page 3367 1 P R O C E E D I N G S 2 (LOBBY CONFERENCE AS FOLLOWS: 3 THE COURT: Hi. 4 MR. ROBBINS: Good morning, your Honor. 5 MR. CARDOZO: Good morning, your Honor. 6 MR. KESSLER: Good morning, your Honor. 7 MR. MEYER: Good morning. 8 THE COURT: Hi. I don't know if Karen 9 mentioned, one of our jurors is actively ill, sick to her 10 stomach, got sick in the car on the way in. 11 We've got a little nurse's office in the building, 12 and she's down there now lying down, I guess. So I don't 13 know whether she's had sort of a Pepto Bismol kind of thing 14 to see if it sort of settled her stomach, but it sounds like 15 this is not potential, it's actual. 16 MR. MEYER: Not something any of us want to 17 see. 18 THE COURT: So it's going to present a problem 19 with going forward. 20 My thought was that we might just hang out for an 21 hour or so and see if she got any better and we could at 22 least do part of the day rather than blowing up the entire 23 day, if that's fine with you. 24 MR. KESSLER: That's fine. 25 Can we assume it's going to be at least a half page 3368 1 hour? 2 THE COURT: She's been down there 20 minutes 3 or more now, a half hour maybe now. So I would say -- I 4 would give her almost until 10:30. Let's see what develops. 5 And if she's still that distressed, then I guess we'll just 6 have to wash out the day. 7 MR. CARDOZO: I agree. 8 MR. ROBBINS: That's fine. 9 MR. KESSLER: That seems a reasonable way to 10 proceed. 11 MR. MEYER: We'll be in the cafeteria if you 12 need to find us. 13 THE COURT: Yes. 14 MR. CARDOZO: Okay, thank you. 15 THE COURT: So we'll see you back here at 16 10:30. 17 MR. KESSLER: Thank you, your Honor. 18 END OF LOBBY CONFERENCE.) 19 (Recess.) 20 (Whereupon, the jury entered the courtroom.) 21 THE CLERK: Court is now in session. The 22 Honorable George A. O'Toole presiding. 23 Iain Fraser, et al, versus Major League Soccer, et 24 al. Civil Action 97-10342. 25 Would counsel please identify themselves for the page 3369 1 record. 2 MR. KESSLER: Good morning, your Honor. 3 MR. CARDOZO: Good morning, your Honor. 4 THE COURT: We can -- we know who they are. 5 Most of them, anyway. 6 (Laughter.) 7 MR. KESSLER: May I proceed, your Honor? 8 THE COURT: Mr. Kessler, please. 9 MR. KESSLER: Thank you, your Honor. 10 Your Honor, plaintiffs call as the next witness 11 Mr. Alan Rothenberg. 12 ALAN I. ROTHENBERG, sworn 13 THE CLERK: Please be seated. 14 State your name for the record and spell your last 15 name, please. 16 THE WITNESS: Alan I Rothenberg, 17 R-O-T-H-E-N-B-E-R-G. 18 DIRECT EXAMINATION 19 BY MR. KESSLER 20 Q Good morning, Mr. Rothenberg. 21 A I hope so. 22 Q Mr. Rothenberg, I'd like to cover some background to 23 start. I show you a copy of Plaintiffs' Exhibit 785, which 24 is already in evidence. 25 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, if I may approach page 3370 1 the witness? 2 THE COURT: All right. 3 MR. KESSLER: Can you display that, please, 4 Gary. 5 Q Mr. Rothenberg, this is a chart in evidence discussing 6 some of your different functions and responsibilities, and 7 I'd like to go over it with you. 8 Let's start, Mr. Rothenberg, with MLS, Major League 9 Soccer. 10 It's correct that you were the founder of Major 11 League Soccer? 12 A Yes. 13 Q And you have the title as chairman of Major League 14 Soccer? 15 A Initially, yes. 16 Q Okay. 17 And you are an investor in Major League Soccer, 18 correct? 19 A Yes. 20 Q And, Mr. Rothenberg, do you currently have an investment 21 interest in Major League Soccer? 22 A Yes. 23 Q Okay. 24 What percentage interest do you have? 25 A Approximately 4 percent. page 3371 1 Q Four percent? 2 A It's a C unit in the league. 3 Q Now, did you pay any money to get that interest in Major 4 League Soccer? 5 A Yes. 6 Q Okay. 7 How much did you pay? 8 A It was divided -- the initial payment was $100,000, and 9 over the past five years, I've probably put in several 10 hundred thousand dollars more as more capital had to be put 11 in. 12 Q And for that you own 4 percent of the entire league? 13 A Yes, but it was in two parts in the sense that I was 14 granted a certain equity position based on what's called 15 sweat equity, working for it, and the other part was what I 16 paid for but the aggregate is 4 percent, a little under 17 4 percent. 18 Q You were given 3 percent, I think, for the work you did 19 for the league; is that correct? 20 A And also I entered into an agreement to be a consultant, 21 and it was to do ongoing work for the league, yes. 22 Q And as part of your work starting up the league, being a 23 consultant, you were given 3 percent? 24 A I think that's right. And then, as I said, I also 25 invested on top of that and just because there's been page 3372 1 changes in ownership over the period of time, I think my 2 equity interest now is somewhat closer to 4 percent, and I 3 put in several hundred thousand dollars of additional money. 4 Q And when you were consultant to the league in addition 5 to getting, as you said, 3 percent sweat equity, you also 6 were paid salary as well, correct? 7 A I received a fee for a three-year period. 8 Q You received a significant compensation for that, 9 correct? 10 A I received a fee. 11 Q You didn't think it was significant? 12 A I worked hard for it. I think I earned it. I can't put 13 a label on it. It was decreasing every year. That's what 14 the contract called for. 15 Q Now, Major League Soccer is a for-profit corporation, 16 right? 17 A It's organized as a for-profit corporation. There 18 haven't been any profits, and there are none in sight. 19 Q It's not a nonprofit? 20 A It's not organized to be a nonprofit organization. 21 Q It's not a charitable organization, something like that, 22 right? 23 A No, sir. 24 Q Okay. 25 And, in fact, the investors who were brought into page 3373 1 Major League Soccer, you helped bring in those investors; is 2 that fair? 3 A Yes. 4 Q Okay. 5 And those investors, when you gave the materials, 6 were told that the hope was that they would get a nice 7 return on their investment, right? 8 A Yes, that was the hope. 9 Q Okay. 10 And MLPS, you were the president of MLPS; is that 11 correct? 12 A I believe so. Frankly, didn't pay that much attention 13 to the titles. We organized that as a subsidiary of the 14 World Cup Organizing Committee, and I believe I held that 15 title but -- 16 Q Yes. 17 MLPS was a subsidiary of WCOC and -- 18 A Well -- 19 Q Right? 20 A Well, World Cup USA '94, Inc., is the corporate name. 21 Is that what we're abbreviating as "WCOC"? 22 Q Mm-hmm. 23 A Okay, then WCOC. 24 Q Okay. 25 And with respect to MLPS, it was set up by the page 3374 1 World Cup Organizing Committee, World Cup 1994, to develop 2 the plan and the business for a Division I professional 3 soccer league, right? 4 A Yes. 5 Q Okay. 6 And, in fact, MLPS initially signed player 7 contracts and then turned over that business to MLS when it 8 was formed, correct? 9 A I believe that -- yes, we would have signed player 10 contracts before -- 11 We had a lot of different agreements that were 12 signed by MLPS before MLS, the LLC, assumed all the 13 liabilities. 14 Q In fact, MLS assumed the liabilities and assets of MLPS? 15 A Yes. 16 Q You're an attorney, are you not, Mr. Rothenberg? 17 A Yes. 18 Q So you understand when I say MLS was the successor to 19 MLPS; is that fair? 20 A For these purposes, that's fine, yes. 21 Q Okay. 22 Now, as I said, you're an attorney. You're a 23 partner in the law firm of Latham~&~Watkins? 24 A Yes. 25 Q Okay. page 3375 1 And how long have you been a partner at 2 Latham~&~Watkins? 3 A I joined that firm in the summer of 1990. 4 Q Okay. 5 And it's correct, isn't it, that Latham~&~Watkins 6 was hired as legal counsel to the WCOC? 7 A It performed legal services for the WCOC. It was not 8 the exclusive law firm. 9 Q It was paid for those legal services, correct? 10 A It was paid in part. And, actually, the first 11 $300,000 of legal fees was donated because of the nonprofit 12 nature of the WCOC, and then after that it was billed at 13 normal rates, less a 10 percent courtesy discount given to 14 nonprofits. 15 Q Okay. 16 And so after that, your law firm billed the WCOC 17 more than a million dollars, right? 18 A Over the course of the next several years, yes. 19 Q Okay. 20 And Latham~&~Watkins was also legal counsel to 21 United States Soccer Federation, right? 22 A From time to time, but it was not the same kind of 23 relationship. It was just on a few isolated special 24 projects. 25 Q Okay. page 3376 1 And you were from 1990 to 1998 president of the 2 United States Soccer Federation, right? 3 A Yes, yes, sir. 4 Q Okay. 5 And I take it it was at your recommendation that 6 USSF hire Latham & Watkins, your law firm, to work for the 7 USSF? 8 A Probably, but it started back then. I don't remember. 9 Q Oh. 10 A There's one -- it's a minor mistake, but it's a mistake 11 on there. You got under USSF chairman of the Board. I 12 haven't been that. That, to my knowledge, is no title at 13 all for the USSF. 14 Q Just president? 15 A President from 1990 to 1998, yes. 16 Q And with respect to Latham~&~Watkins, they didn't work 17 for USSF before you were president, right, of USSF? 18 A I don't believe -- I don't believe so, no. 19 Q Okay. 20 Now, Latham & Watkins was also legal counsel to 21 MLPS; is that correct? 22 A Yes. 23 Q Okay. 24 And Latham & Watkins was also legal counsel to 25 Major League Soccer, right -- page 3377 1 A Yes. 2 Q -- on some matters? 3 And MLPS and Major League Soccer paid legal fees to 4 Latham & Watkins, right? 5 A Yes, umm -- I know MLS did. I'm not sure whether MLPS 6 did, but -- because, as you know, it sort of flowed from 7 World Cup to MLPS and ultimately to MLS but whatever 8 services they performed in that aspect they were paid for. 9 Q Okay. 10 And Latham~&~Watkins was also counsel to the 11 Olympic Soccer Team when you were involved with the Olympic 12 Soccer Team, right? 13 A Are you talking about the 1984 Olympics? 14 Q Yes. 15 A They were counsel in the 1984 Olympics, but I was not a 16 part of Latham~&~Watkins until that time. I didn't join 17 Latham~&~Watkins until 1990. 18 Q So sometime after the Olympics, you joined 19 Latham~&~Watkins? 20 A Yes, six years later. 21 Q Let me show you a copy of Plaintiffs' Exhibit 785A. 22 Mr. Rothenberg, this was the original version of 23 this chalk, and we're waiting to get a foundation on some of 24 these things. 25 MR. KESSLER: I'd now like to move this page 3378 1 version of the chart in since we established the other 2 pieces of it. 3 MR. CARDOZO: I believe Mr. Rothenberg's last 4 answer indicates there's one aspect of this chart to be 5 incorrect, your Honor. 6 THE COURT: The chairman of the Board of USSF? 7 MR. CARDOZO: No. This is a new version of 8 this document that they just handed to Mr. Rothenberg. 9 THE COURT: Right. 10 MR. CARDOZO: No, in addition to that, your 11 Honor. 12 THE COURT: In addition to that? 13 MR. CARDOZO: With respect to the soccer -- 14 the Olympic Soccer Team reference. 15 MR. KESSLER: I believe it's accurate, your 16 Honor. They were legal counsel to the soccer team. 17 MR. CARDOZO: Your Honor, I'd be happy to 18 approach, if you think it's appropriate. 19 THE COURT: Well, I think he's explained the 20 error. It's ambiguous. If you want to explain it again so 21 it's clear when it's up there -- otherwise, I think it can 22 be used. 23 MR. CARDOZO: Okay. 24 MR. KESSLER: Then I offer Plaintiffs' 25 Exhibit 785A. page 3379 1 THE CLERK: Entered as Plaintiffs' 2 Exhibit 785A. 3 (Plaintiffs' Exhibit No. 785A received in 4 evidence.) 5 Q Okay. 6 And if we can take a look now on this chart now-- 7 actually, Mr. Rothenberg, we don't have this on the chart, 8 but you also were -- had a role at the United States -- USSF 9 Foundation; is that correct? 10 A Yes. 11 Q You were a member of the Board of Directors of the USSF 12 Foundation as well? 13 A Yes. 14 Q Could have added that box as well. 15 Let me ask you a little bit about the WCOC, 16 Mr. Rothenberg. 17 The WCOC was a nonprofit organization, right? 18 A Was and still is. 19 Q Still in existence? 20 A Yes. 21 Q Okay. 22 And the WCOC was formed by the United States Soccer 23 Federation; is that fair? 24 A The predecessor to WCOC was formed by the United States 25 Soccer Federation, that's correct. page 3380 1 Q Okay. 2 And then the predecessor transferred its assets to 3 the new -- what we're calling WCOC? 4 A Yes. 5 Q Okay. 6 A That was done -- the first step, the creation of the 7 predecessor, was done before I was elected president of the 8 United States Soccer Federation. The transfer took place 9 after I was elected. 10 Q And, in fact, Mr. Rothenberg, the transfer from the 11 original World Cup Organizing Committee to the new WCOC was 12 done at the request of FIFA; is that correct? 13 A Not really. 14 Q Not really? Okay. 15 Let me show you a copy of Defendants' Exhibit 1298. 16 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, I don't believe 17 there's any objection to this document. I move it into 18 evidence. 19 MR. CARDOZO: No objection, your Honor. 20 THE COURT: All right. 21 THE CLERK: Marked and entered as Defendants' 22 Exhibit 1298. 23 (Defendants' Exhibit No. 1298 received in 24 evidence.) 25 Q You'll see, Mr. Rothenberg, this was a meeting of the page 3381 1 Board of Directors of the World Cup '94 Organizing Committee 2 that was held on November 13, 1990; do you see that? 3 A Yes. 4 Q Okay. 5 And you were present at the meeting; is that 6 correct? 7 A Yes. 8 Q Okay. 9 And if you take this organization, World Cup '94 10 Organizing Committee, Inc., that was the predecessor 11 organization, correct? 12 A Yes. 13 Q And if you take a look at the second page -- 14 A Yes, I have looked at it and I was wrong. I didn't 15 remember that there was a letter from Mr. Blatter saying 16 that that would be the case. 17 Q Okay. 18 So Mr. Blatter, he was the general secretary of 19 FIFA; is that correct? 20 A Yes. 21 Q And Mr. Blatter said he would -- FIFA would only 22 contract with respect to the 1995 World Cup with a new 23 corporation formed with a board of directors consisting of 24 Messrs. Blatter, Rothenberg and Cale; is that correct? 25 A Yes, he said '94. You said '95, but, yes, that's what page 3382 1 he said. 2 Q Okay. 3 Now, why did FIFA insist on this? 4 A When I was elected president of the United States Soccer 5 Federation, it was assumed by everybody, I would think, that 6 I was also going to become the chairman of the World Cup 7 Organizing Committee. 8 And, in fact, Mr. Fricker, my predecessor, the man 9 that I defeated in election for the US Soccer Federation 10 position, held both of those positions, president of United 11 States Soccer Federation and chairman or president of the 12 Organizing Committee. 13 Notwithstanding my election in August of 1990, 14 Mr. Fricker continued to refuse until this time to turn over 15 the running of the World Cup Organizing Committee to me, 16 which upset a lot of people, including FIFA, because that 17 wasn't supposed to be the way things go. The president of 18 the association also was head of the Organizing Committee. 19 After three months of Mr. Fricker being 20 recalcitrant, FIFA finally said we got to move on, just form 21 a new company, and we'll contract with them, at which point, 22 as you can see, Mr. Fricker then finally said, okay, I'll do 23 it. 24 Q So this new WOrld Cup that was formed, WCOC, was 25 specifically formed so that you could be the head of the page 3383 1 World Cup of the new committee, right? 2 A No, it was formed so they could get on with organizing 3 the World Cup. Nothing was happening except a lot of 4 corporate in fighting, which obviously jeopardized 5 preparation for this huge event, and FIFA, who owns -- bless 6 you. 7 It's FIFA's event, it's not ours. FIFA said, Get 8 on with it. This is the way we do business. Let's go. 9 Q But I thought you just testified that FIFA's 10 understanding was the president of the USSF should be the 11 head of the World Cup Organizing Committee, right? 12 A Yes. 13 Understand how FIFA works. They have -- 14 Q Could I just get an answer -- 15 A But I can't answer without explaining it. 16 Q Well, let's -- 17 Can I first get an answer, did FIFA state that the 18 president of the USSF should be the head of the World Cup 19 Organizing Committee? 20 A I think FIFA expected that. I don't know whether they 21 stated that, but that's the way they do business, always. 22 Q That's the way they do business, okay? 23 A Is that they do business with their national 24 association, which is what the USSF was. 25 When they gave the World Cup, it was to the USSF. page 3384 1 It wasn't to an Organizing Committee. It was the USSF who 2 chose to create a separate company. 3 But as far as FIFA was concerned, they deal with 4 their members. Their members are the national associations 5 and so as far as they're concerned, when you have a new 6 president of the national association, that person then is 7 the person that they have to deal with in running their huge 8 event. 9 Q So -- 10 A So it was the Federation that created -- again, before I 11 was around -- this separate entity, and FIFA didn't want 12 that in the way. 13 Q Okay. 14 So FIFA's view is they're dealing with the USSF. 15 They wanted the USSF to make sure it was in charge of 16 running the World Cup through this separate organization, 17 right? 18 A Yes. 19 Q Okay. 20 So it's fair to say that the USSF was expected to 21 assert control over this World Cup Organizing Committee, 22 right? 23 That was what FIFA expected? 24 A I think FIFA always looks to their national association 25 to accomplish the task. page 3385 1 Q Okay. 2 And then this World Cup Organizing Committee, which 3 USSF was asserting control over, it was the one that created 4 MLPS as a subsidiary to develop a Division I league, right? 5 A Ultimately, yes. 6 Q Okay. 7 And then the USSF, it then made a decision about 8 whether there would be one Division I league or multiple 9 Division I leagues, right? 10 A Ultimately, that's what occurred, yes. 11 Q Okay. 12 And when it was making that decision, it was making 13 it where one of the applicants was a subsidiary of an 14 organization that USSF had set up and was responsible for, 15 right? 16 A That's the chain of events, yes. USSF set up the World 17 Cup Organizing Committee. The World Cup Organizing 18 Committee set up MLPS, and that's the chain. 19 Q And that was supposed to be a neutral decision-making 20 process, right? 21 A It was supposed to be a decision-making process on what 22 was in the best interest of soccer. 23 Q Right. 24 It wasn't supposed to be what was in the best 25 interest of its subsidiary or the best interest of its page 3386 1 chairman or the best interests -- it was the best interests 2 of soccer, as you understand? 3 A Absolutely. 4 Q Now, moving on to this, it's correct, isn't it, that 5 when this new organization was formed, that Mr. des~Bordes 6 specifically insisted that if we're going to have a new 7 corporation, that the Certificate of Incorporation must 8 provide that any surplus from the World Cup would be 9 delivered to the United States Soccer Federation; is that 10 correct? 11 A At that time, that's what was in the minutes, yes. 12 Q And, in fact, you gave assurances -- Messrs. Rothenberg 13 and Cale gave assurances that that's how the money would be 14 used, correct? 15 A At that time, correct. 16 Q Okay. 17 And, in fact, Mr. des~Bordes then told -- if you 18 look at the next page -- told that to Mr. Fricker, that the 19 new corporation would have language ensuring that the 20 surplus would belong to the Federation. 21 That's correct, isn't it? 22 A Yes. 23 Q And there was some concerns expressed at that time that 24 the surplus might be diverted for other purposes, right? 25 That's why these assurances were given? page 3387 1 A Actually, no reason was stated. 2 Q Well, why was it so important to give assurances to 3 Mr. des Bordes and Mr. Fricker at this time that this 4 surplus would only go to the Federation and not for some 5 other purpose? 6 A I guess you got to ask Mr. des Bordes or Mr. Fricker -- 7 MR. ROBBINS: When I stand up, I'm probably 8 going to say something. 9 I object to the question. 10 THE WITNESS: I'm sorry. 11 THE COURT: Overruled. I'll permit the 12 question. Go ahead. 13 A I don't recall anything being stated at all at the time 14 as to what their concern was. 15 Q So your testimony is you gave these assurances that this 16 would happen without having any understanding of why you 17 were asked for the assurances? 18 A I had a suspicion, but I don't recall them stating 19 anything, and that's what you asked me. 20 Q Okay. 21 What was your suspicion? 22 A I was somebody that was brand new to the Soccer 23 Federation. I was elected as a "outsider" in August. This 24 was the old guard, and they were tremendously, as I say, 25 suspicious of I don't know what, my motives or whatever, and page 3388 1 that's the way they were acting. 2 They never said anything. I don't know what, if 3 anything, was on their mind. Nothing bad was on my mind 4 other than getting the job done. 5 So it was easy to give an assurance because I never 6 intended to do anything except turn the surplus over to the 7 Soccer Federation, which ultimately decided that they wanted 8 to create a foundation. 9 Q Now, in fact, WCOC ended up advancing $5 million to 10 Major League Soccer as a loan, correct? 11 A The ultimate amount was 5 million, yes. 12 Q In fact, with interest at the end, it was significantly 13 above $5 million, right? 14 A It was 5 million plus interest, yes. 15 Q Okay. 16 And that was one of the things that Mr. des~Bordes 17 was concerned about initially, wasn't it? 18 A He never said that. I don't think there was any 19 discussion about that at all. 20 At that time, no. 21 Q Okay. 22 Later on, Mr. des Bordes voted against loaning that 23 money, right? 24 A Later on, he did. But at this time, there was no 25 thought of this. There was no discussion of it. page 3389 1 There was simply the understanding by everybody 2 that part of the obligation of the Federation and the World 3 Cup Organizing Committee was to create a professional first 4 division outdoor soccer league, but I don't know that it was 5 discussed at that time. 6 Q Well, you were already on November 13, 1990, when we 7 looked at this meeting, you were already working on plans 8 for a Division I professional league, right? 9 A I was not working on any plans. I had appointed a 10 committee right after I was elected to look into how to 11 develop professional soccer at the highest level in this 12 country because it was clear to me when I got elected that 13 was one of the big things that was bothering the membership 14 because nothing concrete had been done. 15 So I appointed a committee just to look into how we 16 go about doing it. That was it. It was just a study 17 committee to try to figure things out. 18 Q You were actively working on it yourself, weren't you, 19 at that time? 20 A Personally? 21 Q Yes. 22 A Absolutely not. 23 Q Absolutely not, okay. 24 A I was -- I was with the committee -- 25 Q Mm-hmm. page 3390 1 A -- and looking into the issues, but for me personally, 2 never. 3 Q Mm-hmm. 4 Do you recall the fact that at this time, 5 November/December 1990, you personally were actively working 6 with outside counsel on the structure of the Division I 7 league? 8 A We were probing ideas. Nobody was working on anything 9 other than let's get some ideas, how can we do this, what 10 will work, what's the history been, why has it been such a 11 problem over the years to get professional soccer accepted 12 in this country. 13 And I, as the president of the Federation and ex 14 officio member of all committees, was probing everything, 15 pushing everything, but I wasn't doing -- 16 I had no plan in mind. I was trying to figure out 17 what should be done. 18 Q You were working -- your law firm, Latham~&~Watkins, was 19 working with the committee, the professional outdoor soccer 20 league committee, on different structures of a league in 21 December of 1990, right? 22 A They were asked some legal questions because as this 23 committee was working, we were kicking around ideas. So 24 they and another law firm were asked to give us some 25 guidance, some input on whether certain ideas that we were page 3391 1 talking about were lawful. 2 Q And the ideas were actually your ideas, right? 3 It was your idea at the time, right? 4 A I had an idea, yes, but I wasn't the only one because 5 there were other people that had other ideas, had similar 6 ideas. 7 Q Mr. Rothenberg, is it fair to say that you were 8 the first one who raised the idea of structuring the league 9 the way it would be structured? 10 A I -- I wish I could say for sure. I know I believed 11 that a single entity was the right way to run a league and 12 that it was absolutely lawful, and I put that on the table, 13 but I -- 14 I know at least one other person had a similar 15 view, and it's somebody that came to that view without 16 talking to me. So I don't remember who else said anything. 17 Q Whether you were the first or the second, it is true 18 that by November and December of 1990, you were actively 19 reviewing this issue with your outside counsel about 20 developing a Division I league, right? 21 A Not the way you put it, no. We were probing for ideas. 22 We were trying to figure out what, if anything, could be 23 done. 24 There was, A, no plan; and, B, at the end of that 25 that committee's work, the committee evaporated. They made page 3392 1 no report. They made no recommendation. Everybody went on 2 to other business. 3 And then there was some follow-up by other people 4 based on what had come out of that committee. 5 Q You were working with Hank Steinbrecher, right, back 6 in -- in December of 1990? 7 A The committee had about 17 or 18 people, as I recall. I 8 assume Hank would have been one of them, you know, as the 9 general secretary of the Federation which he had become 10 about a month before that. 11 He sits in on any committee meeting that he can get 12 to, so he probably was involved. And, as far as I say, 16, 13 17, 18 other people. I just tried to get people from all 14 parts of soccer, particularly people who had some 15 professional experience, either pro league, I had agents, I 16 had promoters. Hank had just come from Gatorade where he 17 was a sports marketing guy. 18 Just an amalgamation of people sharing ideas. 19 Q But you were working with a small subcommittee of about 20 five people with you in this, is that fair, even though 21 there may have been a big committee that was appointed? 22 A My recollection is that we broke out in a few different 23 small committees to pursue different subject matters, and 24 it's possible that I was on one of them. 25 I don't really remember that. page 3393 1 Q Let me show you a copy of Plaintiffs' Exhibit 128. 2 MR. KESSLER: I don't intend to offer this, 3 your Honor, but I want to use it to refresh the witness's 4 recollection about the subcommittee. 5 MR. CARDOZO: Your Honor, I object. Can we 6 approach? 7 THE COURT: All right. 8 (SIDEBAR CONFERENCE AS FOLLOWS: 9 MR. CARDOZO: This is a letter which we claim 10 privilege and an inadvertent waiver. It was the subject of 11 a pretrial motion before you, and Mr. Kessler had contended 12 there was a waiver of the privilege and therefore he should 13 be directed to answer the questions, and you had denied his 14 motion. 15 We still submit that it's a privileged document. I 16 knew that Mr. Kessler was reading from this, and I was 17 reluctant to interrupt his examination, but I really think 18 we've gone as far as -- we've gone farther than is 19 appropriate, your Honor. 20 This is a privileged document. It's a privileged 21 document on its face. We established in discovery that we 22 think that a former employee of the World Cup had somehow 23 got ahold of this document and turned it over. I think the 24 question is -- it's a privileged document. 25 MR. KESSLER: I don't believe there's any page 3394 1 privilege with regard to this document. It's been long 2 since waived. We briefed that extensively. It was 3 circulated to the entire National Team back in '92 without 4 any objection from MLS, and their predecessors, USSF, or the 5 World Cup Organizing Committee at that time. 6 We put in an affidavit of Mr. Levinstein about how 7 he got it and how it was circulated, and it was discussed 8 why the agents had this. 9 But, in any event, your Honor, I'm not going to 10 offer the document. What I want to do is ask him about 11 these committee members who were working on the Division I 12 league at this time. That's my purpose of showing it to 13 him. 14 I don't intend, for example, even to ask about the 15 body of it because, frankly, your Honor, it goes to the 16 issues I think you've taken out of case about the single 17 entity. So I have no intention of offering or asking about 18 that. 19 MR. CARDOZO: But the point is he has the 20 substance of a document he should not have. 21 We took a deposition of a witness -- 22 MR. ROBBINS: Shelly Azoff. 23 MR. CARDOZO: -- Shelly Azoff who said she 24 thought she got it because she had taken it from the offices 25 of the USSF. page 3395 1 So that there's a factual issue, at best, but we 2 assert the privilege, and I think until and unless you're 3 going to offer it, then I don't see how you can overrule the 4 privilege. 5 I think it's inappropriate for the witness to be 6 questioned about it off of this document. 7 MR. KESSLER: Just so your Honor knows, 8 Ms. Azoff actually testified that she was given the document 9 by staff and that no restrictions were put on her 10 distribution. 11 That is her sworn testimony. 12 MR. ROBBINS: That's not true. That's just 13 not accurate, Jeffrey. I was there, and I took her 14 deposition. That's not accurate. 15 MR. KESSLER: I believe that is accurate. 16 THE COURT: All right. All right. 17 Was this the subject of the earlier -- 18 MR. CARDOZO: Yes. 19 MR. KESSLER: Your Honor, what the subject of 20 your ruling was was we wanted to ask additional questions 21 about this from witnesses about -- that there was a general 22 waiver, and your Honor did not permit us to ask additional 23 questions. 24 There was no motion ever made either asking for the 25 return of this document or that we otherwise couldn't use page 3396 1 this document. The question was whether this document was 2 the basis to -- 3 THE COURT: Well, if the only question you're 4 going to ask is whether seeing the distribution list leads 5 him to recall a committee which he doesn't recall -- 6 MR. KESSLER: That's what I'm trying to do, 7 your Honor. 8 THE COURT: -- that's harmless. But that 9 doesn't touch the substance of the -- 10 MR. CARDOZO: That's the only question? 11 MR. KESSLER: Yes, that's all I'm trying to 12 do. 13 MR. CARDOZO: Sometimes when the Judge makes a 14 ruling, there's a misunderstanding, so I want to make sure 15 that is the only question you're asking, Mr. Kessler. 16 MR. KESSLER: I'm going to ask only about 17 that. I might ask about the date. I'm not asking anything 18 about the substance of this document or these paragraphs. 19 I'm not asking anything about -- 20 THE JUROR: Excuse me, she has to get out of 21 here. 22 THE COURT: Go ahead, take her out. 23 MR. KESSLER: What I would simply be doing, 24 your Honor, is asking about at this time, which is why I 25 mentioned the date, does this refresh your recollection that page 3397 1 this was the subcommittee and what was that subcommittee 2 doing, and I'm going to ask questions about the 3 subcommittee. 4 THE COURT: All right. For that limited 5 purpose. 6 But I think we're going to have -- 7 MR. ROBBINS: We're going to stop for the day 8 anyway. She's not coming back. 9 END OF SIDEBAR CONFERENCE.) 10 THE COURT: We'll take a recess, jurors. 11 (Whereupon, the jury left the courtroom.) 12 (Proceedings adjourned.) 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25