.
20 And did the Federation proclaim itself to be the
21 national governing body of soccer?
22 A No, the -- an act of Congress and subsequently the
23 United States Olympic Committee did that.
24 Q All right.
25 So the United States Olympic Committee was created
2161
- GULATI -
1 by the act of Congress, correct?
2 A The United States Olympic Committee has authorization
3 under an act of Congress, the Amateur Sports Act, yes.
4 Q And it was the US -- the United States Olympic Committee
5 that designated --
6 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, leading.
7 Q Who designated --
8 What entity designated the Federation as the
9 national governing body of soccer?
10 A The US Olympic Committee.
11 Q Okay. Thank you.
12 MR. ROBBINS: Could we have Exhibit 190 up on
13 the Board, please. Blow up the first paragraph.
14 Q And I know this has been gone over, so I'm going to do
15 it very briefly.
16 Mr. Kessler in his examination focused on, I think,
17 five people, and I'm going to take you through those five
18 people.
19 Richard Groff, do you see that name up there?
20 A I do.
21 Q All right.
22 Now, Mr. Kessler showed you a letter from
23 Mr. Rothenberg, and -- in which I think Mr. Kessler drew the
24 inference that Mr. Rothenberg was thinking of hiring
25 Mr. Groff to work for MLS.
2162
- GULATI -
1 Do you recall that letter?
2 A Yes, I do.
3 Q I'm not going to show it, but let me just ask you a
4 couple of questions.
5 Did Richard Groff ever come to work for MLS?
6 A No, he did not.
7 Q Did he ever make any money at all from MLS?
8 A No, he did not.
9 Q Did you ever observe Mr. Groff and Mr. Rothenberg
10 interact with each other personally?
11 A A number of occasions.
12 Q How did they get along?
13 A Not very well, for most of that time.
14 Q Was there active dislike, do you know?
15 A For a long part of that period, there was active
16 dislike.
17 Q That period included the December 1993 period?
18 A I don't know when it started. There was -- in the
19 beginning, there was mutual disrespect, but quiet.
20 Q Is it fair to say that they were political opponents in
21 the soccer world?
22 A Yes.
23 Q And Mr. Groff ran against Mr. Rothenberg in 1994?
24 A Yes, he did.
25 Q And lost?
2163
- GULATI -
1 A Yes, he did.
2 Q And Mr. Groff -- did Mr. Groff subsequently take a
3 position with any other soccer league?
4 A With the APSL/A-League, yes.
5 Q What was his position?
6 A He was commissioner.
7 Q And do you remember you were talking to Mr. Cardozo
8 about the problems you had with Mr. Trittschuh because he
9 was bound to the APSL?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And you had to pay -- MLS had to pay $10,000 to APSL
12 because the commissioner of APSL wouldn't let Mr. Trittschuh
13 out of his contract?
14 A That's correct.
15 Q Who was that commissioner?
16 A Mr. Groff.
17 Q Okay.
18 Going down to Mr. Vermes, he's a player, correct?
19 A Yes, he is.
20 Q And Mr. Trittschuh in response to a question I asked
21 said that he respected Mr. Vermese both as a player and a
22 person.
23 Would you agree with that?
24 A Absolutely.
25 Q All right.
2164
- GULATI -
1 And Mr. Armstrong is a player?
2 A Yes, he is.
3 Q And he was also a National Team player?
4 A Yes, he was.
5 Q Now, the -- I think Mr. Kessler was trying to raise an
6 inference that Mr. Rothenberg controlled the National Team
7 to the extent that --
8 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, could I object --
9 (Reporter interrupts.)
10 MR. KESSLER: My objection was -- just say
11 objection. That's fine. Objection, characterizing my
12 inferences.
13 MR. ROBBINS: Okay. I don't want to try to
14 rea d your mind.
15 Q Who was the National Team coach in 1993?
16 A Bora Milutinovic.
17 Q Now, Mr. Milutinovic, he is a well-known coach?
18 A He's a very, very well-known coach in the world.
19 Q Has he been successful in the World Cup?
20 A He's the only coach to coach four different teams in the
21 World Cup that have advanced past the first stage.
22 Q All right.
23 And is he known to be a strong-willed person or one
24 who is subject to the will of others when choosing his team?
25 MR. KESSLER: Objection, your Honor.
2165
- GULATI -
1 THE COURT: Overruled.
2 A No one picks Bora's team but Bora.
3 Q All right.
4 And did Mr. Rothenberg have any ability to tell
5 Mr. Milutinovic to cut Mr. Vermes or Mr. Armstrong if they
6 didn't vote for MLS?
7 A Bora picked Bora's team. Period.
8 Q Now, going down, Michelle Akers-Stahl, is she now
9 Michelle Akers, I guess?
10 A She is.
11 Q Okay.
12 Who is Michelle Akers?
13 A The best women's soccer player ever to play the game.
14 Q All right.
15 American or international, correct?
16 A The best women's soccer player anywhere in the world to
17 play the game.
18 Q And she's been on the National Team -- I guess she
19 didn't play in Sydney, correct?
20 A She retired about a month before Sydney for health
21 reasons.
22 Q But as of 1993 in December, how long had she been in the
23 National Team?
24 A Michelle was on our first National Team that we ever
25 organized in 1985 and except for periods when she had been
2166
- GULATI -
1 injured has been on it through the period August 2000.
2 Q Now, is she known in the soccer community as being a
3 very strong-willed person?
4 A She's a very strong-willed person.
5 Q And would you describe what she's going through, just
6 briefly?
7 I don't want to take up too much time. Just to
8 give a flavor, describe what she went through to play
9 soccer.
10 A The most notable are two health-related issues in the
11 mid to late '80s. We got -- the Federation received
12 documents or a phone call from doctors who said she should
13 not be playing, that she could suffer a life-ending,
14 life-threatening injury, not a career-ending, if she
15 continued heading the ball. She had had some fainting.
16 We told her we weren't going to allow her to play.
17 She went and got her own doctors and got -- we got
18 overruled.
19 She has had operations, too many to count. And for
20 the last five, eight years, I don't know how many exactly,
21 she's suffered from chronic fatigue syndrome. And if you go
22 into the locker room during the Women's World Cup last
23 summer, she's getting IV at half time.
24 She is -- she's something special.
25 Q And is she well respected in the soccer community?
2167
- GULATI -
1 A Absolutely.
2 Q All right.
3 Now, if Mr. Rothenberg tried to have her thrown off
4 because she didn't vote for MLS, what would have been the
5 reaction in the soccer community?
6 A I can't even -- it would be equivalent to someone saying
7 Bobby Knight shouldn't make his own choices. And if they're
8 talking about Michael Jordan, he shouldn't be on the Olympic
9 Team.
10 Q By the way, who was the National Team coach for the
11 women in 1993?
12 A Anson Dorenz [ph.].
13 Q And Anson Dorenz is where now?
14 A He has been for a long time the women's soccer coach at
15 the University of North Carolina.
16 Q And is the North Carolina soccer team successful?
17 A It may well be the most successful college sports team
18 in any sport over the last 20 years and is certainly the
19 most successful soccer team. Records that are like
20 95 percent wins, nine, ten, eleven, twelve national
21 championships.
22 It's unparalleled in any other team sport.
23 Q In your view, would Mr. Rothenberg have had any success
24 if he tried to get Mr. Dorenz to throw Michelle Akers off
25 the team because she didn't vote for MLS?
2168
- GULATI -
1 A Absolutely not. No success.
2 Q Preposterous, right?
3 A Ridiculous.
4 Q Now, one other name, Mary Harvey, I guess she -- I've
5 learned during the course of this trial that she worked for
6 WCOC during this period?
7 A She did for a period of time.
8 Q All right.
9 And so I guess she reported to Mr. Rothenberg?
10 A She reported to someone that was three or four levels on
11 the chart below Mr. Rothenberg.
12 Q And Mary Harvey was an athlete as well?
13 A She is.
14 Q Has she been successful?
15 A Gold Medal in the World Championship, Gold Medal in the
16 Olympics, silver Medal in the World Championship. She's
17 been a very successful athlete.
18 Q Any indication she could have been pressured by
19 Mr. Rothenberg to vote in favor in MLS if she believed APSL
20 should have been the designee?
21 MR. KESSLER: Objection, your Honor.
22 THE COURT: Overruled.
23 You may answer.
24 A No, I don't believe so.
25 Q Just a couple more questions.
2169
- GULATI -
1 Does the Soccer Federation have any economic
2 interest in Major League Soccer -- withdrawn. It's a bad
3 question.
4 If Major League Soccer played -- paid the salaries
5 the plaintiffs are seeking here, or say they should have
6 been paid, would that have any economic impact on the
7 Federation one way or the other?
8 A No.
9 Q There was some discussion by, I think, two of the
10 players the Federation did have an interest in Major League
11 Soccer salaries being low because that would help the
12 Federation negotiate lower salaries for the National Team.
13 Does that have any bearing, basis in reality?
14 A No.
15 Q Why?
16 Do you have the question?
17 In other words, if the soccer players were making
18 more for Major League Soccer, the Federation would have to
19 pay them for -- to play for the National Team.
20 That follow in your mind?
21 A I've heard the opposite from players in negotiations
22 with National Team players.
23 Q What do you mean?
24 A Well, that we're not earning as much as we think we
25 should from MLS. You have to pay us more.
2170
- GULATI -
1 In countries in Europe, for example, a club will
2 pay a lot of money, more than we might pay, so players get
3 very little from the National Team.
4 Our players, and their representatives, have said
5 they're not making that much from your league in the United
6 States playing for the MLS teams.
7 So they need to get more from the Soccer
8 Federation.
9 Q Okay.
10 MR. ROBBINS: I did it. Thank you,
11 Mr. Gulati.
12 THE COURT: Mr. Kessler.
13 MR. ROBBINS: Where's my ovation?
14 (Laughter.)
15 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
16 BY MR. KESSLER
17 Q Good morning again, Mr. Gulati.
18 A Good afternoon.
19 Q Mr. Gulati, we went through a lot of player names and
20 made a lot of checkmarks on that board.
21 If any one of those players wanted to play
22 Division I soccer in the United States, what was their only
23 choice?
24 A At what point in time?
25 Q 1995 to date.
2171
- GULATI -
1 A Restricted to playing Division I soccer in the United
2 States, those players would have had to talk to MLS.
3 Q Okay.
4 So if you're a foreign player, if you're a dual
5 passport player, if you're an American player, whatever kind
6 of player you might want to be, if you want to play
7 Division I soccer in the United States, there are no
8 alternatives, right?
9 MR. CARDOZO: Objection.
10 THE COURT: Overruled.
11 You may answer.
12 A Stated the way you've outlined it, yes.
13 Q Okay.
14 And would you agree with me -- you said some of the
15 reasons why players may want to play in a place could be for
16 personal reasons, right?
17 A That's possible, sure.
18 Q Their family?
19 A That's possible.
20 Q Their children?
21 A Children are part of their family, yes.
22 Q Just a desire because they love the United States?
23 That's the country they want to live in?
24 A Or any other country they want to play in.
25 Q Okay.
2172
- GULATI -
1 But if a player -- if his preferences are in this
2 country -- and would you also agree with me -- let me
3 rephrase the question.
4 Would you also agree with me that most players
5 probably prefer to play Division I in the minor leagues?
6 That's a fair isn't it?
7 A If we're talking about the same country, in general
8 terms, that would be correct.
9 Q Right.
10 So, for example, the Boston Red Sox, you know, the
11 baseball team in Boston, I'm sure you've heard of it?
12 A I have.
13 Q They have some minor league teams, okay. You don't
14 think a lot of the Red Sox want to go play for the minor
15 league teams, do you?
16 They prefer to play for the Red Sox?
17 A That's correct.
18 Q Okay.
19 So if you want to play in this country and you want
20 to play in the major leagues, none of these alternatives are
21 available to satisfy that desire, right?
22 A If I want to drink a Coke and I'm going to drink the
23 Coke, then there's not an alternative to it.
24 But if I'm going to drink Pepsi or any number of
25 soft drinks, I mean, if you want --
2173
- GULATI -
1 If there's one league in the United States at the
2 time that is Division I that fits all of your criteria and a
3 player wants to play on only that league, then the answer is
4 yes.
5 Q Let's talk about Coke and Pepsi.
6 If I want to drink Coke and Pepsi, can I buy it in
7 the store here in the United States?
8 A Or anywhere else in the world.
9 Q Okay.
10 So if Pepsi was only sold outside of the United
11 States and Coke was only sold in this country, okay, you
12 think people would leave this country to go get some Pepsi?
13 A It -- if you're in the grocery store and you only want
14 to buy Coke, you buy the Pepsi -- no, I don't think you
15 would move for a 50 cent incentive to go overseas.
16 Q Okay. That's right.
17 And if people want to play Division I soccer in
18 this country, they're not going to move overseas to go play
19 it somewhere else, right?
20 A If I don't want to move, I'm not going to move. That's
21 what you're saying. If you say it like that, yes.
22 Q That's right.
23 And because you went through that because you were
24 offered more money to work on international soccer rather
25 than to keep working on US Soccer, and you testified that
2174
- GULATI -
1 you said I want to devote myself to US Soccer, I did what I
2 wanted to do, right?
3 MR. CARDOZO: Objection. That's the identical
4 question Mr. Kessler asked on direct.
5 THE COURT: I think it's getting a little
6 argumentative. Let's move it on.
7 MR. KESSLER: It's cross-examination, your
8 Honor, but I understand.
9 Q Let me go to this.
10 Out of all these people you remembered -- by the
11 way, your memory was excellent for this.
12 Do you remember you had trouble on my questions
13 remembering what happened, like, six years ago at a meeting?
14 A Mr. Kessler, I can recite the members of our National
15 Team that played the game last night. I can't recite if I
16 was at a training session with them seven years ago what one
17 of them might have said to me.
18 Q Now, but you can recite where some of these players
19 played, which leagues, seven or eight years ago, right?
20 A Or two or three or four or five years ago, yes, as I can
21 with -- let me finish, please -- as I can with members of
22 the US National Team.
23 Can I recite what they did at a particular training
24 session? The answer is no.
25 Q Okay.
2175
- GULATI -
1 A lot of these players you mentioned -- we're going
2 to go through all this tomorrow. We'll go through every one
3 of the players, okay, so we'll come back to this.
4 But a lot of the players you mentioned only play
5 overseas before they ever played in MLS, right?
6 That's fair?
7 A A number of them, that's true.
8 Q Okay.
9 So for all those players, they played overseas at
10 least seven years ago, at least six years ago?
11 A Keep going. It's the year 2000. We started in 1996.
12 Q MLS is in its fifth season, right?
13 A This is the fifth year.
14 Q Okay.
15 So for the players who only played international
16 before MLS, that had to be at least six seasons ago, right?
17 A That's not correct.
18 Q MLS has been playing five seasons?
19 A A player could have come in 1997. That included players
20 through 1998.
21 Q Okay.
22 You have no trouble remembering players, what
23 leagues they played in on this chart from 1993, 1994, 1995,
24 right?
25 That's some of your testimony here, right?
2176
- GULATI -
1 A Just did the checkmarks.
2 Q Okay.
3 Now, since MLS has started, okay, it's correct out
4 of all these players you mentioned, only eight players in
5 history, eight, have first played in MLS and then went to a
6 Division I league overseas, right? Eight?
7 A I'd have to think about it and go through this player
8 register. We can talk about that.
9 Q Think about it. Go through the player register. You're
10 so good with your memory about this.
11 MR. ROBBINS: Your Honor, I object to
12 Mr. Kessler --
13 THE COURT: Yes. You can ask the questions,
14 but let's leave the comments out.
15 Q Okay.
16 Find me more than eight.
17 A Redefine or define for me again so I understand.
18 Q Okay.
19 Players who didn't play overseas before, so I'm not
20 talking about, like, Mr. -- like a foreign players who you
21 got over on loan and then maybe went back overseas.
22 I'm talking about a player who didn't play overseas
23 before who first came to the MLS but then left MLS for a
24 Division I league.
25 Tell me if you can come up with more than eight out
2177
- GULATI -
1 of the 600 or so players who played in MLS.
2 A So any players who are playing -- I want to understand
3 the question very clearly.
4 Any player who was playing professional soccer
5 anywhere in the world, including the American players who
6 were playing abroad --
7 Q Mm-hmm.
8 A -- in 1995 don't count?
9 Q What I'm asking you to do, Mr. Gulati -- I don't want to
10 argue with you. Okay?
11 Just since you have such a good memory about this,
12 players who have left MLS to go play Division I abroad, who
13 are they?
14 A Players who have left --
15 MR. CARDOZO: Objection. That's a different
16 question.
17 THE COURT: Well, I --
18 MR. CARDOZO: I just want to make sure the
19 witness --
20 THE COURT: It is a different question.
21 Q Answer either one.
22 THE COURT: Well, no, put one question.
23 Q I'll give you one first. It doesn't matter. It doesn't
24 matter.
25 A Players who have left MLS to play Division I soccer --